5 ms·
Do not buy console titles you think are good enough to replay later on consoles except on disc. That's for games. For video content, i'd say do not "buy" anyth
by nottorp 3y ago
Do not buy console titles you think are good enough to replay later on consoles except on disc.
That's for games. For video content, i'd say do not "buy" anything digital. The video content industry has Kafkaesque licensing agreements and a pathological fear of "piracy" so you're guaranteed to lose access either because someone's agreement thrice removed from whoever you "bought" the content from expired, or because the latest copy protection that was in fashion when you "bought" it is now unsupported.
Edit: hey, can your kids inherit your "digital content"? They can inherit your disc collection.
- foxyv 3y agoI've found Amazon Video to be fairly consistent. I don't buy many movies, nor rewatch them often, but they have done well by me. But the video game companies are fond of planned obsolescence and have happily abandoned their customers for decades. Buying a video from Nintendo, Microsoft, or Sony is just asking to have it disappear when they build their next "Store."
- CharlesW 3y agoAmazon is no safer in this respect. https://www.primevideo.com/help?nodeId=202095490#:~:text=Availability%20of%20Purchased,download%20or%20streaming https://www.primevideo.com/help?nodeId=202095490#:~:text=Ava.... "Availability of Purchased Digital Content. Purchased Digital Content will generally continue to be available to you for download or streaming from the Service, as applicable, but may become unavailable due to potential content provider licensing restrictions or for other reasons, and Amazon will not be liable to you if Purchased Digital Content becomes unavailable for further download or streaming."
- foxyv 3y agoI think every service that doesn't allow you to download the video in MP4 will have something like this. Amazon just seems to not have exercised this option on me yet. I can't say the same for the Playstation store. In the future I would love to have a digital collection of DVDs and BluRay backed up to Glacier or something.
- GauntletWizard 3y agoOn you, yet. https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=33010912 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=33010912
- jebarker 3y agoSadly, for video content there's not likely to be any physical ownership within a few years.
- dylan604 3y agoAt this point, I'd say ever. Not sure what you think will happen within a few years that will change.
- jebarker 3y agoRight now there's bluray still, but my understanding is that that's likely to go away too in a few years.
- johnnyanmac 3y agowhy? There are still DVDs being sold of new movies. It's definitely a niche instead of the default at this point, but I don't see Blu-Rays going away entirely for at least a decade.
- jebarker 3y agoIt could be longer, but for example Best Buy is stopping stocking bluray in the US. I believe manufacturers are stopping making players too. If streaming can further close the quality gap then it's hard to imagine it'll last a decade.
- robertlagrant 3y ago> Do not buy console titles you think are good enough to replay later on consoles except on disc. The Xbox store has been great for me. And their backwards compatibility is amazing; I've bought and played Xbox 360 Lego games with my son on the Xbox One.
- lostphilosopher 3y ago> Edit: hey, can your kids inherit your "digital content"? They can inherit your disc collection. With arrival of the holiday season I brought out my Christmas CDs and records from storage. I use these exclusively for music in the house/car/etc., and part of why is that I have kids and I want them to be able to inherit these some day. I understand that physical media degrades and they may not be able to "use" these at some point, but they'll still have the objects and know exactly what versions they "grew up with" and could potentially track down / make replacements. (See also: https://www.goodreads.com/quotes/217710-this-milord-is-my-family-s-axe-we-have-owned-it https://www.goodreads.com/quotes/217710-this-milord-is-my-fa...) I've had family members pass and I've appreciated having physical things I can hang onto, especially things like tools, music, and books where I can use/listen/read and feel a connection with them. (Full disclosure I also prefer physical games, music, and books in general both for my own consumption and for ownership rights reasons.)
- danaris 3y agoThis doesn't have to be an either/or situation: You can have the physical CDs, and use them for as long as they last, and also rip them to have the digital files that you own. Sure, the HDDs and SSDs you store them on will degrade over time, too—but you can transfer the digital files to new ones, with perfect fidelity, as many times as you want.
