5 ms·
There's no counter argument here nor does this come across as informed or educated. All you've done is talk about the process with as many technical words as yo
by mattmanser 15y ago
There's no counter argument here nor does this come across as informed or educated. All you've done is talk about the process with as many technical words as you could without actually saying why 15ms liquidity gives us anything.
Apart from mini-crashes. And massive profits for companies that create nothing and actually were the cause of the recent financial meltdown.
Which is why many of us sit here scratching our heads or make sarcastic comments like the op.
- tptacek 15y agoI read his comment without any trouble. I don't work in finance but I'm perhaps a little more familiar with it than the typical HN reader. It certainly didn't come across as an attempt to snow the thread with jargon. A careful reread generates this list of domain-specific terms: resting orders, liquidity, HFT, passive trading, cancel, execute, spread, market making. Most of these mean what they sound like they mean. If "liquidity" is complicated, it's also the topic of the whole thread. "Passive trading" is probably the closest thing to jargon in the whole comment. It would be better if nobody made sarcastic comments, wouldn't it?
- paulsutter 15y agoHis complaint was that the post failed to explain why 15ms liquidity has any value, not the terminology. I didn't detect any sarcasm there.
- tptacek 15y agoI think if you read his comment just a little more carefully you'll see what I was responding to. I don't have a "side" in this particular debate.
- mattmanser 15y agoI totally don't understand what you're on about, sorry. Paul summed up my point perfectly. You seem to be forming a habit of ascribing things to me I didn't say. It's getting a little embarrassing/annoying.
- tptacek 15y ago"All you've done is talk about the process with as many technical words as you could"
- nihilum 15y ago> Apart from mini-crashes. The Flash Crash was caused by the NYSE's faulty time-stamping system. It essentially broadcast false information that caused traders to think there was an arbitrage opportunity. This was entirely the NYSE's fault. See here for details: http://www.nanex.net/20100506/FlashCrashAnalysis_Part3-1.html http://www.nanex.net/20100506/FlashCrashAnalysis_Part3-1.htm... > And massive profits for companies that create nothing They prevent you from paying even more to corrupt exchange specialists. This creates billions of dollars a year in value. They also have a neat ability to help the market recover from irrational crashes in 20 minutes, instead of lingering there for days or months while everyone is too scared to provide liquidity. > and actually were the cause of the recent financial meltdown. HFT is completely unrelated to the financial meltdown. The financial meltdown was caused by a housing bubble. HFT market makers don't even trade mortgage-backed securities. Those were traded over-the-counter (basically via phone calls) by investment banks. If you don't know what these words mean, then look them up instead of complaining about it. If you want to make a point, it is your obligation to understand the subject matter. Don't argue about things you don't understand.
- yummyfajitas 15y agoApart from mini-crashes. And massive profits for companies that create nothing and actually were the cause of the recent financial meltdown. Could you explain how low latency trading caused either of these things? I'm particularly curious what relation you see between low latency trading in various computerized exchanges, and a financial meltdown primarily involving OTC trading in heterogeneous derivative-like equities. By the way, to answer the question, 15ms of liquidity is just as good as 100ms or 1 sec of liquidity. The ordinary trader doesn't care about latency, latency is purely a game between HFT's to see who will receive the profits from selling liquidity.
- tptacek 15y agoHe's not imputing a direct connection between HFT and the derivatives meltdown. He's implying guilt by association, since HFT systems were deployed by the big investment banks. Of course, so was Powerpoint, which itself probably played a bigger role in the meltdown, so maybe we should ban that too.
- jbooth 15y ago"By the way, to answer the question, 15ms of liquidity is just as good as 100ms or 1 sec of liquidity. The ordinary trader doesn't care about latency, latency is purely a game between HFT's to see who will receive the profits from selling liquidity." I think this is the crux of why people think HFT is a net harm to the economy. They're devoting many millions or maybe billions of dollars to this stuff, and presumably making a hefty profit for it to be worth it, and it actually makes zero useful impact on the market? Yeah, that pisses me off. I have no problem with the financial sector being overpaid if they actually provide value to the economy. Capital allocation is a necessity and nobody's claiming that soviet-style planning would be superior. But HFT looks to me like they're just sucking little pieces out of everyone else's trades, while providing no value to society.
- tptacek 15y agoWithout getting into whether we're paying too much of a premium to the financial industry to make the economy more efficient (for instance, by enabling you to get a 15 year mortgage on a house with 20% down instead of a 5-year mortgage with a balloon payment): HFT makes a profit off the trading spread. The spread is "friction" in the market. It's the gap between what one person wants to spend and another wants to take in for the same good. Every time you make a trade, you cross the spread and thus pay a fee; you're "buying liquidity". HFTs compete with everyone else trying to make a profit from the spread. The people being harmed most directly by HFTs are themselves trying to extract a fee from normal market participants. Moreover, by competing very effectively, the HFTs are narrowing the spread. They are effectively bidding the price of liquidity down. It would make sense to be mad at HFTs if the participants they were replacing were mom's and pop's just trying to make a reasonable living while looking out for the good of the whole market. But that's not who HFTs are displacing. The human traders who profited from spreads in the 1980s were often crooked as a carton full of fish hooks. The markets before automation (and the OTC markets today) are riven with people running strategies to skim money off real buyers and sellers. The more you know about how the markets work and what the incentives of all the players are, the harder it becomes to feel any outrage about HFT.