3 ms·
> If we take this to an extreme, doesn't content just not get made? I can't speak for anybody else but my content will still get made. > Do you think Google i
by jacquesm 3y ago
> If we take this to an extreme, doesn't content just not get made?
I can't speak for anybody else but my content will still get made.
> Do you think Google is going to go to a model where things are freely accessible without ads?
Maybe, maybe not, whose to say what Google will do. Maybe they will value the influence or the goodwill more than the lack of income. Maybe some of the content will be free and other bits will be walled off (effectively this is already the case with youtube music). Maybe there will be less MFY content and that's perfectly ok with me, 99.99% of it is crap anyway. Youtuber isn't a profession I recognize.
> Feels like even when a company provides a way to get rid of ads, many people still won't pay.
And that's ok.
> They _say_ they will, but I find often people will want to substitute their own terms (Well, youtube premium is $x, but I think it's only worth $y, so I'm going to just block ads completely).
Yes, or you pay and you still get ads...
- CubsFan1060 3y ago> I can't speak for anybody else but my content will still get made. How will your content get served? If you say you'll just pay to serve it, I think that's a fine answer.
- EA-3167 3y agoUnless you're a VERY large and successful YT channel, you aren't making bank on YT itself, it's merch and sponsorships, Patreon and so on that make the money. Monetized Twitch-like feeds are another winner, and again not dependent on YT monetization.
- CubsFan1060 3y agoAren't these all VERY tightly integrated? They can sell merch and sponsorships _because_ of YouTube in the first place?
- bluefirebrand 3y agoThe point is that many successful YouTubers wouldn't be broke if they stopped making ad revenue from YouTube, because they make most of their money elsewhere anyways. Which means they would continue making content
- Ekaros 3y agoThat does not answer the question. There is floatplane and Nebula, but beyond those where will be the content be hosted and will those revenue stream actually cover those hosting/development costs and running the site? And on other hand if users are paying you something, would they not expect not to have to watch through mediocre sponsorships?
- jacquesm 3y agoThe 10 views my videos get I can afford. Just like I can afford my web hosting.
- bko 3y agoYouTube is incredibly expensive to run which explains why there's such little competition. Think about it, anyone can host gigs of videos perpetually indexed for free. What percentage of videos have fewer than 100 views? Google has killed off profitable projects. If you think they'll dump tens of billions every year hosting videos that no one watches, you're kidding yourself. And what we noticed with paying is that people are very unwilling to pay even a small amount for a service. For instance FB makes around over $50 per user in North America. What percentage of users do you think would pay $50 a year to use Facebook?
- account42 3y ago> YouTube is incredibly expensive to run which explains why there's such little competition. So? That's their problem. > Google has killed off profitable projects. If you think they'll dump tens of billions every year hosting videos that no one watches, you're kidding yourself. Can't wait for YouTube to die. Hopefully the replacement will be less centralized and not beholden to a single american company. > And what we noticed with paying is that people are very unwilling to pay even a small amount for a service. Most "services" are not worth the effort needed to pay them, the amount doesn't even come into it. This is also a self-created issue. Google et al have trained people to not pay by dumping money into these "free" services to kill the competition. Now they are upset that people don't want to pay them? I can't find a violin tiny enough to express my compassion for them. > For instance FB makes around over $50 per user in North America. What percentage of users do you think would pay $50 a year to use Facebook? So? They make $0 off of me. I don't care how much they can or cannot make with ads, that doesn't make ads acceptable.
- concordDance 3y ago> tens of billions every year hosting videos That seems way too high. There's something like half a trillion hours watched per year. Does it really cost almost $0.10 for an hour of video?
- jacquesm 3y agoYoutube is hilarious, on the one hand they keep forcing autoplayed content on you and then they match that with a popup that inquires if you are still watching the video.