- dingnuts 3y agoit's actually a reasonably cost-effective way to collect music by going to used book stores and buying used CDs, then ripping them and serving them to yourself with something like Navidrome so that you have the convenience of streaming w/ the physical disk on a shelf somewhere
- mrguyorama 3y agoI can't stand the stupid streaming "But not on THIS service" model of movie watching, so this is how I do movies. $5 on ebay gets you pretty much any DVD you want, $100 or so for a box set of some television show, and ripping DVDs is literally one click. I've wanted to switch to BluRays lately, because HD, and they are barely more expensive than DVDs on ebay, but ripping blurays is NOT trivial.
- generationP 3y ago> The video content industry has Kafkaesque licensing agreements Isn't the same happening with video games? I've seen video games remove some music from their soundtracks as their limited-time licenses lapsed.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- hoherd 3y agoIt's not just video games and music. Adobe Lightroom 6 was sold with a perpetual license, but its mapping and object detection libraries did not have a perpetual license, so even though you can run Adobe Lightroom 6 with your perpetual license today, those features no longer work unless you fiddle with your system clock.
- javman 3y agoBuying discs doesn't protect you anymore. Almost everything requires a server connection and they can require you to upgrade to play. I have a physical copy of Overwatch 1. When Overwatch 2 came out, it was an "upgrade" to Overwatch 1, and they simultaneously killed all Overwatch 1 servers. Nobody can play Overwatch 1 anymore. Maybe Nintendo Switch is the way. It seems physical copies only protect you on platforms where offline use is standard.
- nottorp 3y agoI'm talking about single player games. Multiplayer used to be fun but now they're all IAP fests so I ignore them and have no opinion on them. Edit: and duh. When you buy a game that's only played online you're dependent on the servers staying up. It's logical. There are other kinds of games though.
- pixl97 3y ago>I'm talking about single player games. This means nothing, there have been piles of single player games that have required a connection check before working. Sim City 4 was an example of this. And, even buying it and not having that check doesn't mean that it won't be updated to require a server (you have an actual disk to reinstall right, because the original installer may disappear too).
- piperswe 3y agoSimCity (2013), not SimCity 4. SimCity 4 was the last beloved SimCity game, released in 2003.
- nottorp 3y agoYou're talking about EA, Ubisoft and Rockstar titles there. Case closed. Incidentally, if you must get something from those 3, they're forbidden to require an account on at least the PlayStation. Not sure about XBox.
- johnnyanmac 3y ago
- treyd 3y agoThe problem is that so many games ship with day-1 updates since they ship on disc buggy and in some cases unplayable. If you need to play the game on a different console that hasn't downloaded the updates and the servers have been shut down then you're doomed to a worse experience. Piracy (and a PC) is the only option at that point.
- dylan604 3y agoTo me, this pretty much makes the physical disc a hardware dongle proof of purchase type of item more than a source of code for the game.
- kmeisthax 3y agoFunnily enough the Nintendo Switch actually fixes this. Consoles can share updates peer-to-peer, and it's actually super nifty for local multiplayer groups.
- treyd 3y agoI'm really surprised by that, but that's neat. The next step would be allowing users to export the (probably signed and encrypted) update packages onto their own media for backup on their own terms.
- BashiBazouk 3y agoI used to be in the physical disk camp until during a move my ps4 and media collection was stolen. Bought a new ps4, deactivated the stolen ps4 from the account, activated the new ps4 and was able to download all the digital games. The disk games I had to repurchase which in many cases I never bothered. There were only a handful of games that were worth it. No system is perfect...
- nottorp 3y agoYes, but in this case whoever stole your stuff wasn't the person that sold it to you :)
- BashiBazouk 3y agoOn the other hand they did replace what was stolen from me unlike the vendors of physical versions...
- BobaFloutist 3y agoWhy is this my problem? Personally, I think companies should simply not lie about what they're offering for my money. To be honest I wouldn't be surprised if this Playstation move ends in a lawsuit.
- johnnyanmac 3y ago>For video content, i'd say do not "buy" anything digital. the streaming wars more or less solved that problem already. No one is even pretending to sell you content on Netflix, D+, Hulu, Paramount, etc. And that is what's reigning surpreme. >hey, can your kids inherit your "digital content"? They can inherit your disc collection. in theory, sure. They can take control of your accounts. I'm guessing a kid that far off is about as likely to log into my old PSN as they are to hunt down an ancient PS3/4 to play an old disc though.