3 ms·
I can't quite phrase this right, but persistence of vision and "frames" is really quite distinct from I+P blocks, and what we have in modern LCD screens is anyt
by ggm 3y ago
I can't quite phrase this right, but persistence of vision and "frames" is really quite distinct from I+P blocks, and what we have in modern LCD screens is anything but a fixed rate scan.
I really liked old TV. those wagon wheels running backwards were a direct artifact of PoV and frame rate.
The whole NTSC vs PAL vs SECAM debate, was about what aesthetically is best against what eyeballs do. Personally I didn't get the argument NTSC was better for live action. I just think PAL was superior to all the others.
Yes it was wasteful of bandwidth. Yes, it was analogue signalling of something which was at the fringes of what analogue and digital is (encoding colour as a layer over b&w signalling of grey levels, under a time code synchronisation for framing). But, it was also amazing, and I think we've lost something in MP2 -> MP4. We've also gained fidelity of what is sent to what is received and we've gained far more content.
I do really miss old analogue(ish) TV
- layer8 3y agoWhat I miss is the motion clarity of impulse-driven displays vs. today's sample-and-hold displays. Smooth 60 Hz scrolling on a CRT is something so visceral that just can't be replicated on modern displays.
- username135 3y ago#CRTmasterrace
- grishka 3y agoScrolling on a modern 120 Hz display does feel extremely smooth though.
- layer8 3y agoIt’s smooth, but it suffers from motion blur.
- account42 3y agoReally depends on the display - pixel response times vary by a lot.
- layer8 3y agoThis is not about pixel response time. This is for the same image to be held over the whole time interval of the frame, instead of just momentarily, meaning that movements from one frame to the next suddenly “jump” at the interval boundaries, instead of being smoothly interpolated by the eye/brain between momentary flashes like with CRT. Even with instant pixel response, sample-and-hold displays inherently produce motion blur. This is why mitigation techniques like black frame insertion, backlight strobing and scanning backlights exist.
- account42 3y agoNo, motion blur is not caused by that. Motion blur might be added intentionally to hide non-smooth movement with low framerates but that is uncommon outside of games or pre-rendered content (movies). And for a 120 Hz display (or even higher framerates) the jump between frames is small anyway that any reasonable scroll speeds will appear as smooth without the need for motion blur. If you are seening motion blur on a high-framerate display then either it was already there in the source content, intentionally added by the application, or you display has a crappy pixel response time. It's not an inherent problem with high-refresh displays.