5 ms·
Sounds like throwing the baby out with the bathwater to me. I have a hard time seeing how one can justify avoiding providing something that users of a service
by mindcrime 15y ago
Sounds like throwing the baby out with the bathwater to me. I have a hard time seeing how one can justify avoiding providing something that users of a service are desperately eager for, and which would undoubtedly help grow the ecosystem around said service, all because of one potential negative consequence. And especially one that, at the end of the day, people can simulate anyway by just posting the same content (by hand) to G+, Facebook, Twitter, etc.
- backspace 15y agoKey words: "by hand" -- posting spam by hand doesn't scale. That's what it's preventing.
- jamesbritt 15y agoI have a hard time seeing how one can justify avoiding providing something that users of a service are desperately eager for, ... How do people know what g+ users are "desperately eager for"? Have there been studies? Polls?
- tobyjsullivan 15y agoI'll bet Google's done the studies and polls. And I'll bet they are seriously considering the response: "We don't want API-driven auto-junk filling our streams!"
- mindcrime 15y ago"We don't want API-driven auto-junk filling our streams!" Nobody does, but - again - we're talking about throwing the baby out with the bathwater here. Not everything posted via API is "junk."
- jamesbritt 15y agoNot everything posted via API is "junk." True, but enough of it is to make it a problem. What could Google do to trap the noise but allow the signal? Rate limiting? Pattern matching against Twitter posts?
- mindcrime 15y agoOK, I don't mean to say that every G+ user wants this, mind you. But that a substantial number do is pretty obvious by the posts to the ticket about this, and observing how people interact with other, similar social networks. Does anybody really think that people wouldn't like to be able to use TweetDeck (or whatever) with G+? Or programatically interface with G+ from their blog, or whatever? I may ultimately be proven wrong, but I'd be shocked it a proper study did not show strong demand for a write API.
- mmastrac 15y agoHere's an example of why they don't want to turn it on (this is one of the examples they use internally). https://plus.google.com/107158560758466172135/posts https://plus.google.com/107158560758466172135/posts Charlie Kindel uses a backdoor to paste his tweets to G+ and adds very little to the community. There is no interaction on his posts - it's just added noise.
- mindcrime 15y agoThere is no interaction on his posts - it's just added noise. Fine, then the people who find it to be noise can un-circle him. For the class of people who are largely interested in the same topics as Charlie, it isn't even noise in the first place. Honestly, I don't see this as much of an argument against allowing the Write API.
- jack-r-abbit 15y agoReally? Sure, I don't find his content appealing, but I don't think that has anything to do with the manner in which he posted it. Replace all those tech articles and RT's with links to bacon (or zombie) related content and Mr. Kindel has a shot at being voted president, no?
- jsnell 15y agoThe content might be slightly unappealing recycling of tech news, but the manner in which it's posted is what really hurts there. It'd look crappy anywhere, but especially so on Google+ where posts are long form and links are rich. Like he apparently had some original ideas about the naming of Windows RT, represented in 4 posts each ~100 characters long (one of which seemed to be an "end of split post" marker). It looked the worst of both worlds. And argument so abbreviated it had been reduced to gibberish, but looking very verbose due to having been artificially split.
- jack-r-abbit 15y agoAlthough... those 4 posts about Windows naming could actually be an argument FOR a write API. If he wasn't using a hacked up backdoor, then maybe he'd have an app that could have handled that in one post. But I do see both sides of this. It just sucks when the few idiots ruin it for everyone else. It'd be nice to post via API and it would be nice if people didn't abuse it. ;)