5 ms·
Are you under the impression that you're assigning homework to students? I'm asking for an explanation that goes beyond "they make money, and I don't understan
by yummyfajitas 15y ago
Are you under the impression that you're assigning homework to students?
I'm asking for an explanation that goes beyond "they make money, and I don't understand how, they must be ripping people off!"
e.g. Alice wants to sell at $10.00. Bob wants to buy at $10.05. They could simply trade with each other, but if Eve gets her way, Eve will buy from Alice at $10.00, and then sell to Bob for $10.05, making $0.05 on each share that would otherwise have gone to Alice
What's missing from your explanation is time. If you actually wrote out a specific explanation involving limit orders (like I suggested), you would immediately have seen that.
If Alice wanted to sell at $10.00 and Bob wanted to buy at $10.05, they would have already traded. The millisecond Bob's order hit the market, he would have filled Alice's order (or she would have filled his, depending on which was bigger). Eve never had any ability to participate.
If Eve played any role, there was a time delay. At 12:20, Eve put an order BUY(price=$10.00, quantity=100, time=12:20) onto the market. Alice chose to sell to her at 12:30 because she wanted to trade immediately, with no risk of her order being unfilled. After buying her stocks, Eve turned around and placed a SELL(price=$10.05, quantity=100, time=12:30:01) order. At 12:40, Bob comes along and places an order BUY($10.05, quantity=100, time=12:40), which is filled by Eve's order.
If Alice wanted to hold out for $10.05 she could have. She chose not to, because she didn't want to run the risk of Bob never showing up. Eve didn't "scrape pennies" from Alice and Bob, Alice paid her $0.05 to take the risk of Bob never showing up.
- dpark 15y ago> I'm asking for an explanation that goes beyond "they make money, and I don't understand how, they must be ripping people off!" I didn't say that anyone was ripped off. There's nothing inherently wrong with being a middle-man in a transaction. I just don't see that HFTs are adding any real value. > What's missing from your explanation is time. You're pretending that Alice and Bob placed their orders 20 minutes apart. That's not the game HFTs play. HFTs are playing games of milliseconds. It's not 12:20 and 12:40. It's 12:20:00.200 and 12:20:00.450. If Eve had taken the day off, Alice would have traded with Bob, and it would have looked just as immediate to both of them. And if there were a high risk that the market would tank immediately after Alice's sell order were placed, then Eve wouldn't have left her buy order on the book anyway. If your 20-minute wait scenario were realistic, then sure, HFT would be adding meaningful liquidity. But then, it wouldn't be called high-frequency trading, and you wouldn't have written about how "speed matters".
- tptacek 15y agoIf Eve had taken the day off, Alice would have traded with Bob, and it would have looked just as immediate to both of them. This comment makes sense only in the context of a message board hypothetical, because it presumes foreknowledge on Alice and Bob's part. Here, Bob showed up. Eve looks like a genius. But it was equally likely that he wasn't going to show up. A lot of the discussions about liquidity and HFT here seem a little innumerate. They appear to work from a scale where the hypothetical Alice's ask price is "absolute zero". That's not the real scale. Obviously, instead of Bob showing up at $10.05, you're equally likely to end up with Chuck at $9.95. If you're not equally likely to get Chuck instead of Bob, why are you selling?
- dpark 15y ago> This comment makes sense only in the context of a message board hypothetical, because it presumes foreknowledge on Alice and Bob's part. Here, Bob showed up. Eve looks like a genius. But it was equally likely that he wasn't going to show up. Equally likely? So HFTs are flipping coins blindly and just happen to make a lot of money because they can flip quickly? > If you're not equally likely to get Chuck instead of Bob, why are you selling? I don't understand this question at all. I'm selling because I want to sell my stock. Maybe I'm liquidating assets to buy a house. Maybe I'm speculating that the market is going to tank. Maybe I'm just adjusting my asset allocation. I could be selling for any number of reasons, and I don't care about Bob or Chuck. I just want to sell and get the market price.
