5 ms·
The X Prize is taking aim at aging with a new $101M award
- Alex3917 3y ago> The winners will have to prove by 2030 that their intervention can turn back the clock in older adults by at least a decade in three key areas: cognition, immunity, and muscle function. Can't you already get that just by exercising?
- Gualdrapo 3y agoPeople rather like miracles and low effort results.
- toomuchtodo 3y agoAnd we will pay incredible amounts for them. The Danish central bank is holding interest rates below that of the ECB due to how successful Ozempic and Wegovy are [1] [2]. It's expected to be a $100B market by 2035 (assuming "one and done" gene therpay doesn't fast takeoff [3]). [1] https://www.cnn.com/2023/08/21/business/ozempic-wegovy-demand-denmark-economy/index.html https://www.cnn.com/2023/08/21/business/ozempic-wegovy-deman... [2] https://fortune.com/2023/09/22/obesity-drug-market-ozempic-wegovy-2035/ https://fortune.com/2023/09/22/obesity-drug-market-ozempic-w... [3] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=38495653 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=38495653 (if I can get the benefits of exercise without exercising, "shut up and take my money"; success is about outcomes, not effort)
- RandomLensman 3y agoJust in case: The Danish Central Bank is reacting to the economic success of the drug maker which impacts the currency flows and thereby the currency peg they are managing. (Not some health benefits thing by the central bank).
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- mensetmanusman 3y agoAmerica exporting the disorder of the US healthcare system and crashing currencies as we help companies become larger than their nation state GDPs. Kind of funny actually.
- RandomLensman 3y agoNo currency crashing with DKK.
- BurningFrog 3y agoOf course we do. Nothing wrong with that!
- kiba 3y agoThat would be like investing into a single stock, and hoping that your investment pans out. You diversify your investments to reduce the risk of catastrophic loss. I would like to encourage maximum effort into maintaining my health while waiting for interventions to develop. This is all on top of competing priorities such as projects I am working on.
- dghughes 3y agoNo I'd say by being active you are being the best you can be and also maintaining as best you can your body but it will still degrade. If you're out of shape so you decide to be more active, eat well, you fell better. You will gain muscle lose excess fat eventually you arrive at a level of health that is normal. You will be as healthy as we all should be. This is something I think many people miss about being active. When I was in my 20s and 30s the gym was a social thing, to see and be seen. Plus being 20s you can build muscle, get fit, do anything and recover in a day. In my 40s I felt I was ahead of most people in overall health no gut no out of breath from menial tasks. By health I don't mean the "swol bros" or the gaunt 1% fat people. But in my late 30s early 40s my routine suffered and then stopped going due to a new job with odd hours. Although I did feel I had momentum of all those years but it faded quickly. It was the consistency of going more than anything that I think was a benefit to my health. I wasn't a power lifter, a marathon runner, a body builder, one of those squash players I was just going to maintain my overall health. Really it's a bit like countries with socialized medical care. You go often and catch problems early so you are better overall not near death's door when you finally go to a doctor. Same for a dentist you go frequently to catch problems since you can't regrow teeth it's too late then. Old age without being active in the previous decades is like that it's too late.
- BurningFrog 3y agoNot if you already are exercising.
- qgin 3y agoYou can make your health in older age worse by not exercising. But no amount of exercising can fight aging.
- jamesTee49 3y agoNeed creatine monohydrate maybe around 5-12g daily depending on age. I have seen MANY 60+ that look like late 30s simply keeping a daily creatine supplement religiously. Weight lifting prefer especially having bones being stressed compare to cardios.
- UtopiaPunk 3y agoI think having guaranteed healthcare and shorter work weeks would be a more effective means of extending a healthy life. Maybe not for the uber-wealthy, but definitely for the rest of us.
