8 ms·
Medicare Advantage increasingly popular with seniors but not hospitals, doctors
- SoftTalker 3y agoAlmost every facet of health care and end-of-life care involving seniors is a scheme to drain them of whatever wealth they have before they die.
- FirmwareBurner 3y agoWe should probably fight to change it, since we'll all end up in their place, it's just a matter of time.
- EvanAnderson 3y agoIf you're rich enough you'll be fine. This seems like an another example of how expensive it is to be poor, but the "floor" for "poor" is elevated. Edit: I think we should do something about it, but money = speech so there's nothing to be done as long as the status quo benefits people with money.
- borski 3y agoThe status quo doesn’t benefit people with money. That they don’t get a significant benefit from Medicare doesn’t mean that shitty insurance somehow benefits them more.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- EvanAnderson 3y agoIt benefits people who are rich enough to have ownership interests in the shitty insurer market.
- FirmwareBurner 3y agoAren't a lot of those companies public? Meaning they're not owned by the stereotypical evil "Monopoly Man".
- borski 3y agoMost of these companies are public, and you do not have to be rich to own shares. Also, tons of rich people do not own healthcare insurer interests. Tbh, they generally don't perform exceptionally well. "Rich people," as a group, do not somehow benefit significantly from insurance companies being garbage to those they insure.
- mschuster91 3y agoYup. Elderly care in most countries - including Europe - is a scam designed to keep the poor classes poor. Assuming long-term care is ~3000€ a month and ten years of life expectancy, that's ~360k€, or what most of us made in lifetime savings (remember, here in Europe we got actual pensions, so no 401k needed). However, a family that already has 2, 3 million € in liquid assets? For them, even two or three people in elderly care won't make much of a dent - the interest earned from these assets alone is enough to pay for their care. And for everyone above that it's not even a question. Now, the worse problem is there is no (ethical) way around the issue. Modern medical care as well as strict workplace safety regulations and the downturn of heavy industry (that caused a lot of people to die of silicosis, asbestosis and whatnot) allows for far longer life times, even with mentioned severe illnesses that would have taken out earlier generations before they had even hit pension age, and there haven't been wars to take out a decent part of the population either (which had been the norm prior to the end of WW2). At the same time, we can't just give poor elderly people a gun and tell them to off themselves out of ethical reasons, and we don't want to pressure them to "look for a way out" on their own either. We also can't rely on women to do the care labor as they did prior to the 70s, for both ethical and economic reasons (we need women in the work force). And we also can't import cheap labor from overseas to fill the gaps in staffing to drive down wages, because we already did that (good luck finding nurses and other care staff in Eastern/South Eastern Europe - all bled dry and burned out!).
- ffgjgf1 3y ago> here in Europe we got actual pensions, so no 401k needed Right.. you do realize that Europe is not a country? And anyway that’s not really true in many places (or anywhere to be fair if you want to enjoy a decent QoL). > However, a family that already has 2, 3 million € in liquid assets? For them, even two or three people in elderly care won't make much of a dent - the interest earned from these assets alone is enough to pay for their care If you have 3 million and need 360k a year that not really the case at all unless you make some relatively risky investments and/or don’t pay taxes. > which had been the norm prior to the end of WW2 It certainly wasn’t the norm outside of the 30 year period between the start of WW1 and the end of WW2 (also on the whole it disproportionately affected young men).
- jackcosgrove 3y agoI read the article and was nonplussed by the dichotomy between hospitals and doctors on one side and insurers on the other. First I'm not sure if hospitals' and doctors' interests necessarily align all the time, but maybe they do on this issue. Second I would be willing to sympathize with doctors much more than hospitals - those are the entities issuing the astronomical bills that bankrupt people after all, while monopolizing care in metro regions to control physician wages. I don't really see a champion for patients in this fight.
- coryrc 3y agoIt's also draining working people of wealth. We have all these tax breaks to keep old people owning their homes while they get free care, while working families pay all their earnings to landlords and our taxes go to elderly care instead of public services.
