6 ms·
For Women to Think Mathematically, Colleges Should Think Creatively
- Retric 15y agoSignificantly more Women graduate with a BS from US collages than Men. Is that yet another gender imbalance that needs to be addressed by schools? Or is that a societal issue and having collages focusing on increasing Male admission and graduation rates a waste of resources?
- hjuihjigt 15y agoSilly, if there are more women and having a degree is valued by society then there is no problem. If there were fewer women then that would be a problem that needed to be addressed urgently.
- robertpateii 15y ago"Significantly" is an exaggeration. The numbers i found (http://www.acenet.edu/AM/Template.cfm?Section=News_Room&TEMPLATE=/CM/ContentDisplay.cfm&CONTENTID=38683 http://www.acenet.edu/AM/Template.cfm?Section=News_Room&...) said that women earn 57% of all BS degrees. I imagine it'd have to get closer to 75% before people actually started worrying about men's graduation rates.
- Retric 15y ago57:43 = ~33% more women get a BS degree than men which is a fairly large gap IMO. As to the gender gap in the hard sciences 52% of undergraduate Chemistry degrees go to women which arguably makes them under represented, but only relative to their overall dominance. Chemistry is often looked at as a gateway to Medicine so it's arguably a great choice for an undergraduate degree. However, I would argue getting a PHD in Astronomy or Physics is a poor economic choice which is one of the reasons why so few women do so. PS: Any argument that women can't hack / are unprepared for the hard sciences falls apart based on chemistry numbers.
- realitygrill 15y agoPeople will only start worrying when the ratio is closer to 3 women graduating per male?
- robertpateii 15y agoLet me rephrase. Using 75% implies a certain level of authority I don't have. "I think it will take a bigger imbalance before people start worrying about a gender imbalance in favor of men."
- rmc 15y agoSignificantly more Women graduate with a BS from US collages than Men. Is that yet another gender imbalance that needs to be addressed by schools? Perhaps. But the majority of the gender imbalances negatively affect women. So let's look at that first.
- deleted 15y ago[deleted]
- meta-coder 15y agoWith all due respect, I think it is in the DNA. Looking at our evolution during the past million years, may be women were dominated by men. They might not have had enough freedom to follow their curiosities until several thousand years back. So it will take more time to have their brain evolve to levels that current men's brain is at. Have we done enough comparative studies of men's and women's brains?
- why-el 15y agoAre you serious? First you say its in the DNA, and went on to ask if research was done on it? How did you arrive at the ridiculous conclusion?
- meta-coder 15y agoI said "I think it is in the DNA." and not something like "I know for sure, it is in the DNA."
- Tichy 15y agoIf there is a biological reason, I think it would be more likely that it is because men have reasons to take risks and women haven't - other than men, women can almost always reproduce, no matter if they are rich or poor. See "Is there anything good about men?" http://www.psy.fsu.edu/~baumeistertice/goodaboutmen.htm http://www.psy.fsu.edu/~baumeistertice/goodaboutmen.htm
- mustafa0x 15y agoThank you, that talk was fascinating - and I don't use that lightly.
- rmc 15y agoit will take more time to have their brain evolve to levels that current men's brain is at Wait, did you actually compare women to cave men or half monkey? Maybe that's why blacks aren't represented well in highly technical or high paying jobs, cause they only came down from the trees recently?</sarcasm> OK I'll bite: The problem with your 'evolution theory' is that men and women aren't separate species and interbreed, a lot. Half the DNA in each women comes from a man, and half the DNA for a man comes from a woman. If "women DNA" were 'stupider' than "man DNA", then (like lots of genetic traits (e.g. skin colour, height)), you'd see it evening out over the generations. If there was a "dum dum gene" that only lived on the X or Y chromosome, you'd have to explain why it doesn't seem to affect people who don't have XX and XY (some men are XXY, some women are X, etc.)
- roguecoder 15y agoThe article mis-states their case: women earn 52% of chemistry undergrad degrees and 41% of straight-up math degrees. The problem is not math itself but the culture surrounding Engineering, Physics and Computer Science in particular.
- hjuihjigt 15y agoAs far as math is concerned, not even close to 40% of advances in the field are fostered by women. In fact it seems that even though more women get Bscs in math, actual cutting edge research in math continues to be made by 10% of women at best, roughly the same ratio as a generation ago. Still not a single Fields medalist is female (despite the tremendous backstage games to change that) and that is not because of bias, very few (if any) women currently deserve it.
- Shorel 15y agoWomen are good and average and safe (genetically speaking). Men are more distributed in the extremes: both extremely bad and extremely good. Just think of this: Why the number of people in prison is mostly males instead of half male and half female? Should we try to 'correct' this too? This is not a problem of society, but a consequence of different reproductive strategies.
- Mz 15y agoI don't know that there is any reason to think these social outcomes are rooted in genes. It looks to me like it's rooted in something else. Care to share where/why you got the idea that it is genetically determined? Thanks.
- barry-cotter 15y agoWhat is the maximum number of children a man can have? What is the maximum number of children a woman can have? What does this imply about the best strategy for maximising number of descendants for men and for women? Male mating strategies exhibit far higher skew than female ones. Men have higher variance than women in every trait I know of, from heighth to IQ scores to income. Men take more risks. Here's[0] where you'll find the most convenient counterarguments or pointers to same. Here's[1] the best book I've encountered on the general topic. The introductory chapter is excellent. [0]http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Criticism_of_evolutionary_psychology#Ethnocentrism http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Criticism_of_evolutionary_psych... [1]http://books.google.com.hk/books/about/The_Handbook_of_Evolutionary_Psychology.html?id=esDW3xTKoLIC http://books.google.com.hk/books/about/The_Handbook_of_Evolu...
- robertpateii 15y agoDo bias, discrimination, and biological differences not drive preferences? Kids internalize the bias of the culture around them at an early age. Why is this a mystery to the authors? Referenced Quote from Article: "While bias, discrimination, and biological differences may have some secondary influence, they found, women simply prefer careers that don't involve math over careers in engineering, physics, mathematics, operations research, computer science, and chemistry. Why this is so remains unanswered." Some Related Material: Podcast interview by Scott Hanselman on this same topic(http://www.hanselminutes.com/303/improving-diversity-in-technology-with-kimberly-bryant-from-blackgirlscodecom http://www.hanselminutes.com/303/improving-diversity-in-tech...)
- crusso 15y ago> Kids internalize the bias of the culture around them at an early age. How are you determining the weight and timing of causative factors in order to make a nurture over nature proclamation like that?
- robertpateii 15y agoI wasn't making any sort of proclamation like that. I'm asking why the authors think that nature and nurture is not a sufficient explanation for the preferences of college age adults. I brought up cultural bias specifically because it's something that people are used to trying to change, as opposed to genetics.
- anusinha 15y agoSome thoughts about the coder culture and how it relates to women can be found on this really interesting blog post. http://www.infoworld.com/d/application-development/the-ugly-underbelly-of-coder-culture-190618 http://www.infoworld.com/d/application-development/the-ugly-... I can't say that I agree with all of it, but it's definitely worth reading to understand certain social and cultural dynamics.
- gm 15y agoArticle does not pass the smell test. College is not where people go to decide if they are mathematically oriented or not. Everything that precedes it does.
- crusso 15y agoThe article is in the Chronicle of Higher Education. It's speaking to an audience of Educators at the University level. Naturally, the context of their solutions will be one in which those Educators operate.