3 ms·
Replacing like for like should be a fairly easy job. But replacing between different systems does seem to be a nightmare. It's interesting that Americans are r
by pjc50 3y ago
Replacing like for like should be a fairly easy job. But replacing between different systems does seem to be a nightmare.
It's interesting that Americans are retrofitting them into HVAC systems, while in the UK we're trying to retrofit into natgas/water based systems, and seemingly the Scandinavians have gone for .. I'm not sure but it seems cheaper?
I upgraded to a "hybrid" system because it was the least cost / minimal change, so I continue to have natgas hot water which can optionally heat the radiators if the control unit deems it economic (no, it doesn't have dynamic pricing). And that was still £15,000 even though it could reuse all the existing radiators. Apparently having 8mm "microbore" copper plumbing is a problem for "low temperature" heat pump systems, because they rely on higher throughput.
At the end of winter I'll write-up my bills and evaluate the experience.
- kwhitefoot 3y agoIn Scandinavia we use air to air heat pumps. We generally don't have central heating of any kind so we aren't so tempted to try to shoehorn the heat pump into a system based on hot water. Air to air is much cheaper and is more efficient because it doesn't need to raise the temperature of the working fluid so much and doesn't require a big fluid to water heat exchanger. I'm having a Toshiba Polar 35 heat pump installed soon. Nominal output 3.5 kW, maximum output 7 kW. The total cost is 28 kNOK, about 2.6 kUSD, 2 kGBP. Should be enough for the whole ground floor of about 80 square metres.
- khimaros 3y agowhich refrigerant is used in this?
- kwhitefoot 3y agoR-32 [1] "Difluoromethane, also called difluoromethylene, HFC-32 Methylene Fluoride or R-32, " [2] [1] https://www.toshibavarmepumper.no/globalassets/inriver/resources/r106513-datablad-energietikett-toshiba-polar-25.pdf https://www.toshibavarmepumper.no/globalassets/inriver/resou... [2] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Difluoromethane https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Difluoromethane
- amluto 3y agoDo mean air-to-refrigerant-to-air or do you literally mean a big box with ducts coming out? The latter is called a “packaged terminal” heat pump in the US, and they haven’t really caught on except in cheap hotels.
- kwhitefoot 3y agoIt's two parts, the compressor in a box with a big fan on the outside and a box on the wall indoors containing a refrigerant to air heat exchanger and a fan. The two are connected by pipes, typically three or four metres long, containing the refrigerant. So yes, air-to-refrigerant-to-air. But your packaged terminal heat pump is also air-to-refrigerant-to-air. Both are just refrigerators turned inside out. "“Packaged terminal heat pump” means a packaged terminal air conditioner that utilizes reverse cycle refrigeration as its prime heat source, " [1] [1] https://www1.eere.energy.gov/buildings/appliance_standards/standards.aspx?productid=46&action=viewcurrent https://www1.eere.energy.gov/buildings/appliance_standards/s... Most heat pumps installed in dwellings in Norway are capable of cooling the building as well as heating it. This is the one that will be installed in my house (in Norwegian, Google does a good translation job): https://www.toshibavarmepumper.no/varmepumper-luft-luft/toshiba-polar-25/ https://www.toshibavarmepumper.no/varmepumper-luft-luft/tosh...
- amluto 3y agoWow, that “packaged terminal” page is terrible. They’re a single object, and the refrigerant doesn’t leave the object. Outdoor air flows through part of it, and indoor air flows through another part of it.
- balfirevic 3y agoHow do you deal with ventilation? Central unit, or a device per room? Or just opening windows? :-) > Air to air is much cheaper and is more efficient because it doesn't need to raise the temperature of the working fluid so much and doesn't require a big fluid to water heat exchanger It might still be worth it to go with water based system if you're going to have underfloor heating. It requires lower water temperatures, so efficiency hit is not that big compared to air-to-air systems (if there is a hit at all). As a bonus, there are some savings from using the heat pump to heat the hot water for showering and you get the supreme cozyness of warm floors. On the other hand, now you need some other way of cooling in the summer as underfloor system will not work for that.
- kwhitefoot 3y agoWe rarely need cooling. Average annual temperature is 14°C, maximum last year was 31.5°C in July but the average that month was 17.8°C :-)
- fragmede 3y agoHopefully that lasts! Where I live it didn't use to get hot, so no one has air conditioning, but for the past three years we've been hit with a week of 32°C/90°f + temperature. Those that can afford it have added air conditioning, but as global climate change kicks in, I'm expecting more extreme weather to become the norm.
- ChatGTP 3y agoI don't want to be rude, but the fact people install are conditioners for 1 week of 32°C is absolutely ridiculous. The majority of the world deal with these temps for months on end without A/C.
- fragmede 3y agoI mean, not everyone went out and bought one, a lot of people just put up with it. But a window AC is roughly $200, which fits within the disposable income budget of the middle class.
- stetrain 3y agoIt's fairly common in the US to have central AC plus a gas furnace. Retrofitting the AC with a heat pump lets you move away from the gas system.
- dcuthbertson 3y agoReplacing an AC system with a heat pump might provide you with an avenue to move away from a gas furnace, but I found that avenue to be very expensive. I live in New England and in June 2022 I replaced a broken down AC system with a heat pump. The company installed an electric supplemental heating unit, because the heat pump can work down to only 25F (about -4C) and during Winter it will definitely get colder than that. However, last Winter cost me about $800 more than any previous Winter here (I've lived in the same house in New England for the past 33 years). After a pipe burst in the baseboard heating system (because it wasn't running, it was only -10F outside, and the pipe passed through a poorly insulated area of the house), I had the HVAC company rewire the system to use the gas-fired, forced hot water baseboard system as the backup. I look forward to much lower heating costs this Winter.
- crazygringo 3y agoModern heat pumps are able to work at much colder temperatures than that. I understand your bill went up because the backup electric heating was kicking in. I don't understand why in 2022 it would even be an option to get a heat pump installed that only works down to 25°F. That's super outdated tech.