10 ms·
Fake chips, I got stung
- inasio 3y agoI now this is hacker news, but for a second I wondered about fake chips as in fish and chips
- LinuxJedi 3y agoWell now I'm just hungry! :)
- jvanderbot 3y agoAnyone take a crack at the underside characters on the counterfeit chip?
- bigbillheck 3y agoI was wondering if it could be Devanagari or something similar based on that strong horizontal line.
- jstanley 3y agoI tried drawing it in https://www.qhanzi.com/ https://www.qhanzi.com/ and it looks a bit like 防 which apparently means "defend". Or maybe more like 阮 which means "Ruan" (maybe that's a person's name?).
- dmurray 3y agoChecked with a Chinese native speaker who also thinks it's 阮.
- LinuxJedi 3y agoAh! Thanks. I tried several different visual search methods whilst writing those post but was coming up blank.
- libreliu 3y agoI think it goes to "贤". As a native speaker I think "阮"'s possible but unlikely, since most people will write the "阝" part more straight.
- bewaretheirs 3y agoI don't know Chinese but Google translate says "贤" means "virtuous", "worthy", or "able". Is that word plausibly used to refer to devices to mean "it works" or "it passes tests"?
- mook 3y agoIt's more likely to be the name of the QA person that checked it. Writing a literal "OK" is so much easier if they just wanted it mark it as good otherwise.
- pringk02 3y agoI'm stumped. I've never been good with handwritten Chinese, but even rotating it I can't match it to any valid character. The closest I got was 阹 which means "to surround"
- otteromkram 3y agoDid you try viewing it in a mirror? Sometimes that helps.
- netruk44 3y agoI thought I'd check with GPT-4 vision preview just to see what it could make of the character. Unfortunately, it couldn't figure it out. > The logographic character you're referring to appears to be a Chinese character, but it's not clearly written which makes it difficult to identify with certainty. (There was more to the response, but it was more about why the character might be written there)
- LinuxJedi 3y agoYea, I tried a couple of AIs on it whilst writing that post and didn't get anywhere. It does look like elsewhere in the comments here people have maybe figured it out though.
- libreliu 3y agoAs a native speaker I think its "贤", just rotated right by 90 degree.
- bogantech 3y agoIf I needed to replace a 65C02 I'd buy a WDC 65C02 new from mouser - they're still made today :)
- bonzini 3y agoLast paragraph: "As a side note, I have designed a prototype board that allows use of a brand new 65C02 IC made by Western Digital in retro machines. The Western Digital chips have a slightly different pinout to the others, so need a slight conversion. PCBs for this are coming soon."
- akino_germany 3y agoBut the WDC chips are made by Western Design Center, not Western Digital Corporation.
- bogantech 3y agoThanks I have no idea how I missed that :/
- satiated_grue 3y agoWDC application note on that (note the pinout differences): AN-002: Replacement Notes for Obsolete Versions of 6502 8-bit Microprocessors https://www.westerndesigncenter.com/wdc/AN-002_W65C02S_Replacements.php https://www.westerndesigncenter.com/wdc/AN-002_W65C02S_Repla...
- no_time 3y ago
- cglace 3y agoI once interviewed a candidate who had previously worked for the DoD as an engineer that validated components. I was blown away by how far they went to ensure the components they received were genuine and 100% matched the specs in their contract.
- baz00 3y agoYeah I did 6 months on a goods in line. We measured every single part and did full sampled testing. This was on defence grade parts as well from big vendors. They were rebagged, kept in stores ready for use so there were no surprises.
- H8crilA 3y agoWhy is the defence industry so much more intense when it comes to checking parts? Is it mostly because it may be years or decades between purchase and usage?
- AnimalMuppet 3y agoPartly that. Also they tend to push parts farther - temperature range, probably also radiation hardness, maybe some other things. When you need a part with a milspec temperature range, you really want to get a part with that range, not a part with a smaller range with a forged label.
- doikor 3y agoA lot of the environment stuff is more about actually testing that the part can take that. A civilian part might be very close (or the exact same part with a different model number) and even better in some cases but as it was never tested you don’t know.
