11 ms·
Lobsters
- voidfunc 3y agoI had a lobster account and a bunch of invites once upon a time. Totally forgot about it. Closed gate HN never really appealed to me.
- bmsleight_ 3y agoI quite like Lobste.rs - yes it is is a ghost town. I dont have a login as know no one on it. But it less reddit that maybe modern day Hacker news can be.
- warkanlock 3y agoGhost town? It's active and growing!
- corobo 3y agoIt still seems about the same as it has been for years from an outside perspective <20 comments (votes, even) on most posts It's pretty ghostly for a site that's been around since 2012
- praptak 3y agoWhy would I care about these numbers? It has up to date discussion on interesting news, so it's alive and kicking.
- corobo 3y agoWhy would you personally care? No idea, I don't know you. Why would anyone else care that there's discussion on a discussion forum? Because that's the point of it lol
- s1artibartfast 3y agoI have never thought of it that way, and I'm still not sure I understand the idea. For some people the point of visiting a site is related to the number of votes or comments?
- corobo 3y agoWell no the numbers aren't going to be a thing anyone directly cares about. Of course not, haha. Looking at my previous comments I'm not sure I even said anything that would imply that? What the numbers represent (how active the community is) is the bit folks would care about. In any case I used the numbers as a measure of how much the site is growing or not growing in response to the comment I responded to. The numbers seem the same as they've always been, hence it does not look like they are growing as the comment I responded to was claiming.
- s1artibartfast 3y agoThanks for clarification. I thought you were suggesting size or growth as a value themselves. I agree people want some activity on discussion forums, otherwise what's the point. Another hand I think a lot of people think volume is inversely related to Quality once you get past a certain threshold
- dun44 3y agoWhen things grow, they change, often becoming worse from their “old” users point of view. So, why would you want it to grow, as opposed to staying the way you like it?
- corobo 3y agoThis seems to make a few assumptions I'm not sure I agree with. Growth is worse. Growing too fast can make things worse, aye. Not necessarily because there's more people in general but because the community changes as a result of them joining. The new users don't adapt to the existing culture quick enough, and because there's so many of them in a short amount of time the culture is disrupted and pushes out the existing userbase, locking in the new culture. This is one of the reasons lobsters has the invite system going by their about page so they seem to be actively trying to prevent this effect. Maybe there's a better way to do it, maybe this is the only way, that one's not really for me to say. Even if it was for me to say I don't have any better suggestions. I want it to grow. I don't really have an opinion on lobsters in that respect. If it works for them and their users, that's great! Some sites just ain't for me, no worries. It is currently the way I like it. I like a wider variety of comments, so in its current form lobsters isn't the way I like it. There's plenty of other places on the internet for me to get my fill though, we're on one of 'em now! I wouldn't want them to change on my behalf. If it works for what they're after - again that's great! While the site isn't my cup of tea I can absolutely see why they run it like they do. If Reddit shut down tomorrow and all the more memey tech users migrated here in one go, this place would become terrible (as always, in my opinion) - I can see why they do what they do, even if I don't personally enjoy the end result. No problem though, it's one less source of easy dopamine. Lord knows I don't need any more of those :)
- TillE 3y agoYeah that's some extremely sparse discussion, on par with a really tiny subreddit. Maybe it's ok if you're just passively using it as an aggregator of interesting links?
- stephenr 3y ago> know no one on it Shoot me an email, it's in my profile.
- bdcravens 3y agoNo version numbers in the Gemfile? That's brave.
- riffraff 3y agoI feel versions in Gemfile tend to make things harder to update and often end up accidentally retaining some old version. You won't get a random version bump unless you do `bundle update` anyway, since you have a lock file. Unless you really need a specific version, let those gems be free :)
- rad_gruchalski 3y ago> Unless you really need a specific version, let those gems be free A wet dream of anyone looking for a method to perform a supply chain attack.
- riffraff 3y agothat is what Gemfile.lock is for. You are not getting a new version unless you do ask for it explicitly.
- rad_gruchalski 3y agoYeah, that’s actually true. I looked at it from a wrong angle.
- CodesInChaos 3y agoThose are just as easy when using the standard "semver compatible with the specified version" approach. The lockfile will prevent such attacks on build, and on upgrade it doesn't really matter security wise if the new version has the same major version.
- brink 3y agoBeing harder to update is the point. With ruby being untyped and lazy evaluated, it's even worse. If any library's api changes between versions, unless you're sure you have a unit test for that function, it'll happily deploy and crash in production. Plus as long as you're using a service like snyk.io to make sure that you're covering security vulnerabilities, there's usually not much reason to updating if it works.
