5 ms·
Is El Salvador's Bitcoin bet paying off?
- frereubu 3y agoTLDR: We don't know because there's no transparency from the president.
- meerita 3y agoWhat kind of transparency are you missing? I think it's one of the most transparent projects the presidency has given about. You can access all the information publicly.
- RandomLensman 3y agoNot OP, but it reads like the broader costs of the bitcoin project are guesses (wallet development, promotion, ...), not published numbers - is that all available?
- misnome 3y agoAs I understand it, there is no public information on what is held and how profitable the endeavour has been, and the specific graph along with the tweet that is linked in this article is a third-part that merely estimates holdings?
- aredox 3y agoThe article talks at length of the total lack of transparency. The government spokesperson doesn't address the problem at all when probed.
- frereubu 3y agoThe only information on the actual Bitcoin holdings has been released in tweets by the president, which don't include anything like a Bitcoin wallet address, so there's no proof that the government actually owns them, and no public body is tracking those investments. If the article is true - and I have no reason to doubt those particular details - then this really feels like a "trust me, bro" situation.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- faeriechangling 3y agoHard to get much more transparent than bitcoin.
- frereubu 3y agoYou need to read the article - the point is that the president has given no details of the holdings except in tweets, and has not answered questions about the enormous sums of money used to promote the scheme, including a $30 "bonus" for all citizens over 30.
- faeriechangling 3y agoI don’t much care that the BBC is too incompetent/lazy to do research on assets which are so insanely traceable and transparent and complains that a public body isn’t tracking things. All it says to me is I shouldn’t read the BBC and instead follow journalists like Coffeezilla who actually understand the subject they’re reporting on and spend time researching and expose the financial mismanagement related to crypto by doing actual blockchain analysis. They didn’t even seem to try. They just got some important sounding experts to complain and called it a day.
- frereubu 3y agoIt is important for public accountability that a public body tracks these kinds of things. Why should citizens of a country have to become experts in a subject when the government should be transparent about what they're doing in the first place? This is pretty basic stuff. Also, as I said, there are other things they're not being transparent about, like the sums of money used to promote the scheme. You can't find that on the blockchain.
- Yizahi 3y agoThey aren't using bitcoin, they are trying to use a proprietary closed variant of it, loosely linked to the mainnet.
- u320 3y agoBetteridge
- anonymousDan 3y agoOooh. The HN hivemind is not going to like this. More seriously, as I understand it the recent price rises are because it looks like its going to be possible to buy Bitcoin ETFs and the like more easily?
- dale_glass 3y ago3.7M is basically nothing for a country. El Salvador's GDP is $74 billion, so this is 0.005% of it. And this gain does nothing unless the BTC is sold, and the proceeds benefit El Salvador in some way. This also assumes that amount of BTC can be sold. They need to find an entity that will send them ~$120M for their BTC, and better hope that this won't crash the market.
- ric2b 3y ago$120M is, as you said, not that much in the Bitcoin market.
- dale_glass 3y agoIt's not much in the market at large, but you need to find some party or several that has $120M sitting around, and willing to exchange that for BTC. I expect making that transaction isn't that easy.
- weird-eye-issue 3y agoCould literally just sell that on one of the major exchanges over the course of a few hours I've sold $8M on Coinbase Pro within minutes by setting a limit order (not a market order - although I'm sure some people will reply without knowing the difference) and it didn't impact the price
- npoc 3y agoIt would be an over the counter sale. Even using an exchange directly, together Coinbase and Bybit are trading $1B/day BTCUSD - there's no shortage of buyers.
- expertentipp 3y agoScanning some articles and photos in them, it feels like a massive dystopian cyber scam.
- colesantiago 3y agoNo it isn't paying off. The people in El Salvador aren't using it, and not even for 'payments'. https://restofworld.org/2022/el-salvador-bitcoin/ https://restofworld.org/2022/el-salvador-bitcoin/ Just because 'Number Go Up' doesn't mean there is any utility in these fictitious tokens. Another thing, Unrealised gains are just that, Unrealised, not real. So this is still not 'paying off' unless El Salvador fully gets out of gambling a portion of their government's money on the Bitcoin token, instead of buying every top. But of course, they and everyone else is staying in because... 'Number Go Up'
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- pockmockchock 3y agotheir bonds seem to do pretty well..
- LAC-Tech 3y agoThe BBC is a weird publication. They never use interesting language, yet they always make it very clear who they do and don't like.
- becquerel 3y agoThat's ideology for you.
- andybak 3y agoIt's a matter of degree. No source is free of bias or ideology so it's not particularly interesting to call the BBC "ideological" as it's rather like calling a tree "green" (don't pick holes in that metaphor, please) My point is - your comment doesn't really add much as you're not saying whether you think the BBC is unusual and if so - in what way.
- TomK32 3y agoIn other news: "First-time rider on roller-coaster happy about the steady climb and great view"
- ArtTimeInvestor 3y agoIf you only look at the Bitcoin the governments hold, El Salvador is now roughly on par with the USA in terms of Bitcoin per capita: El Salvador: 3000 Bitcoin / 6M people = 0.0005 Bitcoin per person USA: 200K Bitcoin / 300M people = 0.0007 Bitcoin per person But if you also look at the private sector, the US is probably way ahead. Microstrategy alone holds over 150K Bitcoin. Coinbase is said to hold over 2M Bitcoin. Same for mining. The USA has by far the most capable Bitcoin mining infrastructure. For now, it looks like the USA manages the same feat in regards to crypto as it did with the internet: Be the main player in a huge landgrab with no other country able to even come close. And we see the same story play out in AI too. With the main players being OpenAI, Microsoft and Google who are all in the US. I wish there was a study which analyzes what the magic formula of the US is. I have not seen one yet. It seems like the US is unstoppable when it comes to being the brain of the world. I don't live in the US. But me and everyone around me is connected to each other via US technology. US phones, US software, US services. And it looks like this will only continue to increase with self driving cars and other robots being the basis of all our everyday tasks.
- tutfbhuf 3y agoI believe it has to do with the fact that the US possesses a vast amount of land, abundant natural resources, a long-standing democracy, no wars on its territory for an extended period, and a relatively large population size. If you compare that with other wealthy countries such as Germany, then you'll see that they have less land, fewer natural resources, haven't had democracy for as long, were divided until the late '80s, and do not have as large a population size. Therefore, just by sheer numbers, it makes sense that everything in the US is bigger. Moreover, Germany, for instance, has a culture where wealth is accumulated across a large number of medium-sized companies, whereas in the US, wealth is increasingly concentrated at the top (for example, the ones you mentioned). These are, of course, the entities everyone knows and talks about.
- Axsuul 3y agoIt's beyond that – culture. Being ambitious in US is rewarded and celebrated. Plus having the most powerful military in the world makes others want to invest more into the US due to the likelihood it will still be around.