- anonporridge 3y agoTax burden is somewhat tangential to real root of the problem on working people. The deeper problem is that pushing so many resources towards old, retired people means that a huge chunk of the economy and jobs are forced to orient towards elder care. To be darkly blunt, elder care is a deeply depressing kind of work, especially when it's for strangers rather than family. A society with an increasing percentage of the population as old people who don't do anything interesting is an increasingly depressing society for young people to live in. It really seems like a downward death spiral.
- scarface_74 3y agoAnd this is why most cultures have multigenerational housing. Yes it’s worse for economic growth and mobility.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- lapcat 3y ago> A society with an increasing percentage of the population as old people who don't do anything interesting is an increasingly depressing society for young people to live in. It doesn't have to be this way, and the "solution" isn't a baby boom or Logan's Run. There are a lot of older people who are capable of working, but society presents many barriers to this: 1. Age discrimination; 2. Employers overworking employees; 3. Lack of flexibility in working conditions (part-time, work-from-home, etc.); 4. Lack of educational and job training resources for older people Society tends to push the majority of people toward retirement, both because it wants older people out of the workforce and also because working life tends to suck for the workers (hence the desire to retire ASAP). But a lot of retirees are actually bored and would welcome becoming useful again, if society provided better opportunities for them. Instead of "work hard until you retire", we could all perhaps "work easy until you die". Older people are forced to make the choice between working hard and retiring, but younger people are presented with similarly bad choices, for example, working hard or spending time raising your children.
- scarface_74 3y agoUnpopular opinion, what’s wrong with that? Who should pay for health care for people who can pay themselves and they get to leave their children an inheritance? While my parents who are in their 80s aren’t rich, as an only child, I stand to gain something. I wouldn’t be upset if they couldn’t leave me anything because they needed it to be comfortable at the end of their life.
- faeriechangling 3y agoWell a more functional system is being displaced by the inefficient free market American Healthcare system. I can only imagine why doctors and hospitals are not chomping at the bit to deal with bad faith insurers fraudulently denying claims nonstop while never being punished for doing so.
- jws 3y agoAround here folk call it the "Three D" strategy. Delay, deny, die. If the insurance company can put off your procedure long enough you might die and then they don't have to pay for it. Family friend who has lost so much hearing he can't participate in conversations anymore has been strung out for 6 months by his insurance on a cochlear implant. The final hurdle was them denying because of incomplete paperwork, that they did indeed have said paperwork which was part of the initial submission. If Americans find this unacceptable, they will need to adjust the laws to change the incentives to the insurance companies.
- toomuchtodo 3y agoThis might help your friend. https://www.propublica.org/article/your-right-to-know-why-health-insurer-denied-claim https://www.propublica.org/article/your-right-to-know-why-he...
- pstuart 3y agoThat might help a lot of people ;-)
- novok 3y agoThe american system is also not a free market, it's a worse of most worlds situation.
- nobodyandproud 3y agoThe large hospitals (this includes “non-profits”) are complicit. See https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=38509774 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=38509774
- KittenInABox 3y ago> The insurance industry’s lobbying arm, AHIP, said in a February letter to the Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services that prior approvals and other similar reviews protect patients by reducing “inappropriate care by catching unsafe or low-value care, or care not consistent with the latest clinical evidence.” Reminder of the orthopedic surgeon whose recommendation for surgery was denied from insurance citing an insurance-paid doctor who is lifetime banned from doing surgery for installing a hip in backwards Edited to add: > Studies show that Medicare Advantage costs taxpayers more per beneficiary than the traditional program. But the plans enjoy the backing of many lawmakers, especially Republicans, because of their popularity. Ugh. Ugh. Of course they're popular, the upfront costs are small, and the united states has literally over 10% more food insecurity in the past year alone[0]. Americans literally can't afford medicine, not because they just really really love Medicare Advantage! 0. https://www.cbpp.org/blog/food-insecurity-increased-in-2022-with-severe-impact-on-households-with-children-and-ongoing https://www.cbpp.org/blog/food-insecurity-increased-in-2022-...
- gopher_space 3y agoI wonder what sort of liabilities insurance companies open themselves up to by automating approval. Having a quack on staff isn't surprising, doctors who'd put their license on the line like this probably don't have too many options.