- Xiol32 3y agoWould be less of a ghost town if they allowed sign ups rather than via invitation only. Appreciate that's kinda the point of the site, but if it's a ghost town then it's clearly petered out.
- bigdubs 3y agoQuantity may have a quality all its own in warfare but for comments having the invite tree and accountability is pretty nice! I'd rather have (2) really insightful comments than 300 trying to promote themselves.
- tapirl 3y agoInvite doesn't always guarantee insightful comments.
- thrdbndndn 3y agoFrom my experience in invite-only forums, it can only assure some bottom line (mainly, fewer troll posts), but it doesn't help at all on the quality of comments. The only thing I saw that ever significantly improved the quality of comments is vote-based comment system when it firstly started to emerge (I'm thinking Reddit in its first few years). But unfortunately it nowadays has been gamed to death, probably even worse than old public forums.
- gtirloni 3y agoExcept you don't see those 2 really insightful comments there.
- robocat 3y ago> 300 Exaggerating doesn't make reflect well on your argument. HN doesn't have a notable problem with self-promotion.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- 3y ago
- 38 3y agoNot a fan of having to beg for an invitation. Seems like HN is able to handle moderation with a small crew.
- mariusor 3y agoSmall crew of very high quality *paid* moderators. I don't know how many other hats Daniel wears in YC, but based on the times he's active here, he's spending _a lot_ of time doing moderation work. Lobste.rs, as far as I know, works only with volunteers which probably are an incohesive group of random people with random thresholds for how they moderate. It's entirely reasonable for such a community to build redundancies in the methods for lowering unwanted content.
- zimpenfish 3y ago> Seems like HN is able to handle moderation with a small crew. A certain amount of moderation. There's still a large amount of content posted on here that should probably have been moderated but isn't (for whatever reason.)
- renewiltord 3y ago[flagged]
- eatonphil 3y agoGood posts on software more reliably get to the top of lobste.rs than on HN in my experience. Whereas on HN you're competing with a wide variety of topics. Lobste.rs is pretty focused on just hardware/software hacking. I don't mean that negatively. I'm glad we talk about varied topics on HN. But it's also nice to have a place that almost only talks about software/hardware. Sometimes I've thought about starting a "software internals" forum but then I remember that's basically exactly what lobste.rs already is.
- treesciencebot 3y agoAny reason why HN source code is not published? The best I can think of is not to let people see the penalizing behavior, but having an open standard might actually help it improve rather than keeping it as a hidden secret that slowly gets discovered by independent malicious parties.
- capableweb 3y agoHere you can find the latest public code: http://arclanguage.org/ http://arclanguage.org/ But I don't think there has been any public updates since that release (edit: updates from YC. There is a community-led project that continues to improve the codebase after that release)
- shawnz 3y agoIt shares the same lineage as this code: https://github.com/arclanguage/anarki/tree/master/apps/news https://github.com/arclanguage/anarki/tree/master/apps/news
- krapp 3y agoAnarki and its version of the forum is so far removed from the original Arc base that it isn't even worth comparing at this point.
- dun44 3y ago>The best I can think of is not to let people see the penalizing behavior I wonder if it would be possible to split HN (or any other HN-like site) into two halves: one would handle the actual storage of posts and comments, and another would handle the scoring, ie the order the comment tree branches appear in. Then we could have multiple of the latter, competing with each other on the scoring alone, with the actual content being common.
- solardev 3y agoKinda like how reddit has "hot", "top", and "best"?
- Hakashiro 3y agoI had an account here. I still do. Like some other people point out: Invitation-only means trolls are less likely to show up. But the higher end of quality is not significantly better than HN. If anything, it might be worse. My experience with the moderation there is that some people post clear self-promotion articles, but when I attempted to post my things, I get told that this content is not welcome on the site. Why my content is not welcome and other people's self-promotional articles are I don't quite understand, but it is obvious they don't need me on the website.
- mooreds 3y ago> when I attempted to post my things, I get told that this content is not welcome on the site. Why my content is not welcome and other people's self-promotional articles are I don't quite understand, but it is obvious they don't need me on the website. I feel the same. I spent a fair bit of time on the site, including posting ~600 articles and commenting. Some of my posts got a fair bit of upvotes. I got a couple of warnings when I posted my own content, even though it was 5-10% of my posts. Super frustrating, so I told the moderator I wasn't going to participate any more. And I haven't. Their site, their rules, but I don't have to spend my time there. https://lobste.rs/~mooreds https://lobste.rs/~mooreds is my profile.
