3 ms·
> Perhaps most alarming to the plaintiff, Amazon's Product Safety Team specifically inspected the camera to "ensure" that Amazon wasn't platforming a product be
by ceejayoz 3y ago
> Perhaps most alarming to the plaintiff, Amazon's Product Safety Team specifically inspected the camera to "ensure" that Amazon wasn't platforming a product being used to “infringe privacy,” “surreptitiously record others for sexual purposes,” or “create and store child sex abuse material.”
This is the key bit that makes it different from your examples.
- ReptileMan 3y agoThat is kinda tricky because >Tech legal expert Eric Goldman wrote that a victory for the plaintiff could be considered "a dangerous ruling for the spy cam industry and for Amazon," because "the court’s analysis could indicate that all surreptitious hook cameras are categorically illegal to sell." That could prevent completely legal uses of cameras designed to look like clothes hooks, Goldman wrote, such as hypothetical in-home surveillance uses. How creative the amazon team has to be when reviewing the products. Do they have a duty that using the products in ways the seller has not written could achieve those goals. Personally I don't see non creepy uses for a bathroom towel camera. But in this case it is obvious that the one that must be sued is the person that used the camera. And suing amazon is obviously in bad faith and a money grab.
- jacquesm 3y agoIt's pretty easy actually: If a product has more creepy usages than that it has contrived good usages you should probably err on the side of caution.
- pixl97 3y agoNo, this is a pretty poor argument. Simply put anyone coming after your product can submit a completely unrealistic set of abuses they could do with your product whereas your products normal uses may only cover a few particular tasks. If you (the state) doesn't want a product on Amazon, you should be required to show meaningful evidence the product can both be harmful and is against the law to sell in your jurisdiction.
- jacquesm 3y agoYes, but that pretty much proves the person is not acting in good faith. normal use of spycam -> spying. normal use of beer bottle -> holding beer.
- pixl97 3y ago> normal use of beer bottle -> holding beer. That's actually a poor argument if you want to get that level to detail. Bottles are just bottles. The label and fluid you put in define if it's a beer bottle. The same bottle could be a soda bottle. Again, coming back to cameras this will get problematic really fast. What if I just make a very small camera "for integration into other devices". I mean, sounds perfectly legal. But if one of those devices is a clothes hook at which point to either of the products become illegal?
- jacquesm 3y agoI think you just like arguing for arguing's sake so I will bow out here.
- withinboredom 3y agoIf it quacks like a duck and looks like a duck, it probably isn't a lemon. I don't think you have to be too creative here. I don't think it is reasonable for any spy cam to be legal, since the majority of the time you'll be recording people without consent (otherwise, what is the point in getting one).
- graphe 3y agoWould you use that same protocol for all cameras, SSDs, HDDs, and microsd cards that could “create and store child sex abuse material"? Someone should be in prison, but it isn't Sony, hitachi's or AT&T's fault when their products are used in this way.
- ceejayoz 3y agoSSDs don't tend to market themselves via description/pics as "great for child porn" though. The likelihood of a towel rack spy camera being used for ill purposes is substantially higher than an SSD.
- graphe 3y agoThis didn't say it was great for child porn either. Both cameras and storage classify under “create and store child sex abuse material.”
- ceejayoz 3y agoSure, but hidden cameras whose marketing appears intentionally designed to hint at spying on bathrooms is not the same as "cameras and storage". Your argument is like going "GHB and ibuprofen are both drugs!" and claiming they're the same as a result. No.
- bluGill 3y agoThere are products that have legitimate uses but can be abused for something else; and there are products designed for abuse that also have legitimate uses. Small cameras have a lot of useful uses. However a camera disguised as a towel hook is clearly designed for use in a bathroom where it is unlikely it will be used for legitimate purposes. If you make a camera as a towel hook you need to have good know your customer policies to ensure only legitimate porn producers buy it. The general public should buy concealed cameras that don't look like things that you would find in a bathroom thus making it more likely if used in a bathroom they are found.
- 3y ago