- shigawire 3y agoMost do have automation in place. In fact, the big EHRs are now working with payors to help facilitate automatic interoperability for insurance claims. So the insurer can directly pull up the patient's chart and use discrete data elements for claims processing.
- jjk166 3y agoOdds are there's something buried in the insurance policy's terms that gives them permission to do stuff like that.
- sokoloff 3y ago
- buildbot 3y agoMedicare Advantage is incredibly predatory and a misalignment of incentives. It pushes what should be a socialized program to the free market, which abuses it and rejects care in order to turn a profit. It's very funny people were worried about ACA "Death Panels". The insurers offering Medicare advantage basically have doctors on their payroll acting exactly as people feared, except it's the free market so somehow that's okay?
- Racing0461 3y agoIt's the trolly problem.
- EvanAnderson 3y agoI've observed that, too. "Death panels" conducted in public by parties appointed by accountable representatives are somehow repugnant, but having decisions made by completely unaccountable and inscrutable bodies is somehow okay. These decisions have to be made, why would we not want them made under some amount of public scrutiny?
- buildbot 3y agoExactly. The sad reality is in any (mostly) closed system, say, the USA or even earth, there are resource limits and you might be able to do more good by treating 4 patients with more simple cancer's vs. 1 patient with a very complex cancer that requires 10 doctors, 20 scientists, and endless support staff working over months to create a personal gene therapy for you. It's difficult and sad, but as a sibling comment said, it's literally the Trolley problem. Until we live in a utopia with nearly limitless resources, then the problem still applies, in both the public and private sector. I'd rather have it be public too.
- TehCorwiz 3y agoYou’re assuming that the efforts don’t feed back into knowledge and treatment for other people when in reality it does. But even outside that extreme example people are regularly denied treatment for existing easily treated ailments.
- grogers 3y ago> The inspector general’s office found that 13% of the denied requests for treatment it reviewed and 18% of denied claims were for care that should have been covered. That is a lot lower than I expected based on the rest of the article. Maybe still a bit too high for false positives, but it's not outlandishly high. Those numbers make it seem like the insurers are doing a lot better job at avoiding unnecessary treatment than the doctors and hospitals are doing...
- Guvante 3y agoDon't assume Medicare is denying zero claims. That is certainly not the case. 87% of denials aren't fraudulent does not mean they caught all of those and Medicare would have missed them. Also remember that counting claims is weird, they could literally be making their "profit" off these incorrectly denied claims.
- candiddevmike 3y agoWhat's the difference between adjudicating unnecessary treatments and "death panels", especially for senior care?
- kmeisthax 3y agoThere is no difference. "Death panel" is just a scary sounding term for the institution that adjudicates unnecessary treatments.
- fragmede 3y ago"Death panels" is a memetic phrase used by propagandists to get people worked up against "Obamacare". It's frustrating to see people not be able to see through their schemes.
- EvanAnderson 3y ago"Death panel" is a term contrived by a small number of people, who have enough money that they will never be denied care, to scare people who might have enough political will to make the system based on something other than having money.
- WalterBright 3y agoThe rise in healthcare costs started in 1968, when the government instituted programs to reduce costs. The highest cost industries in the US are the ones that had reasonable costs until the government stepped in to reduce those costs: 1. education 2. health care 3. housing
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- specialist 3y agoYou're referring to the Civil Rights Era and LBJ's Great Society. On the flip side, had we extended equal rights and opportunities from the drop, our GDP would have grown that much faster. IIRC > $1.5T per year. In other words, not paying up front cost us more long term.
- WalterBright 3y agoThe Civil Rights Era wasn't the cause. The Great Society was.
- jmyeet 3y agoPretty much everyone recognizes the exploitation, immorality and injustice in the brick kilns in India, Pakistan and Bangladesh [1]. This is called debt bondage. This is a harsher form of indentured servitude [2]. Interestingly, such practices were made explicitly illegal (along with slavery) with the Thirteenth Amendment. Yet many of the same people can't reognize that the systems we live under aren't that different. As long as someone has a smartphone and a PS5, they seem to become oblivious to their chains. Every aspect of your life is designed to extract wealth from you, primarily through debt. Student loan debt, medical debt, end-of-life care, housing debt. Many of these things used to be free or very cheap. The US health care system is just wealth extraction and rent-seeking. [1]: https://www.antislavery.org/what-we-do/past-projects/india-debt-bondage/ https://www.antislavery.org/what-we-do/past-projects/india-d...
