4 ms·
This project is a good reminder I really should finish that LiIon article that I've had on the back burner ever since I built the long range e-bike. Some obser
by jacquesm 3y ago
This project is a good reminder I really should finish that LiIon article that I've had on the back burner ever since I built the long range e-bike.
Some observations just from the pictures:
- corners of the nickel strips are not rounded, chances of cutting through the insulation of the cells, and in the high res pictures you can see some places where that might already be happening.
- welds are all over the place, from nice penetration to very shallow, possibly welds with high resistance, possibly burn through of the interconnects.
- physical construction of the pack is dangerous, no protection against impact if the whole construct is dropped. If it ever is dropped I would recommend immediately placing it in a fireproof container that is not indoors. And don't transport it in elevators or vehicles.
- no insulation rings between the tops of the batteries and the metal strips! That's really asking for trouble. You can see more than one spot on the pictures where the metal strip is directly in contact with the plastic and the welding process has likely further reduced the safety margin. The plastic sheathing of the cells is not enough protection for this kind of construction. Any insulation failure there means that you now have shorted an unfused pod and that pretty much guarantees a fire.
- balancing wires cross and pass over parts of the pack at a different voltage, a short of a balance wire can set off a thermal runaway.
- in general, wire management needs to be substantially improved if this is ever to become safe. Way too many wires that carry wildly different voltages cross and recross, especially close to soldering joints that might cause issues because the wires tend to shift inside the insulation if they're under tension while soldering.
I'm both impressed and horrified, this is the most clear illustration ever that I've seen for 'knows enough to be dangerous'. Laying out the sense/balance wires on a pack is a lot of work if you want to do it safely and even the pros (looking at you, Bosch) get this wrong. The result is that if ever one of the sense wires shorts out that it will essentially become a fuse and the energy imparted to the cells may just be enough to set off a thermal runaway. Wire management on the project here is terrible.
- spacecadet 3y agoNice comment. I was scrolling and going "ooh looks like a bomb", "oooooh", "oh yes thats basically a bomb".
- jacquesm 3y agoIf you like this kind of bomb then you should check out the various diy powerwall channels and blogs. Some of those I can't watch without yelling at the screen.
- Loughla 3y agoThey're amazingly funny. Just the overall sense of "oh it's just a matter of time before this person loses their house in a fire." Yes mr. power, that small sandbag will stop the inevitable fire. We put in solar this year, and my neighbor, who I used to think was reasonable, walked me through the MASSIVELY unsafe powerwall he installed after learning on YouTube how to do that.
- jacquesm 3y agoTime to move... I have a freestanding house for a reason. I've seen more than one place go up in flames because someone figured their attic gardening project would compensate for the mortgage.
- Loughla 3y agoLuckily we're country neighbors, so he's ~3/4 of a mile away. I'll be able to see the flames, but other than that, I'm good. If he was connected to my house, or even close like in a suburb, I would absolutely report him to someone. But because he's not, I just chuckle to myself and appreciate that he has no spouse or kids to die in the inevitable fire.
- jacquesm 3y agoI think part of the problem is that on the outside Lithium Ion cells look no different than any other battery to a lay person. They probably assign roughly the same danger level to them that they would to a C-cell, rather than the conveniently pocket sized handgrenade that it really is.
- onetimeuse92304 3y agoWell... yes. There are amateur projects and then there are amateur projects with a little bit of "spice" on it where you have to grow up and mature with your process just a tiny bit. For example anything having to do with AC or rechargeable cells goes in this category in my book. I also throw in sensitive electronics that needs a little bit of ESD safety.
- jacquesm 3y agoElectronics that aren't ESD safe will not burn down your house though. This just might.
- jrockway 3y agoYeah, ESD safety is just a yield management strategy. "It sure is expensive when every 100th board comes into QA dead." Being careless with lithium ion batteries is "your house burns down, and your insurance company won't pay for it" levels of dangerous; possibly the largest financial risk you can take on as an individual! It's also bad if your family dies in a fire. Personally I just stick with commercially-made solutions from reputable brands here. You want someone your insurance company can sue when it blows up! I have never had any bad luck with lithium ion / lithium polymer batteries, but Reddit randomly shows me r/spicypillows from time to time, and ... it's pretty scary. What would you do if your laptop starts blowing up like a balloon? Have a plan!
- rokweom 3y ago[flagged]
- jacquesm 3y agoI've sent the draft article out to multiple people that have asked for it. The reason why I 'don't go ahead and write that article' is that I want to make sure that I get it right and that takes a ton of time, much more than these comments. And there are a lot of competing demands on my time. As for there being other ones like it: I have looked for them but have not been able to find one that goes to the level of depth that I think the subject requires. Especially because if you get it wrong people will be exposed to serious risks. So I hope you will forgive me my sense of caution. Finally: I think the tone of your comment is out of line. If you don't like my contributions to HN feel free to ignore them, if you have a factual issue you'd like to discuss about any of the comments here then you are welcome to do so.
- Covzire 3y agoJust an observation but you started your post with a bit of a humble brag and then declared everything you saw wrong which is always a risky combination. I've been interested in this kind of stuff for awhile so I definitely appreciate reminders on how to properly wire and contain dangerous battery cells don't get me wrong but I think it just came across a bit differently then you intended.
- jacquesm 3y agoWhat humble brag would that be? It's just the way it is: this article has been sitting in 'draft' mode mostly because I realize how much work it is to do this properly. But researching it and building that e-bike pack (which still functions flawlessly, by the way, if you want an actual brag) has given me some appreciation for how complex this stuff really is. > I think it just came across a bit differently then you intended. To spell it out: don't mess with Lithium Ion unless you are willing to invest a lot of time into educating yourself and a lot of money into tooling. Chances are that by the time you've done the first you will no longer have to do the second because you will abandon your project. Unless you're an idiot like me. And I still wouldn't keep that e-bike in the house or sell it to someone else. And it's probably safer than a pack bought in the store, I just couldn't live with the responsibility.