4 ms·
This comment bothers me, because here I was, reading this story, not generalizing about what gender does what, just seeing a character with flaws, and then your
by stavros 3y ago
This comment bothers me, because here I was, reading this story, not generalizing about what gender does what, just seeing a character with flaws, and then your comment comes along and makes it not just about the gender of the character, but the gender of the author as well. Your comment alleges that it's obvious that a man wrote this character (this sounds sexist to me), because only a man can write a bad female character (this also sounds sexist to me), and the character is bad because no woman thinks like this (I don't know what generalizing something over three and a half billion people sounds to me).
I read the story as the protagonist being vulnerable, insecure, and a bit unhinged:
> For one horrible second I contemplated killing her but that was wildly out of proportion and then I tried to pretend that I had only wished she was dead and then I just tried to forget about it.
The other (female, no less) characters in the story seem to agree:
> “Revenge?” She looked surprised. “I get something like… I don’t know, but revenge is a leap.”
Whereas you explained those same character traits by the author being a man, and thus sexist, and not knowing how women think. That line of thinking already contains two invalid generalizations, ie "this isn't how women think" and "therefore a man wrote this, because only men don't know how women think".
I guess this bothers me because it takes something I read as just about people being people and turns it into a gender/sexism issue, but the mere existence of the complaint itself reveals so much fractal sexism in the eye of the beholder that I wish I could go back and unread it, then I wouldn't have spent ten minutes writing this inelegant rebuttal.
- charred_patina 3y ago> because here I was, reading this story, not generalizing about what gender does what, just seeing a character with flaws, and then your comment comes along and makes it not just about the gender of the character, but the gender of the author as well Have you considered that your POV is limited, and that a woman reading this story (and every other story) might have a different perspective than you? > I wish I could go back and unread it, then I wouldn't have spent ten minutes writing this inelegant rebuttal. You seem to be upset that someone had a different perspective. You might want to learn some emotional control techniques if you are this upset over an observation someone made.
- stavros 3y agoYou just reminded me that there hasn't been a single time I broke my "don't touch gender politics with a ten-foot pole" rule and didn't regret it.
- charred_patina 3y agoI am sorry you don't have the maturity to process different points of view.
- TeMPOraL 3y ago> Have you considered that your POV is limited, and that a woman reading this story (and every other story) might have a different perspective than you? Are you seriously asking 'stavros if he considered that other people may have sexist views and therefore his non-sexist view take is wrong?
- charred_patina 3y ago> Are you seriously asking 'stavros if he considered that other people may have sexist views and therefore his non-sexist view take is wrong? I am asking Stavros to consider that Women readers may be hyper-aware of bad male writing due to its ubiquity. Stavros does not have this view and is upset that someone made him aware of their perspective. I am not a woman so I am not as aware of bad female writing, but when I consume media around women they are able to pick up on things that I would never have noticed. Stavros' inability to understand something this basic means he either has a hard time understanding that people have different POVs, or is so entrenched in anti-gender politics that he can't even fathom a woman's perspective of being forced to read bad writing without getting upset about... (something??? I am not sure what).
- stavros 3y agoWhy does it have to be "bad male writing" or "bad female writing" rather than "bad writing"? How does gender add anything here?
- equalsione 3y agoPerhaps the parent comment is indirectly referring to the Margaret Atwood quote: “Men are afraid that women will laugh at them. Women are afraid that men will kill them.”
- TeMPOraL 3y agoSince Margaret Atwood was, presumably, a woman, this would only weaken striking's case by reinforcing the choice used by the author.
- pierat 3y ago> This comment bothers me, because here I was, reading this story, not generalizing about what gender does what, just seeing a character with flaws, and then your comment comes along and makes it not just about the gender of the character, but the gender of the author as well. The story was written by Conor Barnes. From his LinkedIn, well, see for yourself: https://www.linkedin.com/in/conor-barnes-b49833206/ https://www.linkedin.com/in/conor-barnes-b49833206/
- stavros 3y agoWhat am I supposed to be seeing here?
- striking 3y agoConsider: what is the purpose of each story beat? Why does the girlfriend create the spreadsheet? Why does the main character react so extremely to it? Why does she feel the need to get revenge instead of just moving on? If your answer to each is just "because otherwise there would be no story" it does not make for a compelling, realistic story. Sure, there are women who keep spreadsheets like this, and sure, there are women who have outsized reactions. But none of the surrounding context feels reasonable or meaningful. It misses the reason why people keep spreadsheets like this (more to get a better understanding of themselves than to linearly rank their partners) and why someone might react so extremely or try and get revenge (they had already been through some atypical situation that made them this way or otherwise, for example; nearly any explanation would do but we're not given one). It's not just that the author is male. It's that the author is male and is making contrivances that don't feel realistic, that could feel more realistic after some sort of consultation with either a more experienced writer or just like a woman or whatever. The characters are just cardboard cutouts that move a story forward and that doesn't make for a good read. And is it really sexist to point out (especially in combination with the above) that the author is a man when the whole story is intended to be a relationship between two women, a kind of experience that the author is unlikely to have personally had?
- stavros 3y ago> Consider: what is the purpose of each story beat? Why does the girlfriend create the spreadsheet? Why does the main character react so extremely to it? Why does she feel the need to get revenge instead of just moving on? If your answer to each is just "because otherwise there would be no story" it does not make for a compelling, realistic story. I took the story as satire, with the over-the-top reactions of both the spreadsheet-maker and the spreadsheet-reader. I don't know why the spreadsheet-maker made the spreadsheet, but I also don't know why Romeo and Juliet fell in love, beyond "otherwise there would be no story". Your points are reasonable, it's just that I enjoyed the story as satire even with these elements. > And is it really sexist to point out (especially in combination with the above) that the author is a man when the whole story is intended to be a relationship between two women, a kind of experience that the author is unlikely to have personally had? I'll reuse the same example, do we need Shakespeare to have attempted suicide with his 13-year-old lover before he could write the play?