- gcanyon 3y ago> The winners will have to prove by 2030 that their intervention can turn back the clock in older adults by at least a decade in three key areas: cognition, immunity, and muscle function. <checks math>: that's 10 years of aging progress in 7 years. I'll take it! I'd be ecstatic if I netted 3 years younger for every decade going forward. Of course, I'd actually expect that to accelerate, but given my current age, I'll happily take anything that is breakeven right now.
- swells34 3y agoPersonally, I think we should wait 5-10 years before trying to solve aging.
- gcanyon 3y agoIf you're implying what I think you're implying, just start a rumor that the tech tracks your location, and problem solved...
- ralusek 3y agoForgive me if I'm reaching, but I had absolutely no idea what this discussion was saying. This is my best bet understanding: User implies we should wait 5-10 years to cure aging. Implication being that we want someone near death to actually die. Shot in the dark because people are boring: guessing Trump or Biden. Your response seems to imply that all that would be needed to have that person ignore the technology would be to say that it tracks your location. This seems to imply that you assumed they were talking about Trump, because he's associated with conspiratorial thinking. Did I understand this thread correctly or am I having a stroke?
- credit_guy 3y agoCompletely unrelated to either the GP or GGP. My take was that GGP was making a joke on mathematical induction: wait 5-10 years, and when you get there wait 5-10 years again, etc. So, a roundabout way of saying "just don't do it". To which the GP answered "start a rumor about anti-aging tech invading your privacy", and then even if it gets done, it doesn't get used, so the end result is the same.
- zeryx 3y agoCan I.. vote against this? Death has historically been the only equalizer and return to the mean that has saved us from Tyrants and excessive concentration of power and control. I'm fine with having the life expectancy that I have, am I the only one?
- idopmstuff 3y agoI am both profoundly fearful of death and also incredibly excited to see what's coming, so I'm rooting for success here.
- huklintio 3y ago[dead]
- r2_pilot 3y agoBy all means, you should have the right to control your lifespan. Please let others make that choice too, insofar as the universe will allow us.
- mensetmanusman 3y agoreplace 'others' with billionaires and this statement is more accurate.
- bitwize 3y agoThis research would protect us from aging, but not from bullets or poisons. The likes of Hitler and Stalin would have still died at about the same time had anti-senescence treatments been available to them.
- Cpoll 3y agoMany tyrants have been multi-generational. Many have been deposed, so death can't be the "only" equalizer. And many modern "tyrants" are organizations and systems, not individuals. And who knows, maybe tyrants will act more sensibly if they expect to live in the future they're harming (wishful thinking perhaps). If you take antibiotics when you're sick or choose your diet based on health concerns, you're not fine with the life expectancy you have. Natural lifespans (my words, not yours) don't make any sense with the level of intervention we do. I like to imagine that choosing how and when you will die will one day be right there with self-actualization in Maslow's hierarchy of needs.
- xiphias2 3y ago,,Three or four years in, the top 10 teams will receive a million each. That leaves $81 million for the winners, which will be announced in 2030.'' This sounds great, even the visibility will help a lot. $100M is tiny for a problem that can increase the economy by trillions of dollars, but it's still great.
- momofuku 3y agoGenuine question, with no malfeasance: How successful have precious iterations of the XPrize been? IIRC, there was (is?) one for landing a rover on Mars and another for cleaning up the ocean. Have those companies yielded tangible benefits or even spurred innovations in their respective fields?
