3 ms·
Do a present value calculation of the real value of a solid pension. You'll get a value well into the 6 figures, if not 7 figures. Now do a present value ca
by bryanlarsen 3y ago
Do a present value calculation of the real value of a solid pension. You'll get a value well into the 6 figures, if not 7 figures. Now do a present value calculation of all the health insurance premiums a person will have to pay over their lifetime. And similar for all the other social insurances Nordic citizens get for free.
That's all real wealth that's not calculated in your links.
Or put another way: the Nordic model does not reduce inequality, it reduces the consequences of inequality.
- hash872 3y agoThe US spends over a trillion dollars on Social Security annually, plus I believe another $1.4 trillion or so once you add up both Medicare and Medicaid. (Fun fact no one knows, the US now spends more on healthcare for the elderly than the entire famous military budget). So that covers both pensions and healthcare (which are never free for anyone in any country, you obviously have to pay at some point). So once we factor in over 2 trillion dollars of annual US spending on pensions and healthcare, I doubt there's a huge difference there
- UtopiaPunk 3y agoThe USA spends more on healthcare per capita than many other countries, but our life expectancy and general health is worse than other high-income countries. https://www.commonwealthfund.org/publications/issue-briefs/2023/jan/us-health-care-global-perspective-2022 https://www.commonwealthfund.org/publications/issue-briefs/2...
- bryanlarsen 3y agoAnd US social security measures also significantly reduce the impact of inequality.
- alephnerd 3y ago> Do a present value calculation of the real value of a solid pension. It's irrelevant. Each Nordic country is different. Sweden and Denmark's national pension pays out largely similar to American Social Security ($1k-$3k/month) Finland's appears to cap at around $1.5k/month and the rest is on you. Norway's is very generous (114% of monthly income), but it's easy to be generous when you are also a petro-state and your pension is backed by the National Oil Fund. In all these pensions, you have to contribute to the state pension fund in order to receive more than the bare mimimim ($1k/month) at a level largely comparable to Social Security deductions. It honestly isn't that different than the US SSA, especially factoring in CoL which is California or MA level but average wages are around $30-$50k nominal The "Nordic Model" that became vogue in American political discourse is the Norwegian model, which is almost entirely subsidized by oil. We may as well copy Saudi's social welfare program then (on a separate note it is actually pretty generous after massive concessions were given after the Arab Spring).
- bhpm 3y ago>The "Nordic Model" that became vogue in American political discourse is the Norwegian model, which is almost entirely subsidized by oil. We may as well copy Saudi's social welfare program then (on a separate note it is actually pretty generous after massive concessions were given after the Arab Spring). Unironically yes. The US is the largest producer of oil and the fourth largest exporter. Use the oil money to fund healthcare.
- alephnerd 3y agoNorway has 5 million people. The US has 330 million people. It's easier to spread wealth among a small population. This is why Alaska has had a sovereign oil fund since the 70s and Texas since the 90s.
- nly 3y agoUK state pension is only $1100/mo from age 68 :/