6 ms·
This is so strange, this is exactly how you don't handle problems like this. Write a blog post, explain what happened, explain who's affected and to what exten
by crazygringo 3y ago
This is so strange, this is exactly how you don't handle problems like this.
Write a blog post, explain what happened, explain who's affected and to what extent, explain if it can be fixed and what you're doing, and explain what you'll do to make sure it doesn't happen again.
Putting out a supposed hidden fix in the Drive for Desktop client, to see if it can recover files locally (?!) when the entire issue is files disappearing from the cloud, doesn't seem like it makes any sense.
Or if the problem really is solely with files that should have been uploaded but weren't, and nothing from the cloud ever actually got deleted, then explain and justify that as well -- because that's not what people are saying.
I don't understand what's going on at Google. If actual data loss occurred, trying to pretend it didn't happen is never the answer. As the saying goes, "the cover-up is worse than the crime". Why Google is not fully and transparently acknowledging this issue baffles me. The corporate playbook for these types of situations is well known, and it involves being transparent and accountable.
- FridgeSeal 3y agoThat’s what any normal company who is used to dealing with customers would do, but google isn’t that. Google is entirely unacquainted with the concept of “customer relations”. I’m half convinced that google-the-business sees customers as convenient peasants that purchase whatever it deigns to sell. The idea of supporting customers is basically antithetical to them: look at all the stories of people trying to get support for GCP as a great case in point.
- EarlKing 3y agoAnd this is why no one should have anything to do with Google. If the last fifteen years haven't taught people that, well, there's just no hope for you. For everyone else: Stay away from their offerings as if they were the plague.
- asdff 3y agoIts amazing how you can say as much for almost every product they have. Especially as they get more ambitious. Google Fiber. Sidewalk Toronto. The list goes on. Why believe anything they pitch to you when they've proven time and time again that they aren't likely to deliver as promised, or even at all?
- gaze 3y agothey're exactly this way with youtube, too.
- x0x0 3y agoThere's a pretty big difference, though, between an ad-supported free-to-use service vs a service I pay $216/u/y for.
- gowld 3y agoHave you tested that theory?
- x0x0 3y agoI meant more morally than de facto. As in the buyer of that service, I expect support (and will move to O365 if it is unavailable.) Though in a perfect world there would be more than 2 choices... To be honest, I have gotten pretty good support from GSuite, though it was fixing Google's own incompetence. It turns out that if you bought GSuite when prompted while registering your business' domain w/ Google Domains, that was a special GSuite locked out of certain features. Because reasons. It took contacting support to fix this. In a very Googley way, it was clear that many companies had hit this problem, and they'd built tools to fix it. They of course didn't stop the problem, but they did have a well-orchestrated process to fix it...
- mcronce 3y agoGoogle, institutionally, still seems to have not realized that many users are now customers and not (or at least, in addition to) product. If you are receiving money from somebody, they are your customer, and you have a responsibility to provide at least vaguely good service.
- cyanydeez 3y agolooks like you spelled consumer incorrectly, can I help you with that?
- mcronce 3y agoNo, I spelled customer correctly, but thank you for the offer.
- beardedmoose 3y agoOh they don't care because people keep paying or they make money from the customer data they sell to others. At my employer we just switched away from google because they decided to double our monthly bill because we didn't want to enter into a contract. We could never reach our account manager or anyone at support that was helpful, they are just too big to care now. We are still dealing with stupid Google issues like any time our mail relay sends mail to Gmail servers it's 50/50 whether they decide to block it saying we aren't authenticated properly even though our SPF record is indeed valid.
- aidenn0 3y ago> Google, institutionally, still seems to have not realized that many users are now customers and not (or at least, in addition to) product. If you are receiving money from somebody, they are your customer, and you have a responsibility to provide at least vaguely good service. Tell that to Comcast.
- VHRanger 3y agoComcast is a monopoly. If they had competition they'd learn that quickly. Google has alternatives on all their services except arguably YouTube and search
- bastardoperator 3y agoIt is weird, it's off putting, and it does come off as arrogant. Someone has convinced someone else that these lack of interactions is saving them something or from something. I think it's costs them but I have no data, so it's pure speculation. I know I wouldn't consider them for any serious service except maybe email at this point.
- stillwithit 3y ago> I’m half convinced that google-the-business sees customers as convenient peasants that purchase whatever it designs to sell. Supply side economics says this is what we supply, you buy. Thats how it works.
- nomilk 3y agoCould Google be trying reduce its exposure to legal ramifications (i.e. compensation / class action)?
- lokar 3y agoIf I had to guess I would say legal is being very conservative.
- gowld 3y agoI don't understand the point of Company hosting forums that aren't staffed by Company. Well I do. It doesn't help users at all. The only feature is Company's censorship. It's a hostile social hack on the user base who should be using a different forum host.
