4 ms·
Businesses don’t really exist, they are an imaginary construct that we’ve come up with to help organize resources, ultimately in the interests of working togeth
by bee_rider 3y ago
Businesses don’t really exist, they are an imaginary construct that we’ve come up with to help organize resources, ultimately in the interests of working together.
Business isn’t more important than anything. There are multiple users, sometimes with competing interests; you can’t be everywhere and everything, so you have to prioritize. Going after more profitable users or users that align with some long-term strategy could be seen as “good for the business,” but really the goal is to serve the users (it might just take a couple extra steps).
When the internal politics get confused to the point that people are making decisions just to further the interests of the business without figuring out how it leads to user happiness, the organization has become poisonous. It shouldn’t exist anymore. It might lurch on in a zombie state for quite some time. But it is on the decline, and all the good people will leave.
- charles_f 3y agoI had the same initial reaction. Seeing something written that can be amounted to $ > person looks wrong. Yet, importance is subjective. If you're working on your own pet code for your own pleasure, business has no importance. If you want to transform that into your main revenue source, business is the most important thing, because no amount of user love will transform into practical revenue if your software serves no-one.
- bee_rider 3y agoIf your project is useful to users and requires money to continue, it is in their interest that you make money. The business is just an abstraction around the fact that your users need you to be able to do the thing.
- steamer25 3y agoIt's not really $ > person. It's group of people A, who are conducting a [series of] transaction(s) with group of people B. It so happens that the wares being exchanged are currency vs. software but that's really besides the point. Group of people A ≹ Group of people B
- fritzo 3y agoLet's charitably interpret 'business' here as "a sustainable funding model that can support maintenance, support, and future development". Without a business model, even great user-pleasing, deployable, maintainable software can fizzle out.
- bee_rider 3y agoIt is a useful imaginary construct. It captures the idea that your users, if you are doing something useful, have an interest in you continuing to be able to do it. IMO the reason the article had bring up this obscure !>< operator is because it treated this particular set of user interests as somehow separate from the users. The reason it is hard to rank business vs user interest is because business \in user.
- franga2000 3y agoThis is simply not true. Business exist as legal constructs and there are many things that are good for the business but bad for almost everyone else. Business also do not exist to serve users, whatever definition of user you might have. Business, unfortunately, exist to serve their owners. In most cases (I'm talking primarily about larger companies, not <5 people micro-businesses) the owners want money, so everyone at the company is there in order to get the owner more money. Happiness of anyone else, let alone the users, is entirely irrelevant, unless it happens to correlate with revenue. The only other universal incentive inside a company is self-preservstion, so besides doing whatever makes money, decision-makers will also take their own job security into account when making decisions. Employees won't leave, because the company will make sure they're happy enough. It's surprisingly easy to keep people working for evil and/or faceless organisations if you pay them well, make them feel like part of a "community", etc. (see any FAANG office for an in-depth catalogue of these HR tricks) I agree that this is "poisonous" and that such a company "shouldn't exist anymore", but this is how companies work in practice. This is not a sign of any kind of decline, but of a mature and healthy business that can keep going for decades. Execs change, products change, even owners change, but the business remains.
- smabie 3y agoPretty sure the <5 ppl micro businesses just want money too
- bee_rider 3y agoI think our perspectives are not really too far apart. Maybe it is just a matter of emphasis. > This is simply not true. Business exist as legal constructs and there are many things that are good for the business but bad for almost everyone else. It “exists” as an imaginary construct. The imagining of it exists. Imaginary constructs have been hugely influential through history. Just think of the mythical figures in whatever religion you don’t believe in. People live and die for these figures. But the figures themselves don’t have any interests because only the belief in them exists, not the actual figures. > Business, unfortunately, exist to serve their owners. In most cases (I'm talking primarily about larger companies, not <5 people micro-businesses) the owners want money, so everyone at the company is there in order to get the owner more money. I sort of disagree here. From the worker’s point of view, the business exists to sign their paychecks. Why is this not just as valid as the owners’ point of view? Realistically, lots of work-politics are driven by the interest of individuals to keep those paychecks coming in. For example, people will make it look like they are working harder than they actually are. Managers will inflate their headcount to appear more important. Etc etc. All of these things happen inside businesses, and if you look at the man-hours spent on them, I don’t think it is obvious that the interest of the owners is a bigger focus of energy. Particularly if we treat “the interest of the owners” as some distinct thing, separate from customer happiness or writing artful code. I think people don’t actually “think of the shareholders” much while doing their jobs, day-to-day. How else can we think of the priorities of a non-sentient thing, other than the aggregate priorities of its sentient, priority-having members? > Employees won't leave, because the company will make sure they're happy enough. […] > This is not a sign of any kind of decline, but of a mature and healthy business that can keep going for decades. For these two points, in retrospect I was terribly vague to the point of just being either wrong or so open to misinterpretation as to be indistinguishable from wrong, so sorry for that. By “good people,” I meant people who were not interested in doing the things you listed. For “zombie state,” I meant shambling on profitably, but not doing anything interesting anymore. See IBM for most of our lives. I accept blame for this one! In particular, I regret writing “good people” because of course “good” is wildly open to interpretation. > Execs change, products change, even owners change, but the business remains. I mean, this is sort of a “business of Theseus.” It is really a matter of perspective if, having replaced every component, it is really the same business. Except, in this case, there isn’t even a physical ship in the end to point at. —- Also, it might be worth noting—the article is about what one ought to do, when weighing interests of different parties (user, dev, ops, “business”). If you disagree with me and think the business exists, maybe you agree that prioritizing it over users is not what we ought to do.
- switchbak 3y agoBusinesses don’t really exist? That's like saying feelings don't exist: they're just constructs that we come up with to explain our reactions to situations. I suppose that's true to a degree, but something doesn't need to be made of atoms to be "real". Businesses exist in as much as they are the primary determinant of most people's lives. They shape our cities, our media, laws, politics, foreign policy and have a huge impact in just about everything else that matters. Real or not, it has _real_ impacts all around us. Outside of OSS, I think it's pretty clear that the entity that's footing the bill gets to make the call on how things get made. Even if that's: bad for said entity, bad for the user, bad for the public generally, the environment, etc. (of course, there's industry and governmental regulations, but by and large the company calls the shots).
- bee_rider 3y ago> Businesses exist in as much as they are the primary determinant of most people's lives. They shape our cities, our media, laws, politics, foreign policy and have a huge impact in just about everything else that matters. By this standard, ancient religious figures (now mostly regarded as mythological) exist. Thor, or Zeus (if anyone is a pagan here, I don’t mean any disrespect to your beliefs, but let’s think about whichever one you don’t believe in). > Real or not, it has _real_ impacts all around us. Sure. But people were much more devoted to these figures than any business! Religious wars were fought, people lived and died for these gods. But some of these figures still were imaginary. Being imaginary doesn’t mean they aren’t important. But it means they don’t have interests. In reality, these organizations (religions, businesses) have members, users, and leaders/owners, and the business is an abstract representation of those people. That’s why it doesn’t make sense to ask whether “the business,” which exists entirely as an abstraction for some of their interests, ought to be prioritized above or below them.