3 ms·
>Beeper will fight it either way. That sounds nice and all, but what happens when the first bill comes due from their legal team?
by dylan604 3y ago
>Beeper will fight it either way.
That sounds nice and all, but what happens when the first bill comes due from their legal team?
- canada_dry 3y agoThe Streisand effect will certainly boost enrollment if Apple sues.
- brokencode 3y agoI’d donate to a legal fund on this personally. I think a lot of people and large corporations would like to see Apple have to make concessions here. I think if it comes to it, Apple will wind up looking very bad in a trial. Their behavior here is deeply anticompetitive. iMessage is just too important to modern text communication to be as locked down as it is. If Apple doesn’t want to make an Android app, they should at least make an API so other developers can.
- Domenic_S 3y ago> iMessage is just too important to modern text communication to be as locked down as it is. What do you mean; if a private company creates something, and enough people buy/use it, at some point it becomes a common good? I like the idea of iMessage being open, but I don't like the idea of forcing Apple under government threat to open it
- brokencode 3y agoI don’t know what you mean by “common good” in this context, but if a company has a dominant market position and uses its power to cripple competition, then it falls within antitrust laws. iMessage is so important today, especially to young Americans, that its exclusivity to iOS has become a significant barrier to Android or other operating systems from being competitive. It’s up to regulators and the court system to decide whether that is a violation of antitrust law. But if it is, then yes, the government should force them to open it. That’s what it means to enforce antitrust law.
- mardef 3y agoI feel so old. What is it that I'm missing out in iMessage that is so important? Honest question, I've been texting since t9 and have never owned an Apple device.
- lxgr 3y agoIt provides a much better group messaging experience than SMS (you can see who’s in a group and add and remove people), delivery/read receipts, better image quality, is encrypted (although that gets somewhat negated by automatic iCloud backups), and is free as long as a data connection is available. Of course many other messengers offer most of these features too, but for some reason, no alternative has been able to establish itself in the US.
- chefandy 3y agoiMessage was heavily integrated into the ios flow when sms was the dominant mobile text messaging system. It's not special, and that's the point. It just worked the way people want texting to work as smart phones gained momentum, and iPhones have so much of the market share that it's way more irritating to use a separate messaging app when you can't change the default integration on ios. I miss the convenience of heavily integrated iMessage comms at least twice per day.
- lxgr 3y agoInteresting, I use both Messages and a few third-party messengers, and I wouldn't say that Messages is integrated more deeply with iOS, in the way that e.g. Safari and Mail were for a long time (before you could re-associate http and mailto URLs). The share sheet just shows my most-frequently-used messengers, as well as direct contact names for my most important contacts, no matter what messenger they're actually on. The only thing I can't yet do on my third-party messenger is initiate messages from my Apple Watch, but that's presumably due to a lack of a native watch app more than anything.
- brokencode 3y ago
- not2b 3y agoYes, governments can require interoperability and can limit monopolies. That's how antitrust laws work, like it or not. But if you want to get all libertarian, why should companies be able to use government power (as in courts, DMCA and the like) to shut down smaller companies that reverse-engineer their protocols?
- LesZedCB 3y agocoughs in AT&T
- Domenic_S 3y agoI have a hard time believing that the folks who were smart enough to do all this work somehow forgot that lawyers cost money
- dylan604 3y agoi don't disagree, but nobody can compete with the money Apple can spend. not every David can find a Rainmaker when competing against Goliath. Goliath still wins a lot. He was a champion after all
- chatmasta 3y agoI imagine they'd use some of the $16m+ they raised in VC money to pay the lawyers...