- JohnFen 3y agoExactly this. In my day job, I program industrial equipment that operates in very unfriendly environments (lots of heat, vibration, humidity, etc.) We pay extra for parts that are certified to be able to take the abuse. Many of the parts aren't really any different than what you'd find inside consumer goods. They cost more because they've been tested and certified.
- baz00 3y ago> This was annoying because the seller is based in the UK and claims you should buy from them because you take your chances buying from China. There are a couple of vendors who do this in the UK. They sell counterfeit crap while complaining about it loudly. I bet this was littlediode. Got into a large argument with them over sending out crappy clone / reject bin transistors a few years back. Edit: at the same time I would like to buy a hell of a lot of 2N5458's and relabel them as MPF102's and retire. The MPF102 was an unbinned garbage JFET with wide characteristic spread. The 5458 is a binned one within the range of an MPF102. Same process. Of course though all the crap schematics out there on the Internet demand the MPF102 because that's what Radio Shack sold and no one knows how to substitute parts!
- anilakar 3y agoEBay is full of UK sellers who source stuff from China in bulk and then pass it off as genuine. This is in no way limited to electronic components.
- LinuxJedi 3y agoIt was not littlediode this time, I'm not going to name them (you'll be able to tell with a search as the chip has the same date code on their auction). There are several out there that buy from China and resell. The good ones at least run a barrage of tests first.
- Retr0id 3y agoI've recently been annoyed by "UK sellers" that actually ship from China, but using Yodel's "last mile" logistics[1]. They'll give you the tracking code for the Yodel part of the journey, and it'll take a week longer than the originally advertised, but they'll swear they shipped from the UK. [1] https://www.yodel.co.uk/yodel-services/yodel-uk-delivery/international-inbound https://www.yodel.co.uk/yodel-services/yodel-uk-delivery/int...
- jjoonathan 3y agoOne time an ADC chip in my Rigol scope died. From the pinout, it was clearly a Chinese clone of a TI part. I wanted a replacement clone part, but it wasn't available under the clone name, so I bought the cheapest most suspicious listing of the TI part that I could find, hoping I would get the clone. Unfortunately I got the genuine article. So it goes. https://goo.gl/photos/dxU3ChWUcvCMDW4N9 https://goo.gl/photos/dxU3ChWUcvCMDW4N9 Fortunately I was able to make do with the genuine part, though not trivially: there was a weird clock termination difference. It's never easy, is it?
- baz00 3y agoThis sort of stuff scares me with modern Chinese test gear. I'd rather have some rancid old HP or Tek stuff from the 90s and keep a couple of parts mules in the cupboard.
- buildbot 3y agoThe lab I worked in during undergrad had a massive pile of old scopes and such. One of them was this monstrosity of a scope from the 80s (?) that had a built in thermal printer to capture the output, and was I think in the 1-2ghz range! I’m sure it’s still there, working, waiting for the next undergrad to need its assistance.
- mips_r4300i 3y agoProbably an old Lecroy! With the floppy drive next to the thermal printer.
- buildbot 3y agoYES! You jogged my memory - it absolutely was a lecroy with a floppy disk as well! What a cool piece of equipment. Though I won’t say I was too sad when we got to use a 5GHz touch screen Tektronix instead! It ran Windows XP and was generally super awesome to use.
- CamperBob2 3y ago
- ajb 3y agoIt can't be worth making, or counterfeiting, 6502's for the hobbyist market. Anyone have a clue as to what the mass market for these chips is?
- bogantech 3y agoMaybe old industrial systems or something? WDC still manufactures them so there must be someone designing new things that use these for some reason
- mrWiz 3y agoI suspect that existing designs are built using them to avoid designing something new.
- JohnFen 3y agoI'm familiar with this one, but there may be others: embedded systems. There is a huge market of industrial controllers that were designed around the 6502 and for which there is a large, solid, existing code base. New designs often use 6502-based controllers in order to maintain compatibility with that code base, and existing machines need to be able to be repaired. Fun fact: the ARM is largely based on the 6502. You could argue that the 6502 was a RISC chip before RISC was a thing!