- andy99 3y agoWeird because primarily submitting one's own stuff seems to be pretty common there. Random example from a user currently on the front page: https://lobste.rs/~rednafi/stories https://lobste.rs/~rednafi/stories And that is not the only one on the front page right now that's submitting mostly their own stuff.
- everybodyknows 3y agoThat user's submissions are all within the past week. You may have found someone gaming the site.
- buildbot 3y agoThat's not a particularly good example, their latest self-promo post has a warning from the mod on it...
- packetlost 3y agoLobsters has a simple but effective and fairly strongly enforced tag system that makes it far easier to curate your feed than HN. Despite what others have said here, it is not a ghost town at all, it's intentionally lower noise and they'd like to keep it that way.
- everybodyknows 3y ago> fairly strongly enforced tag system Quite a disciplined policy by the stewards of the website. How does the enforcement work against say, overtagging? Also this: > Inactive tags can no longer be used on new stories. https://lobste.rs/tags https://lobste.rs/tags Roughly 100 tags on the page. I see "news" and "ipv6" marked as no longer active. I'm guessing that "inactive" implies dropping from SQL indexes as an economy measure, while retaining unmodified in the original post's metadata.
- ignaloidas 3y ago> Quite a disciplined policy by the stewards of the website. How does the enforcement work against say, overtagging? Tags are used as negative signal, rather than positive (as in, you filter out tags you don't like, rather than taking the ones you do), so overtagging would kill the submission, and missing tags will be added by others via suggestions (which automatically add the tag after some threshold amount of suggestions).
- kristianp 3y agoThe ghost town link in the readme is gold: https://twitter.com/webshitweekly/status/1399935275057389571 https://twitter.com/webshitweekly/status/1399935275057389571
- rglullis 3y agoAside from the argument for/against lobste.rs, is there anything in the codebase that is worthwhile? Any feature/functionality that could be implemented in Lemmy, for example?
- whalesalad 3y agoIt's a decent example to follow for a run of the mill rails app.
- stephenr 3y agoLobste.rs definitely feels like less of an echo chamber: both Reddit and HN have a large "I don't agree with you, downvote" population - on HN this is officially endorsed as "correct" use too.
- Rochus 3y agoAccording to my experience rather on Lobsters participants seem to be mostly concerned with nagging. Rarely got a useful or positive comment for my posts there. There is a small circle of users who have a particularly good relationship with the admin and flag everything they don't like. I had much better discussions and more useful feedback on some subreddits. I agree that the downvoting possibility encourages misuse. There is no downvoting on Lobsters, but people instead flag whatever they don't like, even if there is objectively no violation of the site rules. Actually I would prefer a site where you can only upvote or flag, not downvote, but the admin in that case should charge people who misuse flagging.
- stephenr 3y agoFlagged as what though? Without seeing actual examples of posted articles that were flagged it's honestly impossible to make any judgement. Edit: I should point out that this isn't a hypothetical question either. As the moderation log is open, we can see exactly why a user was banned or post was removed etc.
- Rochus 3y agoUnfortunately many examples; usually it starts with a "-1 spam", e.g. for this post: https://lobste.rs/s/ebztmj/now_we_know_which_cs_publication_used_term https://lobste.rs/s/ebztmj/now_we_know_which_cs_publication_... And if you then complain that the post doesn't violate house rules, you get some obviously wrong claims from someone of the inner circle why it does; if you then contradict to these claims or present facts, you usually get flagged for trolling, and eventually your comments are removed by the admin. I have still an account but don't spend more time there.
- kirubakaran 3y agoIf you want Lobsters style tags and filtering on Hacker News stories: https://histre.com/hn/ https://histre.com/hn/ (d: mine)
- everybodyknows 3y agoDon't see any clues here as to how the tags are chosen and matched to stories. Can you provide further?
- kirubakaran 3y agoSure, here is the Show HN for it: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=35904988 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=35904988 Thanks for checking it out. Please let me know if you have any other questions.
- GaggiX 3y agoI think the killer feature that HN has compared to any other site I know is Dang.
- tptacek 3y agoLobsters has had a series of thoughtful moderators.
- GaggiX 3y agoThat's not really what people are sharing in this thread, to be honest.
- tptacek 3y agoI've read the thread and don't know what you mean.
- GaggiX 3y agoIt's literally the top comment and its children.
- tptacek 3y agoI've certainly read that thread, and I don't know what you're trying to say.
- GaggiX 3y agoMaybe I'm wrong, but I thought you were trying to compare the Lobsters moderators to Dang in a positive way, something not really emphasized in the top comment and its children.
