4 ms·
While I certainly prefer iOS to Android ... it's really unfortunate that such a situation has emerged. I think the Android platform has only done good for our p
by whalesalad 15y ago
While I certainly prefer iOS to Android ... it's really unfortunate that such a situation has emerged. I think the Android platform has only done good for our planet. Developers have more jobs, more interesting apps are being created, more devices are being sold, there are more powerful and less expensive devices in the smartphone world that are becoming popular in emerging markets and third world countries (don't quote me, but a nearly free Android handset in Nigeria?) Mobile is a paradigm shift. People are more and more connected while away from their homes and desks. Payments are going mobile. Also, Android is the biggest competitor to Apple. I'm certainly an Apple guy in all aspects, but I do appreciate competition in the market to keep everyone working hard and innovating.
Sucks that Oracle will not consider any of that. That no terms could be reached out of simple goodheartedness. Oracle isn't losing money because of Android as far as I am concerned. There might be profit lost due to licensing, but it just feels wrong to me.
- protomyth 15y ago> Oracle isn't losing money because of Android as far as I am concerned. There might be profit lost due to licensing From an Oracle shareholder's point of view (which I'm not), lost licensing fees == losing money.
- mrsteveman1 15y agoAren't they losing money every time someone downloads desktop Java SE for free then?
- kodablah 15y agoTheir argument (which I disagree with) is that creating Java applications is far different than creating a JVM and class libraries. The latter must be licensed. So in their view, driving developer adoption of their language increases the potential for licensing the implementation specification. But let's be honest, OpenJDK is gonna be all there is (sadly). I liked the direction Harmony went, and it was very strict about the legality of what it developed and used.
- rbanffy 15y ago> OpenJDK is gonna be all there is (sadly) Not sad at all. A hostile move by Oracle may be all that's needed to drive a lot more effort into improving it. And the best feature is that it's absolutely Oracle-proof.
- protomyth 15y agoNo, it their product to distribute as they please. IBM and others have paid for theirs so the thinking is Google should pay too. In particular, the licensing on the phone / device edition has always been different.
- rbanffy 15y agoBy scaring everybody away from the Java ecosystem, I believe they'll lose a lot more money on the long run.
- ajross 15y agoSun tried desperately to monetize Java and failed. There's really not much money there, this case is their best hope to see some revenue.
- kamaal 15y agoYes, This is exactly what everybody fails to notice. Everybody please note that Oracle is in the business to make money. And there is nothing wrong with that. They can't just sit on the sidelines and develop java watching other use it to make money while they themselves don't. From Oracle and their shareholders perspective money that they can't make from licensing fees is lost money. No company can justify spending ridiculous money on projects that are going to give them nothing in return.
- rbanffy 15y agoWell... They can always try that old business model - to make things people actually want. To be fair, Java probably brings a lot of business to Oracle. There are a lot of Java applications running on Oracle app servers storing data on Oracle database servers and interfaced to Oracle applications and running on Sun^H^H^HOracle servers. It's just that HNizens live in a much more interesting ecosystem than the average corporate Java programmer who has to wear a tie to the office. Also, Sun did spend ridiculous amounts of money on Java - mostly to level the field against Windows, as Java makes apps easily move from Windows to Unix and vice versa - and made easier to sell SPARC servers that don't run Windows but can run Java applications that also run on Windows. And do so with performance and stability no Windows box could touch. And most can't, even today. Remember: Sun was a hardware company. A confused one, perhaps, but hardware was their core. Oracle, OTOH, invested (or burned) money fully knowing what to expect in return. They can't complain Java does not bring a lot of direct revenue because it was never intended to. And since Java runs very well on x86 hardware running Linux (thanks in part to Oracle), they can't even claim they expected to sell Sun hardware. Unless they had been smoking stuff they shouldn't mention in court.
- loverobots 15y agoGoogle either "stole" from Oracle or it didn't, what you say doesn't matter much. To play your game, the world might benefit if someone took Google's money (entire $45 billion pile) and invested in vaccines or another cause to help the poor. But that's their money, we don't get to decide for them. The same principle should apply for Oracle or Apple.
- rbanffy 15y ago> don't quote me, but a nearly free Android handset in Nigeria? It's so horrible to say it, but someone has to. Not until Android 4.1.9.