3 ms·
BrowserBox^0 landed me a couple of contracts related to web scraping, RPA, process integration and dashboards, but there were quite a few more whose contracts I
by keepamovin 3y ago
BrowserBox^0 landed me a couple of contracts related to web scraping, RPA, process integration and dashboards, but there were quite a few more whose contracts I had to refuse because they came with "grabby" IP clauses, like: "we will own everything you work on while engaged with us, including any related work", which completely tried to disrespect and attempted to abuse the IP protections I sought to create by putting my open-source work: 1) out there in the open, 2) under the protection of a C corporation, and 3) with both AGPL and commercial licenses available.
At first I couldn't believe this would be a thing done by US companies (I thought maybe people in other parts of the world would have tried this, but no), but ultimately I had to face the unpalatable reality that indeed they were trying to unethically trick me into surrendering my IP by using grabby IP clauses.
When I pushed back and went through multiple rounds of contract clause negotiation, their grabby language only got more extreme in iteration (to a ridiculous degree), essentially a legal "fuck you" to standing up for myself and my rights.
Essentially a ploy to try to use an employment contract to own all my OSS work, and when I brought up ways to clarify and mutually protect IP on both sides from any such contamination, they resisted, and ultimately refused. SMH disgusting experience.
I think the most offensive thing about this was that they thought I was such a rube that I could be tricked by that, and also that it demonstrated they would try this with others. I hate the idea that little OSS developers out there were seen as inexperienced rubes to be taken advantage of. It's so hurtful. What about all the other folks out there who weren't canny enough to protect themselves, or even read through the contracts?
For reference this is not just "default clauses". I've signed many contracts that had zero grabby "own everything related" IP clauses at all, in multiple US jurisdictions. This is entirely an optional thing and does not need to be included, especially not in the circumstances I was in. The resistance in the face of subsequent negotiations, only strongly supports the idea that this is a deliberate ploy. Please respect that I'm not going to name and shame specifics tho right now, I think there's other more apt responses. Consider the experiences related here a warning enough to be careful with how you protect your IP in your own dealings, no matter who you deal with.
Sometimes the public face a company presents is so different to how they conduct themselves. Disgusting.
0: https://github.com/BrowserBox/BrowserBox https://github.com/BrowserBox/BrowserBox