- stephenr 3y agoPretty much any complaint about moderation from anyone always has another side to the story. At least two of the tales of woe posted in this discussion have shown that the user was not in fact blameless.
- hiq 3y agoIs there an equivalent of https://hckrnews.com/ https://hckrnews.com/ (especially the top 10 / top 20 filters) for lobste.rs? That's the main way I browse HN, I wish I could do the same for lobste.rs. The closest seems to be https://lobste.rs/top https://lobste.rs/top but it seems to only cover the past week.
- basedkissinger 3y ago[flagged]
- __rito__ 3y agoI never got an invite there, and hence stopped trying. Don't know anyone IRL who is already there I guess.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- Alifatisk 3y agoSame, I visit the site frequently but I don’t now anybody to get invited
- yuppiepuppie 3y agoI was always liked the idea of the site, but never got an invite. I lurk there occasionally when I see discussions around a topic that I find interesting that didn’t get traction on HN.
- kaba0 3y agoIf you share your email, I’m sure you can get an invite now that you publicly asked for it :D
- losvedir 3y agoI like lobsters. One of my main use cases is on my phone in the middle of the night (while rocking my newborn), since it actually has a legit dark mode, unlike HN, which blinds me and lights up the room. I don't understand how HN doesn't...
- Modified3019 3y agoDarkreader is available for most browsers, desktop and mobile: https://darkreader.org/blog/mobile/ https://darkreader.org/blog/mobile/
- mminer237 3y agoHarmonic[0] has a dark mode. [0]: https://github.com/SimonHalvdansson/Harmonic-HN https://github.com/SimonHalvdansson/Harmonic-HN
- kevincox 3y agoAlso much more mobile friendly in general. I typically use HN more but tends to pull Lobsters up far more often on mobile. Even though I do have a user stylesheet for HN it still doesn't make it great on mobile and I can be bothered to fiddle with it too much myself.
- ksec 3y agoDark Mode has been promised since 2020 but we still don't have it yet.
- prakashn27 3y agoI use Firefox in built dark mode feature when browsing at night in mobile.
- tonoto 3y agoHow come that this is the first time (might have visited that site several years ago, recognize the CSS in some way) that I hear about lobster.rs? Is the site entirely by invitation or are there at least a couple yearly signup openings?
- kristianp 3y agoNow there's a thread on there pointing here: https://lobste.rs/s/5vs9tv/lobsters_hacker_news https://lobste.rs/s/5vs9tv/lobsters_hacker_news
- doe88 3y agoGreat site, especially for PL and security links, I read it for a while now but never had the chance to know someone with an account/invite.
- pja 3y agoIf you ask politely on the IRC & share a bit about who you are it’s fairly likely someone will send you an invite. No guarantees though - the likelihood probably depends at least partially on how long it’s been since the last bunch of self-promoting spammers set up their own little invite ring after being invited in...
- tkellogg 3y agoHere's the lobste.rs post about this post https://lobste.rs/s/5vs9tv/lobsters_hacker_news https://lobste.rs/s/5vs9tv/lobsters_hacker_news
- dalanmiller 3y agoIt’s not a ghost town. I really enjoy it for the quality of discussion.
- magicmicah85 3y agoI like the discussions there but looking for an account so I can post. Currently going through github issues and finding things I can fix so someone rewards me.
- aftbit 3y agoYou seem like someone who can add to a discussion, and you like SDR stuff too. Figure out how to contact me using the info in my profile and I'll send you an invite.
- h_o_o_t 3y agoHello, this post actually made me make a post of my own. I think you can have your cake and eat it here. If you filter HN with uBlock Origin to remove topics and sources you are not interested in, i.e. non-technical ones in my case, probably the case for many others too, then you can create what Lobsters was going for, but here on HN. You get the fully populated, buoyant chat, whilst fine tuning the scope of topics and sources you see. I detailed the uBO rules here a moment ago: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=38510651 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=38510651
- zlg_codes 3y agoGood site design, poor community culture. Their design allows them to focus on 'acculturating' new users, but does very little to spell out that culture or present unambiguous guard rails. There are some prominent posters whose personal projects get free passes. I don't feel like Lobsters is a community friendly to people on the spectrum. They expect allistic members who all understand socializing on an intuitive and instinctual level. I've considered looking for an invite, but I don't think I'd be well received and I don't care for being reprimanded by a stranger over tone or 'unprofessionalism' when I see straight trolling or passive aggression in comments. The invite system is solid but I would change a few things to turn it into a place I might have a chance of being welcome.
