5 ms·
The government should forbid the labeling of “buy” or “purchase” of anything that can be revoked after the sale. If it can be revoked, then it should be labele
by lotsofpulp 3y ago
The government should forbid the labeling of “buy” or “purchase” of anything that can be revoked after the sale.
If it can be revoked, then it should be labeled “rent”, with the appropriate time frame. Even if it means businesses have to label it “rent - until an unknown time in the future when we go out of business or drop the license or decide to ban you”.
- Ekaros 3y agoAnd it is not like they would not know the first possible date when the license ends. This should be at the sale page and displayed prominently.
- Kon-Peki 3y ago"Rent" is the wrong word. But so is "buy"
- _trampeltier 3y ago"Licence" a product
- CaptainFever 3y agoI'd go with "Rent Indefinitely"
- Kon-Peki 3y ago"Indefinitely" is a vague term. I'm serious - if we really want the FTC or some other more appropriate agency to step in and force a change in terminology, we must have something that is very clear and precise. Otherwise it would never survive a legal challenge.
- thaumasiotes 3y agoWhy is it a problem that it's a vague term? It's defining a vague clause in the contract. You get certain rights until such time as the company decides you don't get them anymore.
- Kon-Peki 3y agoLook it up in the dictionary. In some interpretations, "rent indefinitely" has effectively the same meaning as buy. In others, it could mean what you described. Such transactions would now mean different things to different people. That's not an improvement, and it is unlikely that the federal judiciary would agree that the federal government has the authority to force corporations to make such a change.
- lotsofpulp 3y agoHow is it the wrong word? Renting means to pay to receive temporary use of something.
- alistairSH 3y agoRent usually has an explicit end (like a home lease is for a year or two, sometimes with an auto-renew clause). I posted in a sibling, but I'd do something like "buy" (actually buy, can download, use offline), license (implied forever, but streaming and revokable), and "rent" (streaming, explicit time period). Not set on those phrases, but something like that framework makes more sense that what we have today.
- unsui 3y ago"rent" is the most common mental model that most accurately describes the transaction. It may not have 100% fidelity, but people understand what renting means instinctively. A different term, even "licensing", loses that impact (which is precisely why different language is preferred by the contract holders, to hide the true intent).
- dimitrios1 3y agoSelling leasing/licensing rights is fundamental to many industries and the government itself in many cases. There's already regulation we can use to combat what digital "ownership" is: bait and switch.
- lotsofpulp 3y agoThis is for the non technical, non professional customer who is sitting at home on their TV deciding to “rent” a movie. When presented with two options, Buy or Rent, the former is obviously incorrect if it can be yanked away. Both options are rent, with different durations.
- dimitrios1 3y agoRight. Bait and switch: a scam to mislead buyers, whereby a seller advertises an appealing but ingenuine offer to sell a product or service that the seller does not actually intend to sell (emphasis mine) The "digital good" is the bait. It makes you think you are purchasing ownership like you would with a physical book, or dvd, or game. The bait is effective because it tries to tie itself to the legitimate form and tries to create a false equivalency of buying a physical copy (in some cases, claiming to be "superior" because its greener or whatnot). The solution would be for companies to be explicit in what is actually happening: you are purchasing an indefinite lease on the content subject to terms and exceptions. But I imagine they don't want to do that because it would cause a dent in their business.
- izzydata 3y agoI agree completely. Also in practice there is almost no such thing as a perpetual license as companies can go bankrupt or just revoke your license whenever they want. They should make the exact nature of the agreement known visibly before you spend any money. Eventually prices would have to drop to reflect that you are merely temporarily licensed things. A digital game is not going to be perceived as a $60 value when it is more obviously a temporary license regardless of the length. If a physical copy of a game is valued at $60 that can be sold then a digital temporary license is going to have to be less. In my opinion a lot less.
- jorvi 3y agoI’m fine with digital products being a license, but then they’re a universal license. Meaning that if I bought the license to play Mortal Kombat via Steam, I should be allowed to freely download it on Xbox and PlayStation too. Right now companies gives us all the disadvantages of both a product and a license.
- izzydata 3y agoI'm fine with licenses too. I just think it should be made more obvious to the user and the price should reflect it's non-perpetual nature.
- blooalien 3y ago> ... "and the price should reflect it's non-perpetual nature." (emphasis, mine) This is one thing that bugs the hell outta me for some game publishers. They used to sell a given ("AAA" or whatever) game for like $60, and you got a disc you could use "forever" (as long as the disc lasted, and compatibility with system updates held out), a fancy manual, slick packaging, and sometimes even a poster or other extra goodie. These days, some (many?) of those companies sell a digital download, hosted by Steam's delivery servers, and often nothing else at all, for the same or sometimes even higher price as physical media. For many of these games, reliance on remote DRM services mean that game can disappear any random time in the future for <reasons>. I generally refuse to support them in doing that, so those companies will only ever see my purchase during a sale that brings the price more in line with the reality. I'd rather spend my money with the publishers / developers that value their customers a bit more than as a "fleshy cash machine".
- alistairSH 3y agoI would also accept "license" in place of "rent" for long enough periods to time. Buy = forever (can download and use offline) License = Implied forever, but streaming only and revokable Rent = Streaming only, time period made explicit (day, week, whatever)
- globular-toast 3y agoNah. License is just a weasel word here. Save that for the lawyers. Consumers can buy or rent. There's no in between.
- alistairSH 3y agoThat's probably preferable, but would increase the cost to the consumer, as Sony (or whoever) would need to negotiate permanent deals with Disney (or whoever) instead of the current system. I'm sort of mostly ok with paying $15 for a semi-permanent license to a movie. I'm not ok with paying $40 for a true permanent purchase. Big guess on those prices, as I mostly just stream whatever is available today, so I'm not the target audience either way, I suppose.
- lotsofpulp 3y ago> I'm sort of mostly ok with paying $15 for a semi-permanent license to a movie. Everyone is until the content goes away.
- globular-toast 3y agoIncrease cost compared to what? You can't compare it to current rental systems, you have to compare it to Blu-ray etc. If the cost of buying a digital copy is significantly higher than Blu-ray then people will just stick with Blu-ray. If they don't want to issue such deals at all then that's fine too, but they just can't use the words "buy" or "purchase" at all and can only say "rent".
- scottyah 3y agoMakes sense for objects, but I think they're classifying these goods as services. Would you call it "renting" a massage, because if something happens and they have to stop part-way though you don't get the full massage as expected? Perhaps the "buy" option should have an implied lifetime of ownership, and anything less they have to pay you back (keeping all those sales $ in escrow would sure be a pain)