5 ms·
> If he wants to be remembered as the dude global labor had to organize against, I mean, the bar is already pretty low where he's at but perhaps we have yet to
by andsoitis 3y ago
> If he wants to be remembered as the dude global labor had to organize against, I mean, the bar is already pretty low where he's at but perhaps we have yet to hit bedrock. Probably with a bit to be said about dying a hero or living long enough to become the villain through the appropriate lens.
Highly recommend watching the full interview that Andrew Ross Sorkin did with Elon Musk (it is the one where he told advertisers to go fuck themselves) - https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=2BfMuHDfGJI https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=2BfMuHDfGJI
It is wide ranging and fascinating. In it, he explicitly says that he doesn't do things in order for other people to like him. Instead, he focuses on making the best products (e.g. best cars, best rockets, best satellite).
- marricks 3y agoMANY things he does are explicitly to be liked. That’s why he posts all the time, goes on interviews, shows up on SNL. Buys a social media company then burns company hours on figuring out why he isn’t the most viewed person on it. He really, really, wants to be internet liked, that’s he claims he doesn’t care about.
- ethbr1 3y agoI'd hazard it's more important to him to be famous, whatever the sentiment, rather than liked.
- marricks 3y agoNo, he wouldn’t get into so many mudslinging fights if he just cared about being famous. He desperately wants to be liked and thought of as cool.
- ehvatum 3y agoThere is a melancholy, defeated aspect to saying someone with such notable imagination and success as Elon is motivated only by insecurity.
- marricks 3y agoI think many deeply insecure tech bros relate to him so much because they don't realize they themselves are that same sort of insecure. Also, I never said he was only motivated by it, he is just obviously extremely insecure.
- vkou 3y agoI don't know what motivates him, but his outward behaviour is that of an incredibly insecure individual, who is constantly seeking validation, and often throws a tantrum when subject to criticism.
- ClumsyPilot 3y agoIt's possible that Elon in his 20's was a better person than Elon today. People change, and not always for the better. In Particular, get drunk on power, surrounded by yes men, etc.
- andsoitis 3y ago> MANY things he does are explicitly to be liked. That’s why he posts all the time, goes on interviews, shows up on SNL. Buys a social media company to goose his number of views. > He really, really, wants to be internet liked, that’s he claims he doesn’t care about. If that were true, then why consciously piss so many people off?
- cultureswitch 3y agoLiked by certain interest groups and not others. Despite really disliking Elon as a whole, one thing I like about him is that he expresses himself like a human being, contrary to most of the HR/PR/D&I drones who claim he's an antisemite now.
- marricks 3y agoNot having a PR team is cool but it’s really just a doorway to seeing how most of these folks really are and it’s just desperately wanting to be seen as Tony Stark.
- davidw 3y ago> claim he's an antisemite We saw the tweets (it wasn't just the one) he boosted and agreed with. You can absolutely be a 'real' and authentic person without promoting that kind of garbage. I don't think I'm alone in having previously thought he was perhaps a bit eccentric, but involved in some cool stuff. I lost a lot of respect for him though.
- andsoitis 3y agoIt sounds like you've made up your mind that he is antisemitic, so this might be in vain, but see: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=38544345 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=38544345
- davidw 3y agoI read what I read, on multiple occasions, on the platform itself, rather than reported by some 3rd party. We all screw up, and IDK, maybe once could be like "uh, sorry, I was really high and not at all myself and I did this thing", but a repeated pattern is enough to convince me that where there's smoke, there's fire. I don't take any pleasure in it. I preferred thinking he was a bit weird (but who isn't) and doing some cool things.
- andsoitis 3y ago
- suoduandao3 3y agoI think he wants to be polarizing. It's not the same thing.