- kaba0 3y agoIf you request an invite here publicly (and have an email in your profile), I’m sure you can easily get one. Also, I haven’t seen anything like tone policing and ‘unprofessionalism’, and I think the boundaries usually are quite objective and trivial.
- culi 3y agoNot sure if this is a hint, but I've been interested in getting an account for a while if anyone is able to invite
- zlg_codes 3y agoIt's important to choose who you invite, and who invites you, carefully. If the invitee screws up, it reflects poorly on the inviter. If the inviter screws up, everyone they invited may also get looked at. I don't know anyone on Lobsters enough to have that sort of relationship with. I don't really submit things, even here; not worth the trouble of being told something's a bad fit, off-topic, repost, bad title, or some other nitpick. There is likely to be friction if I were to participate there, so it's for the best. If it works for you, that's good.
- kaba0 3y agoYour choice, I was invited that way and didn’t see any negative. The ultimate majority of people are decent beings.
- perrygeo 3y agoHas anyone looked at the correlation between HN top posts and Lobsters? I would occasionally lurk on Lobsters until I realized that the majority of content on L had already been posted on HN first. Private community that's basically an echo chamber of existing community's content... no thanks.
- hoistbypetard 3y agoOne person maintains a site that does just that: https://gerikson.com/hnlo/ https://gerikson.com/hnlo/ For me, even if stuff I'm interested in has already been posted on HN, it often rolls off the front page before I ever see it. The front page there moves more slowly, so there's a greater chance I actually see and discuss it.
- thombles 3y agoIt often flows the other way too (speaking from experience with some self-authored posts on Lobsters).
- snapplebobapple 3y agoWhen did that go in ite only? I am pretty sure i jist signed ip agds ago no invite necessary
- cpurdy 3y agoI don't think I've ever posted any articles on Lobsters, but there are a bunch of users there that use the "report" feature any time that they see a post that doesn't support their own personal opinion. That aspect of the site does get old, fast. But most of the users there are cool. Unfortunately, it only takes a few bad users to make the experience of posting uncomfortable.
- jldugger 3y ago> but there are a bunch of users there that use the "report" feature any time that they see a post that doesn't support their own personal opinion how can you tell?
- cpurdy 3y agoThere's a URL for each user that shows their standing. Any recent (last 30 days) reports are listed there. You can't tell who reported you, but you can tell what they were complaining about (which post, what reason they gave). The URL is reddit-like, i.e. /u/username/standing The problem is that there's a downside to being reported, but there's apparently no downside to reporting people. Since there's no down-voting of comments on lobsters, and since reporting comments is apparently free and unlimited, some people seem to use it as their down-vote. And since it's anonymous (the reporting person's name isn't included in the report to the person being reported), and since reporting appears to have no limits or downsides, it inevitably creates some twisted incentives. I currently have no "reports" there, but that's because I (mostly) learned my lesson: Post your own opinion at your own risk. i.e. You'd better make sure that your opinions aren't unpopular with any users there, and particularly not with the dominant group. I think someone else mentioned that the things that they posted that were reported, were also the things that received many more upvotes. I can personally confirm this from my own history. However, I don't find this surprising: If something evokes a response that could cause someone to upvote it, it shouldn't be surprising that it would evoke a response that could cause someone to report it. And receiving kudos for an opinion does not absolve that opinion of the responsibility to adhere to the rules and standards of the site. Coincidentally (and AFAIK not related to this thread here), I did have a comment moderated (i.e. deleted) within the last 24 hours. I'm of mixed feelings on the rationale for the moderation. It's a thread that contains highly-upvoted comments like "I hope those responsible get sued to oblivion. This kind of stuff should result in a corporate death penalty." My comment was: "Just waiting for a case like this to make it up to the US Supreme Court so they can rule that it’s a constitutional right of companies to do this." Apparently, my post was "political". (I can only assume that the "political" aspect was my implication that non-human legal entities like corporations should not be granted legal rights by SCOTUS that expropriate or otherwise displace the rights of actual human beings.) The thread: https://lobste.rs/s/8igrxm/train_firmware_reverse_engineering https://lobste.rs/s/8igrxm/train_firmware_reverse_engineerin... On the other hand, I do agree that some portion of the topic is very technical in nature (and the technical aspects are interesting), and it's hard to discuss that portion of the topic if people are constantly commenting about relevant aspects of the legal system or whatever. So since the post wasn't specifically about the legal aspects (or "political" aspects, if you insist), I can kind of see the point of the moderation.