3 ms·
> I’m yet to find a person that claims these solutions will be enough. It’s just a piece of the puzzle. I know people that believe this, but they aren't scient
by godelski 3y ago
> I’m yet to find a person that claims these solutions will be enough. It’s just a piece of the puzzle.
I know people that believe this, but they aren't scientists. I know quite a few climate scientists and none believe eliminating fossil fuels is enough. I've also never met one that is actually against CCS either, just differing arguments about how resources should be spent which is far more nuanced. Discussion is more complicated around nuclear but maybe I shouldn't bring that up. Its complicated so lots of "experts" on both sides get a lot of information wrong and passionately argue points that are inaccurate. I think around any complex topic -- which absolutely includes climate -- we need to adapt better language and often should probably shut up and listen to the experts. Where experts are not the people you see on the news (a whole other problem I don't want to go into).
I get wanting to make things clearer by simplifying them but you can only simplify so much without losing necessary complexity. The problem as old as time is that lies are unbounded in simplicity while truth has a lower bound in complexity. If you're passionate, you gotta put in the time to gain that knowledge, not just the time to expend your passionate energy.
The problem is that fighting misinformation with misinformation (even unintentional) provides an easy tool for your adversaries to discredit you. You no longer can claim to be founded in the basis of science/logic/facts/whatever you want to call it. It just becomes trivial to discredit and you perpetuate the tribalism. Articles like this even increase tribalism as it splits supporters of decarbonization and even people who want to eliminate fossil fuels. Because now we have to have this discussion instead of the important ones about decarbonization.