- jsnell 3y ago> I don't understand what's going on at Google. If actual data loss occurred, trying to pretend it didn't happen is never the answer. They're not pretending it didn't happen though? As per the article they acknowledged it and published a help center article on it. They named the software versions affected (notifying the affected users seems impossible, since the entire problem was that the data had not been synced). Following the links in the help center article, during the incident they posted in a pinned article in the support forum (multiple times) on how to avoid triggering the bug and how to avoid making it worse. That's pretty much what you wanted to see except for a blog post with an RCA, no? > Or if the problem really is solely with files that should have been uploaded but weren't, and nothing from the cloud ever actually got deleted, then explain and justify that as well -- because that's not what people are saying. So the suggestion is that in addition to the bug that they acknowledged, there's a totally different one that appeared at the same time affecting totally different functionality and with different symptoms, and that they're covering up despite not covering up the other bug? That seems like a complicated explanation when there's an obvious and simpler explanation around. That's also the kind of thing that's pretty much impossible to prove categorically, let alone communicate the proof in a way that's understandable to the average user. What are you going to say? "We've checked really hard and can't confirm the reports"? (I mean, I guess it's possible to do it. Collect 100 credible reports of files going missing that can reliably identify the supposedly missing file by name and creation date rather than say that it was probably a .doc file sometime in March. Then do an analysis on e.g. audit logs on what the reality is. How many files were never there at all? How many were explicitly deleted by the user? How many were accidentally uploaded to a user's work account rather than personal account? How many were still in the drive, and the user just couldn't find them? And yes, once you've exhausted all the possibilities, how many disappeared without a trace? Then publish the statistics. But while doing such an investigation privately to make sure whether there is a problem makes sense, publishing the results seems like a stunningly bad PR strategy even if no data was indeed lost.)
- cma 3y ago> They're not pretending it didn't happen though? From that help center article: "If you're among the small subset of Drive for desktop users on version 84 who experienced issues accessing local files that had yet to be synced to Drive" Is "issues accessing local files" how anyone would describe deleting a user's local files?
- Laaas 3y agoThey've committed securities fraud potentially if they're lying about this intentionally.
- semiquaver 3y agoYeah, but Everything Is Securities Fraud.
- edmundsauto 3y agoTo preface, I do not intend to defend Google nor do I work with them or represent them. That said, I have been in similar situations with large scale customers. It is hard. Some percentage of customers are pathological, and even after you fix their problem refuse to stop continuing the rumors. Once it’s fixed, I want all communication forward looking. Some percent of people are flat out insane, incompetent, or just assholes. Sometimes you have to lock the thread in order to stop a conversation about something that is already fixed. Large scale customer bases are just a different beast. Once you experience it, you know what I mean. That doesn’t mean Google took the right path - only people with a comprehensive perspective can evaluate that, and I’m just some idiot on a forum who knows nothing about the specifics.
- NotYourLawyer 3y agohttps://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Victim_blaming https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Victim_blaming
- starttoaster 3y agoIt could be victim blaming. It could be rational. Have you never been in a situation where a frantic user didn't understand that you gave them the solution to their problem and they just continued lashing out? Sometimes victims are done right by, and they just create victims out of another party.
- edmundsauto 3y agoAnd someone can be a victim of data loss and simultaneously a bully for trying to harangue Google. Being a victim in one area is not a “get out of being called an asshole” card. Especially when it comes to data loss, where ultimately the data owner is the responsible party.
- edmundsauto 3y agoVictim blaming is problematic in general, I agree. But when “shit happens” (as it did here, assuming nobody think Google deleted the data on purpose), at some point victims become aggressors. It sucks to lose your data. It might suck more for the Google employees who lost the data. Have a little empathy for both sides - those who don’t can eat rocks.
- matthewaveryusa 3y agofor google the problem is small enough they're encouraging individuals to file a small claims they'll gladly hand a check for, or it's big enough that google doesn't want to document shooting themselves in the foot. I also think there's a long tail of Beavis' out there that you need to lock things down to stop the rumors. Genuinely, I would love an answer from someone that believes in both "never talk to the cops" and "corporations should be open about their fuck-ups" to articulate how they reconcile both concepts. For me they're the same side of the coin, but I'd enjoy to be convince otherwise.
- geraldwhen 3y agoCops cannot testify on your behalf, only against you. Whereas in business, your public and private statements determine your entire company image. Statements made by companies in public places cannot “only be held against them”. It’s completely different.
- onetokeoverthe 3y ago[dead]
- noobermin 3y agoYour question "why" is probably because you think google should know better. However, I am reminded of the post from a few weeks of the person who left google after decades of working there who claims the culture has changed and attracted more incompetent corporate, political types. EDIT: found it, not decades but almost 2, he left after working there 18 years. https://ln.hixie.ch/?start=1700627373&count=1 https://ln.hixie.ch/?start=1700627373&count=1 See the HN comments https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=38381573 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=38381573
- zx8080 3y ago> This is so strange, this is exactly how you don't handle problems like this. Is it a monopolistic behaviour by the book?
- rvba 3y agoGoogle is an offshoring / low cost company now. Since they struggle to innovate they use the strategy of cost cutting. What means moving development and support (if any) to low cost countries. Low cost countries mean low cost country standards in both code quality and handling of the disaster after the code breaks.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]