3 ms·
> Their stated purpose was to make it more accessible. The reasoned that the neoclassical architecture and old-style font made the space intimidating to people
by lotsofpulp 3y ago
> Their stated purpose was to make it more accessible. The reasoned that the neoclassical architecture and old-style font made the space intimidating to people who didn’t hold those things to be part of their culture and that it was out of tune with the increasing diversity of their collection and programs.
Can put this under the dictionary definition of insanity. Or someone needed justification to get paid without doing any real work.
- Auracle 3y agoI would simply call it demeaning.
- coldtea 3y ago>The reasoned that the neoclassical architecture and old-style font made the space intimidating to people who didn’t hold those things to be part of their culture and that it was out of tune with the increasing diversity of their collection and programs. The whole purpose of an actually inclusive "Museum of Fine Arts" should have been the opposite: to make people appreciate, understand, and enjoy things that they don't feel are "part of their culture", expand their cultural horizons and lift their tastes. Not to excise things they don't identify with, and feed them "safe" stuff tailored to them. That's entertainment.
- InCityDreams 3y ago>...expand their cultural horizons and lift their tastes. Their tastes prior, being (considered) lower?
- p3rls 3y agoYes, it's called aesthetics.
- coldtea 3y agoYes. To conceive of a museum of fine arts, you also need to have a culture that has a sense of different relative worths of both artistic styles and art artifacts. What belongs to a museum vs what doesn't, what is fine art vs what is commercial crap or kitch, and so on. One that believes in informed curation - curation being the very core of what a museum does. Of course this requires an era where the opinion of people devoted to studying, discussing, and creating fine art isn't supposed to be equally respected to that of Joe Sixpack, Jaqueline Middlebrow, Joy Belieber, Arthur Incel, or Random J. Person, where everything is up to personal taste.
- wizofaus 3y agoI don't care for the use of terms that imply appreciating the fine arts is somehow on a "higher plane" and places those who do so above those who don't, but I do think it's worth acknowledging that it takes significant time and effort to develop such appreciation, and that the rewards are subsequently substantial. Personally I've invested significantly in the study and appreciation of Western classical music and I believe what I've gained from that could not be achieved simply by listening to top 40 hits on the radio - but I don't believe those who do only the latter are in anyway "lower" on any sort of ranking system, just that their brains are wired differently, and their cultural background etc. is such that it probably wouldn't make sense for them to make the same investment into music appreciation that I have. It's almost certainly true that they've invested considerably into appreciating other worthwhile aspects of life that I haven't - we can't do it all!
- s1artibartfast 3y agoYes, by their own assessment following the changing or expansion of their tastes. Why change, grow, or learn if you don't think the state after is better than before?
- hitekker 3y agoThis is especially true for religious art. Many think religion is not "apart of their culture" because they haven't learned their own history. A museum ought to show the newer generations the good parts of what came before; be it in Islam, Buddhism, Christianity and others.
- comfysocks 3y agoSo, by making their collection more diverse, they are going to be challenging to a broader swath of visitors, no? People steeped in Classicism need to have their horizons expanded too, right?
- AlecSchueler 3y agoI want to say it makes complete sense to me. It's well known that museums are seen as unappealing to many demographics and the image of association with elitism and colonialism plays a huge role in that. Changing the style choices of museum communications towards ones which are further dissociated from those issues seems like ab obvious first step towrads increasing the perception of inclusivity. I would ask anyone who is labeling it as "insane" what their own background is how European it is before they dismiss efforts to appeal to groups with other histories, and often painful ones as they relate to European history.
- lotsofpulp 3y agoMy background is non white child of poor immigrants to the US from a country that used to be ruled by the UK. I just found it unbelievable that anyone would associate a font with “elitism” and “colonialism”. And my family prioritizes going to museums, even in London, where many of my family live even though that is in the country that oppressed them. I have heard elders complain about the proliferation of the English language itself to be a cause for decline in fluency of the native language, but I can almost guarantee no one has ever thought about the influences of a font. I mean there are actual fish to fry here, starting with legislation, monetary consequences, property rights…I do not see how fonts moves the needle at all, except patting oneself on their back.
- AlecSchueler 3y ago> I can almost guarantee no one has ever thought about the influences of a font. Maybe not but we know that they do affect people's perceptions whether they're conscious of it or not. I think it's fantastic that your family was engaged with museums while you were growing up but we also know that there's a demographic divide in engagement across the wider population. In the UK more than half of white families visit museums annually but for black families that's closer to one in three.[0] > I mean there are actual fish to fry here, starting with legislation, monetary consequences, property rights 100% but those issues are beyond the operational scope of an individual museum trying to improve its engagement. 0: https://www.ethnicity-facts-figures.service.gov.uk/culture-and-community/culture-and-heritage/adults-visiting-museums-and-galleries/latest https://www.ethnicity-facts-figures.service.gov.uk/culture-a...