3 ms·
I agree with your wider point here, but transmission losses favor installing nuclear closer to where it’s actually used. Germany’s investment in solar looks du
by Retric 3y ago
I agree with your wider point here, but transmission losses favor installing nuclear closer to where it’s actually used.
Germany’s investment in solar looks dumb in isolation, especially installing panels in northern Germany. However, there was a real environmental argument to be made that subsidies between 2000 and 2015 were critical to drive down PV prices until the economies of worked out. Today I think Germany investing in nuclear over solar is a good idea.
However change has knock on effects. If Germany was producing say 40% of its electricity from Nuclear it would be less interested in importing electricity from France on nights and weekends. Thus France would be facing even lower capacity factors.
Southern France however is a much better location for Solar so it can ramp down nuclear slightly while Germany ramps up nuclear. Net result would be both countries and the environment being better off. http://newquayweather.com/solarpv/images/SolarGIS-Solar-map-Europe-en.png http://newquayweather.com/solarpv/images/SolarGIS-Solar-map-...
PS: What’s actually going to happen is unfortunately going to be influenced by politics, etc and therefore sub optimal.
- seec 3y agoYou are right in that Germany going into nuclear would not benefit France, the I think the broader point is that someone has to do it, to provide some certainty. But as you say if we were to optimise the installations for the strength of the technology on the different territories, things would be different. I do agree that Southern France can support some decent solar farms, but France is already investing in wind also. I think we have to use all the technologies as best as possible, but for now we will still need a guaranteed generation capacity. I think we most likely agree on the technical problems but the thing is there is too much politics around all this...