- scythe 3y agoI think that his political bloviating (to put it mildly) is best explained by Matt Levine's theory, that he wants to expand Tesla's appeal to conservatives. Getting plugged by Ramaswamy at the last Republican debate to cheers from the audience suggests it isn't the worst strategy. But Tesla's core product will still have issues with this segment, because conservatives are particularly suspicious of heavily computerized cars. However, putting Tesla directly into the political line of fire with the union fight seems more like a case of personal beliefs run amok. Many companies making cars in the United States run non-union shops, including most of the Japanese ones. Their behavior abroad doesn't usually create a problem. But the more that Tesla itself is positioned as a political entity, rather than a car company that happens to have a conservative CEO (which didn't kill Taco Bell), the more he invites the kind of backlash that could really hurt. European regulators watching him scorn their beliefs may take that into account, fairly or not, if they are called on to mediate this union dispute. It seems like a very risky overextension.
- rchaud 3y ago> I think that his political bloviating (to put it mildly) is best explained by Matt Levine's theory, that he wants to expand Tesla's appeal to conservatives. Or, he's a 50yo man with multiple divorces, few personal friends to vent to, and numerous children he's not on speaking terms with. He just joined the millions of men his age that have the same baggage and the free time to spend bloviating online about wokeness.
- ExoticPearTree 3y agoI find it funny that you think he should not be able to do whatever he wants with his companies. He bought Twitter and it was his prerogative to direct everyone there to tell him why he's not number one on that platform. He did not buy Twitter to make money.
- archagon 3y agoWhere exactly did the poster say he should not be able to do so? It’s just vain.
- andsoitis 3y ago> Where exactly did the poster say he should not be able to do so? It is implied with the phrase “burns company hours”
- archagon 3y agoAll I see is the implication that it’s a giant waste of everyone’s time.
- andsoitis 3y agoI hear your sarcasm, but it is also worth to be skeptical of the claim in that same sentence that “to direct everyone there”…
- ImPostingOnHN 3y agothere isn't any sarcasm there, just a poster pointing out the implication that elmu's twitter antics are a giant waste of everyone’s time. elmu's tasking of his staff to figure out why his trolling wasn't making him popular enough was a real thing, and a good example of his time wasting abilities in furtherance of his desperate, desperate, desperate need to feel popular.
- ClumsyPilot 3y ago
- TerrifiedMouse 3y agoThe guy seems to be a textbook case of narcissistic personality disorder. https://www.mayoclinic.org/diseases-conditions/narcissistic-personality-disorder/symptoms-causes/syc-20366662 https://www.mayoclinic.org/diseases-conditions/narcissistic-...
- artursapek 3y agoRemember when he wedged himself into that Thai cave rescue mission, and talked shit about one of the divers on Twitter? Yeah, that was definitive proof that the man is an attention addict. It's sad because he's a brilliant businessman.
- jebarker 3y agoHis behavior on X seems to contradict that though. What does any of that have to do with building the best products?
- andsoitis 3y ago> His behavior on X seems to contradict that though. Then why piss off advertisers?
- jebarker 3y agoBecause that grows his popularity with other groups. Same tactics Trump uses.
- AlexandrB 3y agoYou're trying to find a rational reason for impulsive behavior. There is no "why". He thought the anti-semitic meme was funny/right without thinking too much about it. Then he got mad at advertisers for, as he thought, trying to rein him in. If you want proof that Elon isn't too concerned about making good products, try using Twitter/X without being logged in. The experience is significantly worse than before the takeover.
- andsoitis 3y ago> You're trying to find a rational reason for impulsive behavior. There is no "why". He thought the anti-semitic meme was funny/right without thinking too much about it. If you cared to watch the the interview I linked to above with Andrew Ross Sorkin at the NYT Dealbook summmit, you will hear three things: a) remorse for the dumb thing he said (he says it is probably the worst mistake he has made) b) when you say a lot, you're abound to say foolish things and that he has c) he actually re-explained his clarification of the logic that was widely labeled as antisemitic but that people have chosen to ignore it. If you think this is a cop out, look at (a) again, where he expresses remorse for having said what he said in the way he said it. > Then he got mad at advertisers for, as he thought, trying to rein him in. Yes, when people try to limit what you say (beyond the law) then it is natural to be upset about it. > If you want proof that Elon isn't too concerned about making good products, try using Twitter/X without being logged in. The experience is significantly worse than before the takeover. Let's talk in 3 years. Meanwhile, I'll point you to Tesla (Model Y is the best-selling car of any kind across the world), SpaceX, and Starlink. I don't know about you, but I would classify these as best in class.
