6 ms·
> It's simple really: any participant who rests an order on the book is adding liquidity. Period. If a stock is trading at $100.00, and I put a buy order on th
by dpark 15y ago
> It's simple really: any participant who rests an order on the book is adding liquidity. Period.
If a stock is trading at $100.00, and I put a buy order on the book at $0.01, how have I added liquidity?
> This may lead folks to believe that the liquidity is fleeting because they can cancel away before you can execute. However, that simply means they are better and faster than you, not that they are doing anything wrong.
The question is not whether it's right or wrong, but whether it is beneficial. I don't buy that HFT is intrinsically evil, but there seems to be little convincing evidence that it's actually beneficial, either. The system as you've described it basically involves scraping pennies off transactions that would have occurred anyway. That's not intrinsically evil, but it doesn't seem to actually benefit anyone except the HF trader.
> Why, then, don't we simply require them to rest their orders for a longer period of time? Simple: you want tight spreads. As spreads shrink market making becomes less profitable. When market making is less profitable market makers have to be more risk averse to avoid getting adversely selected and losing money. More intelligent models (they become more informed) and less latency (they can leverage that informedness to avoid being selected) is how market makers stay profitable in a market where the average spread is 1 penny.
What's missing here is an explanation of why we should build a system that enables HFT to be profitable. That's not something I care about. If lower profits for HFT means a better market overall, that's fine with me.
Frankly, in markets where the spread is 1 penny, it seems like there's enough liquidity already.
- yummyfajitas 15y agoThe system as you've described it basically involves scraping pennies off transactions that would have occurred anyway. Could you explain how to "scrape pennies" (as in specific mechanics, your explanation should involve limit orders or whatever), and why this strategy doesn't benefit the speculators the HFT is trading with?
- dpark 15y ago> Could you explain how to "scrape pennies" (as in specific mechanics, your explanation should involve limit orders or whatever), Are you under the impression that you're assigning homework to students? This comes off as really rude. And no, I'm not going to write up a treatise on HFT for you. I don't pretend that this is an area of expertise for me. FTA: Most HFTs run a market making strategy. What this means is they play both sides of the table - they take no position on whether a stock will go up or down. Instead, they try to offer securities both to buy and sell. If you want to buy, they will sell to you at $20.10. If you want to sell, they’ll buy from you at $20. As long as their buys and sells match don’t get too out of whack, the HFT will collect $0.10 = $20.10 - 20.00. What is that if not "scraping pennies"? The entire goal is to jump between a buy and sell in order to skim a bit from the transaction. e.g. Alice wants to sell at $10.00. Bob wants to buy at $10.05. They could simply trade with each other, but if Eve gets her way, Eve will buy from Alice at $10.00, and then sell to Bob for $10.05, making $0.05 on each share that would otherwise have gone to Alice. Engaging in this is not evil, but I fail to see how it benefits anyone else. > and why this strategy doesn't benefit the speculators the HFT is trading with? Because when a HFT makes money, other parties involved make a little bit less. HFTs don't print money. They extract it from the market. Also, because stock markets are not exclusively limited to speculators and HFTs.
- yummyfajitas 15y agoAre you under the impression that you're assigning homework to students? I'm asking for an explanation that goes beyond "they make money, and I don't understand how, they must be ripping people off!" e.g. Alice wants to sell at $10.00. Bob wants to buy at $10.05. They could simply trade with each other, but if Eve gets her way, Eve will buy from Alice at $10.00, and then sell to Bob for $10.05, making $0.05 on each share that would otherwise have gone to Alice What's missing from your explanation is time. If you actually wrote out a specific explanation involving limit orders (like I suggested), you would immediately have seen that. If Alice wanted to sell at $10.00 and Bob wanted to buy at $10.05, they would have already traded. The millisecond Bob's order hit the market, he would have filled Alice's order (or she would have filled his, depending on which was bigger). Eve never had any ability to participate. If Eve played any role, there was a time delay. At 12:20, Eve put an order BUY(price=$10.00, quantity=100, time=12:20) onto the market. Alice chose to sell to her at 12:30 because she wanted to trade immediately, with no risk of her order being unfilled. After buying her stocks, Eve turned around and placed a SELL(price=$10.05, quantity=100, time=12:30:01) order. At 12:40, Bob comes along and places an order BUY($10.05, quantity=100, time=12:40), which is filled by Eve's order. If Alice wanted to hold out for $10.05 she could have. She chose not to, because she didn't want to run the risk of Bob never showing up. Eve didn't "scrape pennies" from Alice and Bob, Alice paid her $0.05 to take the risk of Bob never showing up.
- dpark 15y ago> I'm asking for an explanation that goes beyond "they make money, and I don't understand how, they must be ripping people off!" I didn't say that anyone was ripped off. There's nothing inherently wrong with being a middle-man in a transaction. I just don't see that HFTs are adding any real value. > What's missing from your explanation is time. You're pretending that Alice and Bob placed their orders 20 minutes apart. That's not the game HFTs play. HFTs are playing games of milliseconds. It's not 12:20 and 12:40. It's 12:20:00.200 and 12:20:00.450. If Eve had taken the day off, Alice would have traded with Bob, and it would have looked just as immediate to both of them. And if there were a high risk that the market would tank immediately after Alice's sell order were placed, then Eve wouldn't have left her buy order on the book anyway. If your 20-minute wait scenario were realistic, then sure, HFT would be adding meaningful liquidity. But then, it wouldn't be called high-frequency trading, and you wouldn't have written about how "speed matters".
- surement 15y agoIt's like in Superman III.
- nvarsj 15y agoIt should be obvious how it is beneficial. HFTs are in competition with themselves, not with investors like you and I. Prior to HFT market making, manual market makers (brokers on the floor) were making huge profits on large spreads. This means worse prices for the average investor. Without HFT there would be no "1 penny" spread.
- andylei 15y ago> why we should build a system that enables HFT to be profitable. because HFT's are more efficient. paying a guy to make a market in one stock is expensive. paying for a computer to do it is cheap. when the market maker's costs are lower, they can afford to quote tighter spreads and still be profitable. lower spreads => lower tcosts for "normal" (low frequency) market participants