4 ms·
No. If you're talking about pumping cash into our defense industry, the whole point is that's taking production away from elsewhere. Defense is getting bigger,
by crazygringo 3y ago
No.
If you're talking about pumping cash into our defense industry, the whole point is that's taking production away from elsewhere. Defense is getting bigger, something else is getting smaller in the short term.
Sure, the whole thing has some some ancillary benefits, like getting real-world data, or "advertising to prospective arms buyers", but those benefits don't make up anywhere near what we're spending. If we only wanted those benefits, we would get them far cheaper by themselves.
So no, there are absolutely downsides. This is the very broken glass fallacy that I referred to. I'll repeat the final paragraph of the original for you to read -- you may want to read the whole Wikipedia article though:
> It is not seen that as our shopkeeper has spent six francs upon one thing, he cannot spend them upon another. It is not seen that if he had not had a window to replace, he would, perhaps, have replaced his old shoes, or added another book to his library. In short, he would have employed his six francs in some way, which this accident has prevented.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Parable_of_the_broken_window https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Parable_of_the_broken_window
Again -- I totally support what we're doing, for the record. But money doesn't come free. We shouldn't pretend like this is all almost for free or something. It's not.
- D13Fd 3y agoThe window is already broken. Russia broke it. You are saying we shouldn’t help our ally deter Russia and China from breaking more windows. In your analogy, we are paying to help Ukraine go after the kids throwing stones at windows.
- hyperpape 3y agoQuoting the parent: > Again -- I totally support what we're doing, for the record. But money doesn't come free. We shouldn't pretend like this is all almost for free or something. It's not.
- dralley 3y agoNobody said it came for "free" but it's a hell of a lot more efficient than any other military expenditures we've made in the past 20 years.
- crazygringo 3y ago> Nobody said it came for "free" Yes they did. That's basically the entire point the article is trying to make. That my original content was refuting.
- hamandcheese 3y ago> Defense is getting bigger, something else is getting smaller in the short term. This seems to assume the economy is a fixed-size pie. Is that a valid assumption?
- crazygringo 3y agoYes, it is in this case. This arms production isn't adding to economic growth to increase the size of the pie -- it's merely shifting it. Because its outputs are being sent abroad and not in a way that increases the economic efficiency of anything. If this money were being invested in American business that built products and services sold to Americans, then it would be part of domestic economic growth and the pie would get bigger. But it's not. It's just shifting money instead. The pie size is fixed here.
- deadbolt 3y agoWhere’s the money come from?
- standardUser 3y ago> And all those extra workers that have been hired? Well, they came from working on other things. Why should we assume money diverted from one industry to the defense industry is not a net again for the US economy?
- readthenotes1 3y agoWouldn't it be cheaper just to print the money and give it to people directly without having to engage in all the waste required to start a war to require the bombs to require the employees to give them money?
- notyofriend 3y agoNah that would go to increasing real estate and equity prices. So actually raising the rent on the real economy
- kian 3y agoBecause the entire economic system is too complex for humans to micro-manage without negative downstream effects? I recommend some Hayek if you find this idea implausible.
- rainsford 3y agoThe real nuance of the broken window fallacy is that it's about the lack of economic benefit of a window being broken, not the most economically beneficial decision to make once it is. Clearly you're better off if you have an intact window and you can spend your six francs on something you don't already have. But once your window is broken, replacing it is an equally viable economic decision compared with other uses of your six francs. The window breaking represents an economic loss, but replacing it might actually be the most economically advantageous decision of the ones available ("I wish it wasn't broken" not being an actual option). In the case of the Russia invasion of Ukraine, Russia already broke the metaphorical window by throwing a giant rock through it. So now the relevant economic benefits discussion of sending weapons to Ukraine to use to shoot Russians vs buying everyone in America a pony should be framed (hah) post broken window, not from some hypothetical perspective where keeping an intact window is an option. I totally agree there are economic downsides, nobody should be arguing they don't exist. But I think it's important to make it clear the economic downsides are from Russia starting the war. Once they did so, I think it is reasonable to argue our best economic response is to help Ukraine defend themselves.
- audunw 3y agoThere are probably some economic downsides, but it’s far, far less than what you’d see based on looking at the raw spending. If most of the money is going to modernise the US military while freeing up old stock to send to Ukraine, that’s arguably money that would eventually have to have been spent anyway. Windows do need to be replaced eventually. If you’re replacing an unbroken window a few years before it would’ve been strictly necessary, the cost associated with that early replacement isn’t very high. Considering how attractive US military exports are becoming, I’m not convinced that the spending is a net negative for the US economy in the long term.