- LinuxJedi 3y agoI've been wanting to squeeze that ARM fact in one of my Archimedes blog posts, but somehow never got around to it. It is pretty cool how it was developed.
- Turing_Machine 3y agoI don't know if I'd go quite that far, but the 6502 definitely had some RISC-ish features. The Page 0 addressing mode basically let you use the first page of RAM more or less as 256 extra 8-bit registers (or 128 16-bit registers, etc.), as those locations could be accessed faster and with fewer instruction bytes than locations elsewhere in RAM. A fair number of languages were implemented on 6502-based machines by using multiple Page 0 locations to simulate wider registers.
- Hasz 3y agoI had some mosfet gate drivers (IR2112) that were really marked as IR2113, a higher tier part. The only real way to tell what you've got is to remove most of the epoxy, then boil the rest in nitric/sulfuric acid. After much mess and fume, you'll be left with the raw die and can inspect the markings. I've done this a couple of times, it's quite cool. In my experience, most "fakes" are crappier parts marked up to be better, or chips that have failed QA. Rarely do you get a whole clone, although for some very high volume or simple, old parts, it's a bit more common. If you like this, check out [zeptobars](https://zeptobars.com/en/ https://zeptobars.com/en/), they post high quality dieshots, and sometimes fakes. IR2113/IR2112 die: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=e6DfBuPwAAA https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=e6DfBuPwAAA
- rcxdude 3y agoI've heard a story of the opposite, mislabeled from the manufacturer themselves! They were pressing the buyer to upgrade to a newer, faster MOSFET, but the buyer wasn't interested in dealing with going through the EMC compliance process again, so wanted the older parts. Eventually the seller appeared to relent, and shipped a box of FETs with the older label, but lo and behold the assembled boards failed EMC testing, and it turned out the manufacturer had just labelled their newer parts with the old part number and hoped no-one would notice.
- A1kmm 3y ago> although for some very high volume or simple, old parts, it's a bit more common And often the prevalence of the high volume parts actually makes it nearly impossible to find things using the originals. For example, I once wanted a real FT232 breakout board (or at least a clone that can do most of what the original can do) to use some of the bit-banging features of the chip. But the most popular clones of that chip are very much reduced functionality variants that work as a USB-to-UART but don't do most of the other functionality. This was probably not helped by the fact that the original chips, and early more faithful replicas had onboard flash and allowed a degree of programming, but then the manufacturer of the original chip embedded malware in their Windows driver that detected and wrote bad data to the clones flash (which would have broken many products sold to consumers with them - technically fixable by removing the driver and re-flashing, but probably in most cases just becoming e-waste). So the clone manufacturers responded by simplifying: removing the flash, and removing most of the programmable functionality, and focusing on the UART part that was the most common use case. Now, no matter how hard you try pre-purchase to make sure something is a full FT232 implementation (including asking for assurance about the chip up front) on a marketplace like Aliexpress or eBay, you are far more likely than not to got a limited functionality clone.
- WentFullRetard 3y ago[dead]
- ajmurmann 3y agoWhat's a trustworthy shop to buy chips these days?
- LinuxJedi 3y agoNew / old stock? I have a supplier called TV SAT in Poland who is pretty reliable. I've had pretty good success with UTSource. But it really depends on what you are looking for. Usually it is a case of looking at reviews and crossing your fingers.
- the__alchemist 3y agoDigikey, Mouser, Newark.
- the_pwner224 3y agoAnother comment on this post: "I regularly get fake NXP chips even from the big distributors. Not going to name them here, but it happened at least with the ones starting with A, D and M. ..." https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=38559112 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=38559112
- JohnFen 3y agoEven if they aren't perfect, they are also not trying to defraud anybody. Your odds are much better with them than with other random sources.
