22 ms·
I'd be extremely surprised if the "Mickey Mouse standing on the moon" example image was a legitimate way to "launder copyright". The interesting question is ju
by lxgr 3y ago
I'd be extremely surprised if the "Mickey Mouse standing on the moon" example image was a legitimate way to "launder copyright".
The interesting question is just who will be liable for the copyright violation: The party that hosts the AI service? The party that trained it on copyrighted images? The user entering a prompt? The (possibly different) user publishing the resulting image?
- darkwraithcov 3y agoMM will be public domain in Jan.
- liotier 3y agoSome early versions will.
- JohnFen 3y agoUnless Disney can engineer yet another oppressive extension to copyright durations.
- RcouF1uZ4gsC 3y agoNot going to happen. When Disney did their copyright extension last time, they had bipartisan influence. Now Disney is in the middle of the culture war, and there is no Republican that will risk being primaried to support Disney. Given that you de facto need 60 votes in the Senate, it is not happening.
- JohnFen 3y agoI guess that's some sort of silver lining to the state of things today!
- alphabettsy 3y agoStill protected by trademark depending on how it’s used.
- fsckboy 3y agothe author of a novel has a copyright to the contents, but can't trademark the contents of the novel. the same is true for artwork.
- _w1tm 3y agoOnly the first movie, the trademark is not expiring.
- ryoshu 3y agoI can draw as many Disney characters as I want to and Disney has no recourse as long as I'm not publishing them somewhere.
- JohnFen 3y agoPosting them on IG, Facebook, etc. is publishing them.
- airstrike 3y agoYes, but importantly, generating them with the AI trained on Mickey is not.
- JohnFen 3y agoTrue. This is why I think it's pointless to try to use copyright law to defend yourself against AI companies. Right now, anyway, I don't see any law (or any other mechanism) that provides any protection. If I did, I wouldn't have had to remove all of my websites from the public web.
- slaymaker1907 3y agoBut is publishing a model which can generate images of Mickey a copyright violation? It's definitely a violation if the model is overfitted to the extent that you can, perhaps lossily, extract the original images.
- airstrike 3y ago> But is publishing a model which can generate images of Mickey a copyright violation? Is selling colored pencils that can draw images of Mickey a copyright violation? The way I see it, the tool can't ever be at fault for its use, unless its sole use (or something close enough to its sole use) is to infringe in copyright. Besides, the safeguarding of copyright isn't the single variable we as a society should be solving for. General global productivity is way more valuable than guaranteeing Disney's bottom line.
- glimshe 3y agoHere the problem isn't that the AI was trained on Mickey, but that it generated Mickey. The generated images can still violate copyright if too similar to copyrighted artwork - if published. I think AI companies are working hard on preventing generated images from being similar to training images unless the user very explicitly asks the result to look like some well known image/character.
- alphabettsy 3y agoIt can violate copyright, but as or equally important, companies have trademark protection on their characters and symbols.
- JAlexoid 3y agoYou can violate copyright by intentionally drawing Mickey Mouse, the medium of drawing is not relevant (AI can be considered a medium, as much as a digital camera is a medium)
- ska 3y ago> The interesting question is just who will be liable for the copyright violation I don't think this is going to be hard for courts. If you borrow your friends copy of a copyright text, got to kinkos and duplicate it, then distribute the results - you are the one violating copyright, not your friend or kinkos. The same will hold here I think, mutatis mutandis. This is all completely separable from the training issue.
- __loam 3y agoThe person getting sued there would be the user of the model, not meta, as much as I wish that wasn't how it is. If you use photoshop to infringe on copyright, you're at fault, not Adobe.