3 ms·
First off, I am clearly in complete agreement with the argument presented. That said, now that this case is live and in the media, it should be noted that ther
by ajross 15y ago
First off, I am clearly in complete agreement with the argument presented.
That said, now that this case is live and in the media, it should be noted that there's a certain deep irony in it. Andy Rubin directed all GPL code (all that was practical, anyway) to be removed from the Android userspace out of fear of IP purity concerns. And in the process of all that forking he did deep harm to the open source community. Not just code was forked, but infrastructure was abandoned: compare the level of robustness and transparency of Fedora/Debian/Ubuntu/OpenSUSE packaging to that of the "I cooked a ROM, download it here!" culture in the android world.
Yet Rubin allowed the use of the developer tools of a clearly proprietary product from another company without batting an eyelash. And no one called him on it. And now they have to have this ridiculous fight. So what was the point of forking Linux again?
- mey 15y agoI personally don't care that a company is looking out for it's "best interests"* internally. I am happy that Google is effectively defending the Java community from Oracle (since Oracle doesn't wish to be it's steward.) * If this move is actually in their best interest, and what best interest IS I have no idea. But it's their perception. You could check out http://wiki.openmoko.org/wiki/Main_Page http://wiki.openmoko.org/wiki/Main_Page Not sure if they are still running these days, but they have the goals you seek in mind.
- cdibona 15y agoI fundamentally disagree that Android did deep harm to open source. That's just absurd.
- ajross 15y agoI said it hurt the community. Your code is open. And much of it is great. But it's not something that can be meaningfully shared. Again: compare the community work available at Launchpad or rpmfusion or build.opensuse.org (compatible, signed, versioned packages with automated dependency tracking) to "I cooked a ROM doodz!". The far and away best example of community work in the Android world (Cyanogen) is, what, five months behind the core team at even shipping the software that's already in the field? It's depressing. And what's absolutely infuriating to me (and the point of this rant) is that you started with all that good stuff and threw it out the window chasing some ridiculous notion of IP purity that -- surprise! -- was basically worthless as you're being sued over IP anyway.
- cdibona 15y agoDo you really think the legal picture would be any different if Android were under copyleft?
- ajross 15y agoOf course not, that wasn't my point at all. I think the community picture would be very different if Android had inherited the infrastructure and community of desktop linux instead of charging ahead with needless and inferior reimplementations of glibc, udev, init/upstart/systemd, rpm/dpkg, etc... in a way that cut them off from the rest of the linux community. Ubuntu and Fedora users can package stuff for others in a robust way, including modifications to the system libraries. How nice would it be to fix the awful accelerometer polling on the Galaxy Nexus and point users to a RPM repo? Try out some new gesture tuning? See the point? That kind of work exists, sort of, in the Android world, but it sucks rocks. And the reason for all this breakage was, ostensibly, "IP purity" and the desire to avoid law suits and ambiguity about the software licensing. Which, as it happens, was a fools errand anyway as the platform is being sued regardless. Is it clear now what I'm saying?
- nknight 15y agoYou clearly lack the experience necessary to understand the dynamics at play here. The phenomenon you bizarrely, insultingly refer to as "I cooked a ROM doodz!" is not arrested by copyleft. Small-scale non-commercial GPL violations by individuals are absolutely rampant in a number of communities. Android would not be any different -- nor is it, in fact, since the kernel is still under the GPL.
- starwed 15y ago>compare the level of robustness and transparency of Fedora/Debian/Ubuntu/OpenSUSE packaging to that of the "I cooked a ROM, download it here!" culture in the android world. I don't really understand what your point is here -- a ROM is an image of the operating system, and as far as I know the situation is the same with mainstream Linux. You typically install a distro by downloading the iso from the web and then running it.