- the__alchemist 3y ago
- Luc 3y agoA sure telltale is laser writing. You can tell on their second example - the writing is sharp and perfect. Often the logo is not quite solid color, and you can see it has lines from the laser in it. The color of laser-'printed' text is also typical. The originals often have pretty bad markings on them, actually. Off-center, not aligned, not evenly printed. Too perfect is suspicious. Also look at the pins. Sometimes they dip the feet into solder to make them look unscratched and shiny. I have avoided buying 'New Old Stock' ICs because I could tell the pins had solder on them. A couple of times I found the IC was of the type advertised (after I removed the paint). I guess they just added a fresh coat of paint to make them look new!
- LinuxJedi 3y agoI never thought about inspecting the pins before, a very good point.
- karmakaze 3y agoWhen it mentioned that there was something off about the printing/logo, I zoomed in and recognized it immediately. As I recall the Rockwell International logo has curves joining the angled borders, like you'd expect to see for laminar flow. The pictured one has straight lines that meet at a corner. You can see the difference in logo between the 11450 and '11473' chips.
- userbinator 3y agoLaser etching doesn't come off with acetone (and is usually much harder to read, being more like embossing than printing). That's silkscreened ink.
- Luc 3y agoI'm talking about the 'Another Chip' IC, which has laser writing. It's the bottom one in the header image. They use a coat of paint to obscure previous markings, then use the laser on that, resulting in brownish text (not embossed).
- peter_retief 3y agoFriend of mine got a box of plastic chips with no electronics, from China.
- mrweasel 3y agoWhy even go to the trouble of actually shipping a product at that point? I'm really surprised by the length people will go to, in order to scam others. Someone took the time to do a fake plastic chip, or reprint a silk screen on an chip with a matching pin-out. My favorites are fake USB drives and "fake" GPUs. The amount of time that has to go into finding old GPUs, faking a driver and relabeling seems like it would exceed the value of the scam, but apparently not.
- peter_retief 3y agoWhat I actually thought, they do get to buy some time though.
- Joker_vD 3y agoIf you fail to ship anything, that's an open and close case of fraud. If you ship anything, especially if it's at least superficially similar, you can argue it was a good-faith mistake, just a case of failed due diligence.
- JohnFen 3y agoYes, I think that's it. Also, there's this interesting exchange I had with an eBay seller a couple of years ago. I purchased a bunch of NiMH batteries. Because I test every component I buy even for my hobby projects, I immediately noticed that they were 1/10th the capacity that they should have been, and were marked as. I contacted the seller to return them and get a refund. They told me "honest mistake" and then began a negotiation. "How large of a refund would you accept?" Since the batteries were useless to me, I said "100%". In the end, I did get a complete refund and didn't need to return the batteries.
- 3y ago
- iamflimflam1 3y agoThis was annoying because the seller is based in the UK and claims you should buy from them because you take your chances buying from China. There are tons of eBay sellers who bulk buy from China and then resell with a huge markup but with the convenience of quicker delivery - and the slightly fake sense of being more reliable as they are UK based.
- LinuxJedi 3y agoYep, I was way too trusting this time.
- numlock86 3y agoI regularly get fake NXP chips even from the big distributors. Not going to name them here, but it happened at least with the ones starting with A, D and M. Their excuse is always the same: Telling us they just sourced other distributors because of shortage at the manufacturer, but won't name these "distributors". Really annoying.
- ElijahLynn 3y agoWhy wouldn't you name them here? People need to know, otherwise they will keep doing it yah?
- _whiteCaps_ 3y agoPeople ordering parts would probably be familiar with the major sellers like Arrow, Digikey, and Mouser.
- jtbayly 3y agoWhy complain that they won't name the distributors while you won't name them?
- sheepshear 3y agoThey're being silly. A, D, and M are as recognizable as FAANG.
- whatshisface 3y agoAMD! ;)
- piperswe 3y agoI'm assuming the "D" and "M" are Digikey and Mouser? Rather concerning if true.
- swamp40 3y agoIf you are insinuating Arrow, Digikey, Mouser, we buy NXP from all these same sources and have never seen a problem. They all have traceable lot codes and and entire chains of custody that go directly back to the manufacturer. And during Covid we were checking. That traceability is the reason people buy from them instead of brokers. If you could prove what you are saying it would be a huge scandal. How do you qualify them as being fakes?