- romafirst3 3y agoBest healthcare in the world.
- cscurmudgeon 3y agoIt is though, if you have semi decent insurance. That’s why even US-hating communists come to the US on tax payer money. https://english.mathrubhumi.com/amp/news/kerala/kerala-cm-spent-rs-72-09-lakh-for-treatments-at-mayo-clinic-in-usa-1.9074128 https://english.mathrubhumi.com/amp/news/kerala/kerala-cm-sp...
- jewayne 3y agoIt's not, even if you have good insurance -- and almost nobody does these days, EXCEPT the elderly. Sure, we're world-class at a few high-profile things, but you'll note that things we are good at are immensely profitable. Because right now, the stated primary goal of our health system is profit maximization.
- cscurmudgeon 3y agoI provided a link backing my point and you didn’t. Sure, believe what you want lol.
- jewayne 3y agoOh, I clicked the link about the government official from India. It does a great job of illustrating my point. A wealthy cash buyer of specific health services is going to get world class treatment at Mayo or Hopkins. How many Americans does that describe?
- tzs 3y agoOn the other hand we also have a lot of Americans who go to other countries for medical care [1]. Destinations include Argentina, Brazil, Canada, Colombia, Costa Rica, Cuba, the Dominican Republic, Ecuador, Germany, India, Malaysia, Mexico, Nicaragua, Peru, Singapore, and Thailand. [1] https://wwwnc.cdc.gov/travel/yellowbook/2024/health-care-abroad/medical-tourism https://wwwnc.cdc.gov/travel/yellowbook/2024/health-care-abr...
- bradleyjg 3y agoOf course doctors don’t like it. Insurance companies are the only entities willing to stand up to their cartel. They want to continue collecting monopoly rents without anyone saying boo.
- qgin 3y agoIn what way are doctors a monopoly?
- Centigonal 3y agoInsurance companies aren't their own even worse cartel?
- ars 3y agoNo, they are not. First their profits are capped by law, and second the entire reason these plans are so popular is because they are cheaper. And why are they cheaper? Because insurance companies are pushing back against doctors and hospitals. And since cheaper is a good thing, I don't think you can call them a "cartel", unless you mean a "cartel trying to lower prices".
- qgin 3y ago>inappropriate care by catching unsafe or low-value care, or care not consistent with the latest clinical evidence Part of the issue is that doctors use clinical guidelines as baseline best practice document (but then have to care for patients who do not fall neatly within the parameters of the guidelines), while insurers use clinical guidelines as a ceiling for care (but then use the attributes of patients which don't fall neatly within clinical guidelines as a reason to deny coverage). Yes for 80% of situations, the effect is the same. But for the 20% of situations which fall outside of that it's a rough scene.
- medicare_senior 3y agoI'm in Massachusetts, have been on a BlueCross BlueShied Medicare Advantage PPO for almost 2 full years now. So far I'm very healthy, only see the doctor 1x per year. For the same cost ($175/month) as traditional Medicare, I get the following extras: free tier 1 drugs, $1,000 in free medical supplies per year (everything from band-aids to heating pads), $500 toward fitness or weight-loss programs and $1,000 in dental care coverage. My out-of-pocket maximum is $5,600 if I do get something serious. If I go with regular medicare and want to limit the downside I have to buy a Medicare Supplement plan for an additional $196/month. The major benefit of this route is that I can be anywhere in the US (and internationally although I'm not sure what level of care that is) and get treatment without having to jump through hoops or travel back home. It's hard to turn down the Advantage program's $2,500 of free services and instead spend $2,350 to get the additional coverage. Yet the Advantage program costs taxpayers more, hurts providers and gives off an increasingly sleazy money-grabbing vibe. Ind the end it seems to me like the insurance companies are using tax money to pay seniors to help the insurance companies siphon more money out of the system. [edit: clarified that medicare supplement plan cost is additional to the regular plan cost]
- jamesTee49 3y ago[dead]