- idopmstuff 3y agoFor transparency the below is entirely from GPT-4. All successful except for the Google Lunar XPRIZE. It's notable that these prizes ranged from $7M (Ocean Discovery XPRIZE) to $30M (Lunar XPRIZE), so the stakes have really gone up for this one. Ansari XPRIZE (2004): Aimed at private spaceflight, won by Mojave Aerospace Ventures' SpaceShipOne, demonstrating private manned spaceflight. Progressive Automotive XPRIZE (2010): Focused on energy-efficient cars. Edison2’s Very Light Car won in the Mainstream Class, and Li-ion Motors’ Wave II and X-Tracer Team Switzerland’s E-Tracer won in the Alternative classes. Google Lunar XPRIZE (Not Won): Targeted private teams to land a rover on the moon. Although the prize expired in 2018 without a winner, several teams continued their lunar missions. Global Learning XPRIZE (2019): Sought solutions for children to teach themselves reading, writing, and arithmetic. The prize was jointly awarded to Kitkit School and onebillion, both developing child-friendly learning applications. Nokia Sensing XCHALLENGE (2014): Focused on health sensing technologies. The DMI team won for their invention of a lab-quality blood testing platform. Carbon XPRIZE (2021): Aimed at converting CO2 emissions into valuable products. Two teams, CarbonCure Technologies and UCLA CarbonBuilt, won, demonstrating concrete production methods using CO2. Shell Ocean Discovery XPRIZE (2019): Aimed at advancing deep-sea technologies. The GEBCO-NF Alumni team won, developing autonomous ocean mapping technology.
- eesmith 3y agohttps://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Xprize_Foundation https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Xprize_Foundation shows no one won the Qualcomm Tricorder XPRIZE. That pages also lists additional prizes not listed in your summary. At least several of them must have a winner, so long as someone participates, as there is no hard goal and a winner is chosen from the participants. (For examples, "improve" and "build better" are soft goals.)
- daynthelife 3y agoThis is probably a controversial opinion, but I think we should be careful what we wish for. Death is a necessary part of life. Without it, society will stagnate, overpopulation will become even more rampant, resources will become more scarce, and dictators will hold power for unbounded lengths of time. As hard as it is to say for someone whose mom is battling cancer, I feel similarly about a complete cure for cancer. Death ultimately needs a way to come for us all. The alternative is so much worse.
- taosx 3y agoWe don't even know what a world with less death would look like, if we could be able to delay death, why wouldn't then be able to focus on stagnation, overpopulation and resources. And if something can be done I believe it will be done, if we want it or not. I'm really sorry to hear about your mom. It's tough to see a loved one going through something like that. Wishing her strength and recovery, and hoping you get to spend many more happy moments together.
- jazzyjackson 3y agocheck out season one of "Altered Carbon" for an imaginative take on life extension. The rich are immortal, and keeping you alive can be used against you, resuscitating you against your will.
- kiba 3y agoThis is probably a controversial opinion, but I think we should be careful what we wish for. Death is a necessary part of life. Without it, society will stagnate, overpopulation will become even more rampant, resources will become more scarce, and dictators will hold power for unbounded lengths of time. No. The controversial opinion is saying that death is unnecessary. Your opinion represent the 'mainstream' opinion. I would argue that it's status quo bias, or justification and rationalization for having death. Humans are very good at justifying things after the fact. But taking a look at the individual objections, it either falls apart or a lot more complicated than you think. For example, the fear of societal stagnation. I think this is an overblown concern. People are always changing, however slowly and imperceptible it may be. An 80 years old is going to think very differently than 8 years ago. People are always worried about overpopulation, but you know who pollute the most? Rich countries. The richer you are, the more meat you eat, the more 'resources' you consume. Currently, overpopulation is really about pollution than running out of raw resources, such metals and minerals and energy. We would overheat ourselves before running out of space. Obviously, there's going to be a finite limit, but that limit is so far off that it's basically ludicrous to think about. Dictatorships holding power for unbounded length of time? Sure, dictators might live forever, but it's clear that their society often basically 'stagnate', more like went backward. If you see North Korea and South Korea, you know that South Korea have more lights. Plus, just because you're a dictatorship doesn't mean it's a stable governing structure. There are dictatorships and military junta that are short lived or had been overthrown. Dictators can blunder into serious strategic mistakes, like Mr. Putin. Some even voluntarily democratized, like Taiwan! Human societies are inherently dynamic system that changes over time. It would be difficult to imagine a system that somehow managed to keep things exactly the same. There's always room for disruption.
- mensetmanusman 3y agoBillionaires dangling shiny coins to get the plebs excited about immortal overlords.
- donaldagnes 3y ago[dead]