2 ms·
> so users don't know what the buttons do. They do, though. People are able to figure out commercial websites orders of magnitude more easily than figuring out
by crazygringo 3y ago
> so users don't know what the buttons do.
They do, though. People are able to figure out commercial websites orders of magnitude more easily than figuring out how to fill out their 1040.
> They need to just make their stuff reliably work
Which is what UX and design help with.
> Basic HTML with minimal optional styles checks all of those boxes.
It doesn't. Layout and design are tools that help with clarify and ease-of-use.
> you see that you really just need most websites to be a more convenient version of paper forms.
Nothing could be farther from the truth.
Do you similarly think that your iPhone or desktop interface would be improved if the UX was "a more convenient version of paper forms"?
Paper forms are an extremely limiting form of UX. Why would you ever want to throw out all of the progress we've made with usability?
- ndriscoll 3y agoFilling out your 1040 is "hard" because people don't understand what the words mean, there's a 100 page instruction manual that defines the terms, and it might require filling out other forms too (which you might just need to know somehow that you need to fill them out too). Other than that, the actual UI design is straightforward. You write/type numbers into numbered boxes, top to bottom, occasionally referring back to numbers you've already completed. You could progressively enhance with automatic calculations for relevant fields, but hand calculations work as a fallback. Reliability is unrelated from UI, except insofar as simple UIs are easy to build, and therefore less likely to break. A paper form 1040 is perfectly reliable; it's not going to burst into flames when you're filling it out. As I said above, I couldn't even fill out my payment form on a modern site. It did not work at all. The form did not appear. That is not reliable. It also makes no sense if you know the page is ultimately using HTML, and that HTML has forms built directly in, and they always work fine. And yeah, when I'm doing something like making a payment, setting up a transfer, doing my taxes, or even ordering a pizza, something like a slightly advanced paper form (e.g. with drop downs for options) would work great on my phone or desktop. Have a special request for your pizza that's not on the form? Put it in the free-form instructions box. The "progress" we've made in the last few years is that I can't do bank transfers without switching browsers, which requires selecting a "to" account from a drop-down, a "from" account from a drop-down, and typing an amount. I don't see how something so basic can be so hard to do correctly. There's literally no need for any javascript at all. I don't see the usability gain from whatever they're doing.