- ponector 3y ago...best cars, best rockets, best social network for spreading propaganda and false narratives.
- andsoitis 3y ago> ...best social network for spreading propaganda and false narratives. You might have that view of YouTube in general but this is an interview during the New York Times Dealbook summit.
- eggy 3y agoAgreed, and if Norway, Sweden, and Denmark, are for the people, let the people decide whether want to buy a Tesla and support Elon. Cutting off shipping to their rightful owners sounds like you are curtailing your own citizens from living as they please. Would be interesting if they and other countries unions had stopped the shipments of iPhones to their citizen consumers due to the working conditions and no unions allowed at the time in China. I am sure a lot of sanctimonious iPhone users would be caught in a conundrum.
- The_Colonel 3y agoAs I understand, this is not a top-down decision by the government, but unions and their workers.
- fxtentacle 3y agoYou can still drive from Sweden to Germany and buy a Tesla there, if you care enough about it. BTW, you will always reach the point where you need to "curtail[..] your own citizens from living as they please" or else you'll end up with kids blowing up your stuff just for the fun of it.
- eggy 3y agoI am not equating citizen adults with children, and I do not believe in trying to legislate intelligence. More in the classic libertarian sense that if what I enjoy is not directly harming you or taking away your rights, keep to your own business. Here it is a Scandinavian choosing to buy a Tesla with no concern or argument concerning labor unions. BTW, the UAW sucks.
- mint2 3y agoThey aren’t protesting working Tesla conditions outside their countries. They’re protesting how Tesla treats the workers/unions inside Sweden.
- ljm 3y agoThe capitalist idea of voting with your wallet doesn't really work that way, it's throwing away the power of collective bargaining and instead leaving every man for himself, which would be an instant race to the bottom. The workers are unionised because if they weren't, Tesla would be leading the charge on torching whatever rights workers had previously agreed to. More countries could stand to do this, to show that it is the people who have power over corporations, not the other way around.
- simion314 3y agoIn this one he admitted something about he said some very dumb shit on tweeter, so maybe his fans can accept that he does say dumb shit and stop defending that, let his lawyers and PR team defend him. IMO soon he will admit all this anti union stuff was also dumb.
- andsoitis 3y ago> so maybe his fans can accept that he does say dumb shit and stop defending that For what it’s worth, I don’t consider myself a fan, for the simple reason that I think no human is perfect or likable (Steve Jobs, Bach, Napoleon, Mother Theresa, to name a few). Instead it is better to evaluate someone’s ideas and impact. What is disappointing to me is that we (I count myself here too) make up a rigid opinion of people based on memes, sound bites, unnuanced morsels of information, rather than demonstrating deep curiosity. And so my responses on this thread should be viewed through the lens of surfacing more nuance and curiosity, rather than cheap and absolutist opinions that lack nuance. More conversation please.
- fallingknife 3y agoI like people who say what they mean and don't care what other people think even when they say things I disagree with. I hate people who read from PR scripts. So why would I not defend it?
- simion314 3y agoI do not understand, you like Elon because he says dumb shit, so you try to defend the dumb shit? How do you do that? You try to make the dumb shit look smart or you try to excuse Elon because maybe he was drunk/tired/drugged when he said that dumb shit ? When he admits it was dumb and his fans argued for hours that it was smart how do they feel?
- fallingknife 3y agoWho doesn't say dumb shit sometimes? Why would that bother me?
- forgetfreeman 3y agoStares in soviet-era car body fitment issues. Best what now?