22 ms·
Return to office is 'dead,' Stanford economist says
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- xeromal 3y ago[flagged]
- nequo 3y agoWitty anecdotes are more useful than witty memes and hot takes. One value of comment sections is they add personal anecdotes to the general story. But memes and hot takes add little.
- xeromal 3y agoI think they all belong in the trash especially about things like this which have been beaten to death. One just happens to make me laugh
- Boogie_Man 3y agoChatGPT constantly sounding like a psychotic millennial BuzzFeed writer always makes me a little nervous about the training data.
- xeromal 3y agoI know right? haha
- DoingIsLearning 3y agoThe clear agenda divide across different media platforms is interesting. WSJ, Fortune, FT, all fall along the same line with opinions about all the cons of remote work, or all the virtues of RTO. Whilst most online only newspapers fall along the opposite end of the spectrum. Seems like a topic where everyone has made up their mind and will only accept data if it aligns with their world view.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- outside1234 3y agoOr it is almost like the people they advertise to have a vested interest in RTO. It is sort of like how you see all sorts of segments about "the hydrogen economy" on Fox News as if they live in some bizzaro world there are more than two hydrogen cars out there. It's because the natural gas folks want hydrogen vs. electric and are paying to advertise it.
- geodel 3y agoMakes sense. All financial newspapers are usually located in same downtown where financial or other firms are occupying huge buildings. And so are city halls and other utils. So CEOs and real estate firms would be giving far more interviews to WSJ and FT about virtues of coming to office.
- toomuchtodo 3y agoLets not mince words. CEOs and other folks in that same class certainly get together in person and online discussing these efforts (amongst other topics they're optimizing for of course). "It's a big club, and you ain't in it." -- George Carlin
- geodel 3y agoNo, I totally agree. I just wouldn't use cabal or conspiracy because it is happening in broad daylight.
- toomuchtodo 3y agoFair, agreed.
- dimitrios1 3y agoNothing to do with the media platforms, and everything to do with commercial property owners and commercial real estate. Commercial real estate has big influence in this country and they won't go down without a fight. Media platforms are just shills for whoever is giving them most of their money.
- rossdavidh 3y ago...to be replaced by "actually, you're just laid off, don't come back to the office after all".
- outside1234 3y agoThat might be the case at some companies, but my company has realized this means less facilities, less money, less problems, and once companies (and shareholders) see that, there are going to be more questions about WHY do we need to spend money on your "towering glass box" when we can get it for free from the employee home?
- toss1 3y agoYup. The primary driver of RTO is the massive overhang in corporate real estate. Not only was it overbuilt, it is now also redundant (and not in a good way). Notice one of the primary drivers is Jamie Dimon, Charimand & CEO of JPMorgan Chase, who will be a huge loser in a office real-estate crash, as are many of the other drivers. Meanwhile, most workers have seen that daily commuting is an absurdly wasteful anachronism, and astute managers have noticed (as IBM did decades ago), that remote work slashes Capital Expenditures for real estate, and has gives a massive talent advantage, since your available talent pool is national or global, instead of only a small radius around each office. They can keep trying to make RTO happen, but it won't. RTO has flatlined, and remote will only grow. It'll probably stay stable as current office leases continue to run, but on expiration, any smart company will reevaluate if they really need so much office space.
- geodel 3y ago> Notice one of the primary drivers is Jamie Dimon, Chariman & CEO of JPMorgan Chase, who will be a huge loser in a office real-estate crash, Could be just coincidence that he recently sold his 140 million dollar worth of shares of JP Morgan.
- postexitus 3y agoWith anachronism induced limitations removed and available talent pool unlocked globally, the unfortunate truth is that the average developer comp will come way down. I am not an RTO supporter and highly paid developers supporting RTO is the biggest hand gun ever in human history.
- robg 3y agoCounterpoint: https://www.oregonlive.com/politics/2023/11/portland-mayor-ted-wheeler-renews-plea-for-in-person-work-downtown.html?outputType=amp https://www.oregonlive.com/politics/2023/11/portland-mayor-t... Local officials feel more pressure from the business community.
- geodel 3y agoSeems both article saying roughly same thing. CNBC: 0/1/2/3/4 days at office Oregon Live: At least 20 hours from office for city employees.
