6 ms·
I would like to see a fantasy setting that really grapples with the seemingly bizarre military/population dynamics of Elves. The must be incredibly battle harde
by bee_rider 3y ago
I would like to see a fantasy setting that really grapples with the seemingly bizarre military/population dynamics of Elves. The must be incredibly battle hardened and/or traumatized.
- Deprecate9151 3y agoHave you read, or at least read about, The Silmarillion? Your assumption about their trauma is very correct.
- thom 3y agoNot what you're asking for, but an interesting angle is R Scott Bakker's Second Apocalypse books. He has a race called the Cûnuroi who are approximately Elves, and they accept immortality in a deal with a race of depraved starfaring bio-engineers, except it renders them sterile. They go quite mad over the years, and require increasing levels of violence to feel anything at all.
- climb_stealth 3y agoOoo, that sounds quite interesting. Which book is a good starting point for getting into it? Just asking because I don't want to look too closely and see spoilers. Thanks!
- thom 3y agoThe first book is The Darkness That Comes Before, and it's the beginning of two trilogies (the second of which ends up with four books...) The first three books are as good as anything in the genre. They're quite dark, but have very deep metaphysics, the stakes are incredibly high, and the central character is fascinating. I would tempt you more but I'm trying not to spoil anything. The books do go downhill (as does the author's mental health, I believe). But they are definitely worth knowing.
- beaumayns 3y ago+1 to these books - they have some really interesting worldbuilding. Even the later books have some good parts (quite a good Moria-like sequence, some more exposition on the current state of the insane remnants of Cunuroi society), but they definitely do lose the plot a bit. I'm still not sure myself what really happened in the end.
- thom 3y agoYeah it’s very interesting meeting the youngest Elf. But what happened at the end is pretty clear, I thought, and the series is called the Second Apocalypse after all.
- climb_stealth 3y agoThank you, much appreciated! I have noted them down to start next after my current series. And yep, I'm quite at home with fairly dark books.
- jandrese 3y agoThey turn into Cenobites?
- thom 3y agoThey’re certainly given immortality by cenobites, and they do end up serving them to some extent.
- arethuza 3y agoThere are elves in the Laundry Files universe - and they are not nice elves, as Stross says in notes on the first novel to feature them: "in the Laundry universe, elves are nazis with pointy ears" They aren't immortal although they do deploy WMD levels of magic. http://www.antipope.org/charlie/blog-static/2017/06/crib-sheet-the-nightmare-stack.html http://www.antipope.org/charlie/blog-static/2017/06/crib-she...
- bee_rider 3y agoYeah, I’m thinking of more like hard military fantasy than sci-fi body horror. I want to see elves that have to come to terms with the fact that will always be fighting wars outnumbered hundreds to one, attempting to make up for that gap by using their special characteristics. I don’t want to see them corrupted to debauchery by boredom, but to grim pragmatism by desperation. With wizards-engineers spending hundreds of years on a project, I want to see bizarre siege weapons. Indirect fire guided by giant eagles. The other species should have to pull trench warfare into the fantasy era to reasonably do battle. I think this was put vaguely into the back of my head by the Artemis Fowl books when I was a kid, I thought they had interesting vibes, but of course they were YA novels, and IMO this would be better set in a fantasy era.
- johngossman 3y agoI’ve been thinking about that too. I guess I want the equivalent of a hard scifi that goes into Elvish biology, culture, economics. The population has been declining for millennia, so a huge construction industry recession, presumably overall deflation, shrinking GDP. They don’t age and they have very few children, so presumably no school system, no retirement homes. It’s not clear if Elves get sick, so medicine probably entirely a military function. I’m pretty sure Elves heal, perhaps even regrow limbs, otherwise just random accidents and war wounds would leave a lot of crippled, blind Elves, but Tolkien seems to they all look youthful, clear skin, no obvious wounds. Technology is static, perhaps even going backwards since the First Age, so no startups, no banking. Do Elves have money? So many questions
- huytersd 3y agoIs there a mention of any elvish kids at all in all of his work?
- pdonis 3y agoNo elves are portrayed during their actual childhood, but elvish geneaologies are clearly stated. For example, Celebrian, the wife of Elrond and mother of Elladan, Elrohir, and Arwen, is the daughter of Celeborn and Galadriel.
- jltsiren 3y agoIncidentally, Tolkien portrayed many half-elves during their childhood. Elwing, Elured, and Elurin were young children when the sons of Fëanor destroyed Doriath. Eärendil fled the destruction of Gondolin as a young child. And Elrond and Elros were young children when the remaining sons of Fëanor destroyed the Havens of Sirion. Bad luck runs in the family, or something.
- pdonis 3y ago> Tolkien portrayed many half-elves during their childhood. Yes, unfortunately we don't have more detailed portrayals since those passages in The Silmarillion are very brief.
- rossdavidh 3y agoI suppose there are several explanations: 1) they are the ones who remained in Middle-Earth, while others (e.g. Elrond's wife) departed west over the Sea to get away from the violence of Middle-Earth 2) they are ageless, and seem to have a very high adult:child ratio and essentially no elderly, so nearly the entire population is "military age" Taken together, this could plausibly give not much under 50% able to serve in the military in extremis. Relative to Hobbits, Orcs, or Dwarves, the Elves are biologically far more different than Men.
- tdba 3y agoOrcs are elves who were corrupted and mutilated by Morgoth, so hypothetically elves and orcs might have more shared biology. Hobbits are probably an offshoot or variant of men. Elves, dwarves and men all had separate "awakenings" so they don't have any shared ancestry at all. However, earlier races of men (and especially Numenoreans) were more similar to elves, being larger, wiser and having longer lifespans.
- labster 3y agoThe thing about orcs being corrupted elves isn’t canon, as Tolkien himself never settled on a theory for the origins of orcs. I’m personally against this theory because an elf put under extreme duress will likely just pop back to the Halls of Mandos; when orcs were first bred the way from the West was still open.
- tdba 3y agoFair, I was just stating the commonly accepted origin. Personally, I think the origin of orcs remaining shadowy and mysterious with numerous contradictory accounts is the best canon. After all, Morgoth works secretly to sow confusion and dissent.
- rossdavidh 3y agoArguably, Tolkien did say (in the Silmarillion) that orcs were corrupted elves, and then also said (in Unfinished Tales) that orcs were corrupted Wose. Then he also said that Saruman made orcs from corrupted Men. Most plausibly, since there are numerous cases of different groups of orcs looking at least as different from one another as, say, Hobbits and Men and Wose and Dwarves, "orc" is just a term for any humanoid whose form has been corrupted by a Dark Lord.
- saalweachter 3y agoIt depends on what your conception of elvish immortality is. For instance, you could postulate that the defining feature of elves is that they do not change, mentally as well as physically, once they reach maturity. Their personality crystallizes, as firmly as their biology, and whatever happens to them over the millennia they live, they will remain themselves. This makes them very different than you and I, but IMO it's also very compatible with the way elves are presented in Tolkien.
- ikurei 3y agoThe Non-Men from Prince of Nothing are more or less elf-equivalent, and I thought it gives a much darker and more interesting interpretation on the impact that immortality and tremendous historic loss can have on such a race. However, I reckon the only reason these dynamics seem bizarre is that they would be very bizarre for humans, but elves are definitely not humans; their nature could potentially be very different, especially in LOTR where they have an infinite lifespan and a very different creation than other peoples. Elves are basically aliens, however human-like they look. Would it be strange to find such dynamics in an alien species of octopus-shaped creatures that communicate through electromagnetic fields?