5 ms·
How is putting an extended battery pack in the bed of a truck novel enough to get a patent...? It seems so obvious and uninventive and we already do this with l
by verdverm 3y ago
How is putting an extended battery pack in the bed of a truck novel enough to get a patent...? It seems so obvious and uninventive and we already do this with liquid fuels. Guess we'll have to see if Rivian wants to try and defend it and what the courts think about it
- toomuchtodo 3y agoSounds like a fun exercise to challenge Rivian's patent with prior art perhaps.
- Rebelgecko 3y agoThe patent seems to mostly be focused on the battery cooling mechanisms
- JohnFen 3y agoI couldn't find the actual patent in a quick search, but the odds are extremely high that the patent isn't as general as it sounds. The title of the patent isn't relevant, it's the actual claims in the patent that matter. Odds are, those claims are for something pretty specific, like a special interconnect or something, not for the concept of extended battery packs. But hey, you never know. The patent office has approved bad patents before. It's not impossible that this is an patent office error.
- phonon 3y agohttps://patents.google.com/patent/US20190016231A1/en https://patents.google.com/patent/US20190016231A1/en https://www.rivianforums.com/forum/threads/revealed-rivian-patent-for-auxiliary-battery-module-to-achieve-400-miles-range.53/ https://www.rivianforums.com/forum/threads/revealed-rivian-p...
- willy_k 3y agoThe patent describes an “Electric Vehicle With Modular Removable Auxiliary Battery With Integrated Cooling”.
- Kirby64 3y agoYou need to read the claims. This patent could easily be circumvented, for instance, by making it a non-removable battery (i.e., it's installed afterwards but 'cannot' be removed...). There's probably other workarounds or loopholes but this patent seems relatively weak. I doubt Tesla will have any issues here.
- willy_k 3y agoThe sole purpose of my comment was to state in a comment the information from the link that’s relevant to this discussion, which is what the new part of the patent, which I understand to be the cooling system. I know nothing about patent law.
- DoesntMatter22 3y agoIt doesn't even matter if tesla did. This is a nothing burger even if it's true. Rivian uses numerous patents from Tesla and the cost of using those patents is a mutually assured agreement to not sue if Tesla then uses your patents. So even if Tesla used it, it's going to be be free to use
- kahnclusions 3y agoEven if they are very specific claims, it still can’t be something that would be obvious to the average automotive engineer trying to solve the problem. There needs to be some kind of inventive step involved.
- throwaway290 3y agoSubjective concepts like "obvious" or "average engineer" are not in the equation. Is it a new thing? Is there prior art? That's why innovation pays and R&D is worth it.
- rafatmit 3y ago“A patent for a claimed invention may not be obtained, notwithstanding that the claimed invention is not identically disclosed as set forth in section 102, if the differences between the claimed invention and the prior art are such that the claimed invention as a whole would have been obvious before the effective filing date of the claimed invention to a person having ordinary skill in the art to which the claimed invention pertains.” 35 U.S.C. § 103.
- throwaway290 3y agoThe quote says "prior art must not be too similar as of filing date" which is reasonable. I guess there was no sufficient prior art that detailed coolant connectors and all that stuff ;)
- robomartin 3y ago> obvious to the average automotive engineer trying to solve the problem That isn't the criteria by which non-obviousness is evaluated. In addition to that, a lot of patents that seem obvious to those not experienced in reading and evaluating patents have subtle differentiation in the claims that narrow their scope in a manner sufficient enough to gain admission. IANAL, yet, I have read and analyzed thousands of patents, filed dozens (with the help of patent attorneys) and have taken a couple of courses on patent prosecution from the USPTO and other sources. Having said that, as an engineers, I do think that a huge body of patents ought to be summarily thrown out. I feel that a massive number of patents don't have one iota of real invention in them. This Rivian patent might very well be one of them. In a lot of cases patents such as this one are filed and just to get to the freedom-to-operate threshold. In other words, to defend against being told that you can't do what you are doing because someone else has a patent that might cover it. This is how we end-up with millions of bullshit patents for things that just don't look like true invention to anyone in the field who has more than two functioning neurons in their head. There's invention and then there are patents. The mistake I made as a young engineer was thinking that the two were equivalent. They are not. At all.
- sheepshear 3y agoSo many patents these days are old ideas described with very specific qualifiers to circumvent the prior art disqualifier.
- namlem 3y agoThe patent is probably for the specific implementation, not the general concept.