- tptacek 15y agoIf you need liquidity but want to retain your upside exposure, there's a whole class of tradable instruments that does that for you. If you need liquidity and aren't confident enough in your upside to want to be exposed to the downside, you're happy to have Eve. Note well: your hypothesis is that Alice should get something for nothing. Alice wants liquidity (ie: no downside exposure) and immediate access to the next significantly better price to hit the market. It must be nice to be Alice! :) As for your first question: HFTs do not have crystal balls. If they did, Chris Stucchio would be a billionaire.
- nhaehnle 15y agoHere's the thing though: ostensibly, financial markets aid in allocating capital for real world investment. Real world investment doesn't work on a millisecond basis. It doesn't even work on a per-minute basis - at best, it works on a daily basis. So if we were talking about how the financial markets benefit the real economy, we would say that Alice wants to sell at price X on Tuesday, and Bob wants to buy at price Y on Tuesday. And in that case, the go-between is unnecessary. Nobody in the real economy needs instant order fulfillment when even regular bank transfers take a day to clear. I get that more frequent dealings can help with finding "right" prices. It certainly reduces the spread. The problem is that HFT makes market access unequal. You claim that Alice could have held out for $10.05 if she had wanted to. This is incorrect. Alice most likely does not have the infrastructure in place, and the fixed costs would be far too high for her to participate in that game. So in fact Eve did not provide any kind of useful service to Alice. Eve exploited unequal access to the market for her personal gain. From a libertarian perspective you may say that's fine, granted. But the argument that Eve provided a service to the real economy is not as clear as you make it seem. So there is a tradeoff there. HFT reduces spreads and perhaps helps price finding. However, for most market participants form the real economy, intra-day fluctuations dominate the spreads by orders of magnitude anyway, so reducing the spread isn't even that much of a useful service to the real economy - at least not to the extent it happens today. On the other hand, HFT makes access to the market unequal, limiting market competition. It seems unlikely to me that the current situation is a proper balance within this tradeoff.
- yummyfajitas 15y agoYou claim that Alice could have held out for $10.05 if she had wanted to. This is incorrect. Unless the "5" key on her keyboard is broken, she could have typed 10.05 into eTrade instead of 10.00.
- sseveran 15y agoAt the point of IPO the capital for a company has already typically been allocated. The financial markets allow the owners of a company to sell their shares to the public and realize profits on their prior investments. After that markets are about betting whether the price of the company will go up or down and people trade accordingly. The need to trade instantly is very important for risk mitigation. If unexpected news comes out today that a company is the target of an adverse event like a DOJ lawsuit many market participants will want to react as fast as possible to the news. Say it takes 30 seconds for the price to fall by $10. If you could trade at the 15 second mark you would only lose $5. To an investment firm (non Market Maker or other HFT) this can be crucially important and many firms have automated systems of their own to trade. A key point of the article that most people miss is that someone has always fulfilled the role that HFTs currently occupy. In the old days floor traders occupied this role as pointed out by the article. Floor trading was a club where you had to buy a seat to be allowed in. Depending on the market the cost of the seat might be hundreds of thousands of dollars. The traders controlled access to the markets and for some markets like Oil the only way to trade was through these floor traders. Now these floor traders took full advantage of this and kept the spreads on the instruments they traded much wider than they are today. In the early 90s you could easily pay $.20 per share to the market maker to get a fill on a liquid stock. The realization (as pointed out by the article) that computers could do this better and faster is just like any other industry. The people most hurt by this development were the floor traders themselves. There is a movie called The Pit that explores the effect that computerized trading had on floor traders in Chicago. Today if I want to trade MSFT the spread on BATS's BZX exchange was just $0.01. To me, another market participant I consider it to be much better to pay a penny to Getco rather than $.20 to a floor trader. The colocation business as it has evolved has made market access more equal, not less. Today anyone can pay to colocate a server at NASDAQ, NYSE, BATS, etc... I know longer have to buy a floor seat to be able to trade there. Now there are real market barriers to entry but they are not structural. Just as you can't go build a Google competitor given that you don't have all the historical search traffic data and the infrastructure to compete with them, HFT firms have made significant investments in infrastructure of their own. If you had sufficient capital for technology development you could compete with any other HFT firm. Yes there are people hurt by HFT, just like anything else when new players with greater efficiency emerge. However the average investor who is not competing with these firms is not harmed. The floor traders were, just like telephone operators before them.