- ElijahLynn 3y agoName and shame the bunk seller, warn others. Why no mention of the UK seller?
- LinuxJedi 3y agoJust in case the seller becomes litigious. I may be correct, but I don't want to spend time proving that in a legal framework. You can easily figure it out as the date code on the chips is unique to them and they still sell them on eBay.
- callalex 3y agohttps://www.ebay.com/itm/225089488340 https://www.ebay.com/itm/225089488340
- DoingIsLearning 3y agoOn this topic, is there anything like a 'chip forensics consulting service' out there? Say if I find a batch from a scalper but I am not sure if it is genuine.
- JohnFen 3y agoIf there isn't, there really should be. I bet that would be an excellent business to be in.
- RetroTechie 3y agoOnce I considered offering such a service for a select few parts. But: shipping, and low $ per part doesn't make it worth the effort. If you're buying a $3 cpu it just isn't worth it to re-route through a testing service for several additional $ per pc. + shipping. Now if talking about say, $100+ / piece parts, sure. But then the testing services would have to be extensive, professional, and equipped accordingly. Above my pay grade, so to speak. But yes it would be nice if such service(s) existed.
- JohnFen 3y agoGood points. I hadn't really thought through the economics of it. I wonder... if the testing could be automated at high speed, would that make the economics work? That would enable being able to service entities that buy larger quantities of parts, reducing the impact of shipping costs. Those don't have to even be companies -- I already buy most of the parts for my hobby projects in larger quantities, in order to get bulk discounts, free shipping, and to have sufficient stock on hand that I don't need to order things every time I start a new project. Now my imagination is running wild...
- johndmcmaster 3y agoI agree with this. I often get asked to decap + image chips commercially and its not usually worth it unless its a value add / loss leader as part of a larger project.
- 3y ago
- callalex 3y agoThe seller is “UK In-Stock Components” I don’t understand why the author is being so coy about defending a scammer. https://www.ebay.com/itm/225089488340 https://www.ebay.com/itm/225089488340
- mschuster91 3y agoUK libel laws are insanely strict.
- kazinator 3y agoAnyone know how I can get in on the fake 65C02 chip action? I wanna be rich too!
- calamari4065 3y agoI recently had an issue with some uCs that just wouldn't respond to the bootloader. I suspected they were fake, but I got them from digikey. I asked digikey if they could confirm origin, but they ignored me :( They responded to JTAG correctly, but none of the other documented bootloader modes, which was a dealbreaker. I don't think they were actually fake, but certainly defective or at least incorrectly documented. Every single time I've tried to use an ST device I get bit. I'm sure it's just me being unlucky, but I avoid their parts now when I can.
- johndmcmaster 3y agoI've been collecting a bunch of counterfeit chips to hopefully do a write up on at some point. If you are ok they might sit for a while, I'd love to collect them for that project! Feel free to email me JohnDMcMaster at gmail.com
- Dwedit 3y agoI saw that video on Youtube where someone decapped a fake chip to find out what it really was.
- johndmcmaster 3y agoI have a big pile of counterfeit chips to decap / analyze. Unfortunately busy with work / higher priority projects so haven't gotten to them :(
- ginko 3y agoI would have expected counterfeit clone would use a node much more modern than either the 6502 or R65C02, leading to even better performance. Are there so many original 6052s around that it's cheaper to just relabel those? (I guess cheap 6502s were really everywhere in the 80s/90s)
- LinuxJedi 3y agoThe modern version (W65C02S) is not 100% pin compatible. It would be very obvious very quickly if that had been done. There isn't another modern equivalent with the same pinout that I'm aware of. Yes, there are many original 6502s around, and they are probably worth half of an R65C02, or even less.
- justin66 3y agoI've still got a counterfeit Athlon XP, IIRC a 2500 marked up to appear to be a 3200. I was able to get a refund for the fraudulent part from the credit card processor. Interestingly, AMD offered to send me a replacement, but NOT a 3200, which was top of the line at the time. I kept the counterfeit chip instead. Like the author of this article, I had some performance problems with the part, but I was sure I had a fake when I looked at the printing on the package of the chip.