4 ms·
There’s a few big factors here - one is the amount that insurance will cover is extremely low - experienced psychologists won’t make more than $130 a session on
by taurath 3y ago
There’s a few big factors here - one is the amount that insurance will cover is extremely low - experienced psychologists won’t make more than $130 a session on most insurance, regardless of speciality or niche expertise. Medicaid is worse - the reimbursement rate is like $70-80 a session (not enough to cover CoL and expenses), AND if you want to bill Medicaid they make you jump through a huge amount of hoops and force you to take on more Medicaid clients. This makes for a situation where those most in need of therapy or counseling are only afforded providers who either work practically for charity, or only the most recent graduates with very little experience - that’s if they can find someone in their area, which is next to impossible given almost no therapist can afford to charge rates so low.
Another problem is the insistence from insurers on only the most “evidence-based” treatment modalities. Everyone taking insurance has to play a dance with them to somehow shoehorn in the use of these or else get denied payment for months. As a result diagnoses and treatment methods that get put into the system are only those approved by the insurer - resulting in a dance that leaves a ton of actually useful individual treatments from being recognized. If it doesn’t bill, it can’t be mentioned, even if it’s working. This can also lead to pretty bad outcomes for clients.
The medical model of treatment is preferred by insurance because it’s the cheapest and quickest to tamp down symptoms but rarely gets to the root cause, especially in the most traumatized populations. Take a homeless person and put them in treatment - they’re probably neurodivergent, traumatized, high ACE score. Making surface symptoms like substance use go into remission doesn’t treat the underlying cause of the substance use.
Lastly, psychologists and therapists can’t make up for the lack of integrated community, sense of belonging and social purpose, and relational support networks that are failing all across society. We are an individualistic society that downplays the value of relational ties, which is part of the reason there is such a need for individual therapy in the first place. Relational trauma, lack of community resources, lack of time to spend with others, lack of social cohesion overall all contribute to a mental health crisis that is intricately tied with the excesses and stunted values of our socioeconomic system. It is an intentional feature, not a bug that people are suffering with little to no recourse.
More money will help, more education and spreading of concepts and ideas will help, but as a society there is a massive amount of work to undertake to slow the engine that produces the social pollution that ends with mass depression, anxiety and worse. It is long overdue.
- rumblerock 3y agoMy partner is now in private practice, but started in community mental health coming out of her social work program. Unsurprisingly, for those most in need, like the children with severe mental illnesses and traumatic family histories she worked with, the resources and funding available are woefully inadequate to meet the need. High caseloads, terrible pay, and a model that churns through new grads until they burn out and move on. As much as she cared about the kids she worked with, private practice has been much better for her own mental health and allowed her to have a decent income. And even then, it seems extremely emotionally taxing to provide 4-6 hours of effective therapy per day.
- taurath 3y agoCommunity MH is IMO functionally the same as the public defender system. We do not spend enough on resources to care for populations via this arena. In a ton of ways we treat mental healthcare the same as crime. I'm considering leaving software to go into the field as I have an extremely traumatic background and want to do more with my life, so the economics of it are very front of mind.