- chadash 3y agoI mean, it's not really dead. It has just flatlined in the short term, which makes sense. We are long past the point where most people are concerned about getting sick from COVID, so if your company hasn't called in workers yet, then it seems unlikely that they are going to in the near future. The question is where things shake out in the long term. What percentage of young and growing companies will start remote and remain remote, start in person and then go remote, or start in person and remain in person (it's hard to imagine starting remote and then going in person, but I guess that's possible too)? The long-term outcome is still unclear, and it will take a long time for the dust to settle.
- kmlx 3y ago> it's hard to imagine starting remote and then going in person, but I guess that's possible too wasn’t github started remote-only and then went to some in-person?
- kingTug 3y ago> We are long past the point where most people are concerned about getting sick from COVID Sadly true. I wish there was more discourse on HN about this. I don't think 10+ years from now this will be sustainable without revelatory therapeutics or vaccines that offer complete and total protection. It seems clear that this is going to be a slow burn where everyone's immune system gets nicked, little by little. Contracting covid once a year or couple of years seems to be the reality we're willing to live with and I am terrified of the long term implications of this.
- bell-cot 3y ago> "Return to the office is dead," Nick Bloom, an economics professor at Stanford University and expert on the work-from-home revolution, wrote this week. So...it's "Entrenched Senior $Trend Expert says that counter-$Trend ain't gonna happen".
- zzleeper 3y agoI wanted to point this out, albeit slighty less cynically. NickB invested a lot of capital into becoming the expert on WFH (see e.g. https://wfhresearch.com/project-team/ https://wfhresearch.com/project-team/ ). Whenever I see this in other economists, more likely than not their findings tend to go towards where their capital is invested.
- bell-cot 3y ago> Whenever I see... LORDY, yes. The only solid "scientific" theory which Economists seem to have developed is the millenia-old one of predicting which "truths" each emperor / prince / nobleman / etc. will want to be told.
- phillipcarter 3y agoEconomics professor, meet corporate SVP: "it’s time to disagree and commit. We’re here, we’re back—it’s working, I don’t have data to back it up, but I know it’s better." Source: https://web.archive.org/web/20231129224726/https://fortune.com/2023/08/03/amazon-svp-mike-hopkins-office-return/ https://web.archive.org/web/20231129224726/https://fortune.c...
- coffeebeqn 3y agoBeautifully persuasive
- dvlsg 3y agoAn interesting choice of words. "I don't have the data to back it up" seems to want to imply "we don't have the data at all". But I don't buy that Amazon, of all companies, doesn't have the data. I assume they have it, and it doesn't back what they're trying to push.
- luckydata 3y agowhy would you think Amazon has any data to support that notion? I work at Google and I can tell you for sure we don't. RTO is about how leaders feel about things, not about data.
- phillipcarter 3y agoThe vibes is the data.
- Spivak 3y agoAre you my current CEO? He accidentally let slip that he unilaterally is (trying to) force RTO for 200 people because he's lonely. Oh boo hoo get a social life outside of work. We all suddenly understood why he was not even bothering to engage with the near unanimous disagreement with it.
- karaterobot 3y agoThey're essentially saying that between a quarter and a half of work days are spent at home. They're not saying that WFH won, or that RTO won, and technically they're not even saying that hybrid won. Measuring "work days" is useful in some ways, but I'd like to know about the percentage of fully remote, fully in-office, and hybrid office jobs. I suspect that a hybrid of in-office and WFH work is probably where we are settling, and I think that's far from ideal. With hybrid, you don't get the mobility you get with working from home: you can't live where you want, because you still have to commute into the office a couple days a week. From the business' perspective, you don't get the benefits of hiring people from other time zones (the greater size of the talent pool and, if you are despicable, the option to pay people less for the same result because they live somewhere else). You still have to pay for commercial real estate, even when it's not fully occupied. And, unless everyone's in-office on the same days—which is not the norm with hybrid offices—you still get all the annoyances of having Zoom calls. In other words, I think we're in the process of settling into a mistake. No surprise there I guess. It would be better, in my view, for some companies to be 100% WFH, and other companies 100% in-office. The "native" remote companies I've worked for, the ones who were built around being remote, for were highly productive. Some office-centric companies I've worked for were productive, too. I've not worked for a hybrid company that was really very good.
- rob74 3y agoPssst, don't say that too loud! I resisted RTO, but at least now I still have two days of home office per week, which gives me at least a bit of flexibility. If the opinion that hybrid work is not a good compromise settles in with the powers that be, I think the pendulum will swing toward "fully in office" rather than toward "fully remote".
- JambalayaJim 3y agoGood hybrid policies should mean people are in-office on the same day. People who work together that is, it doesn't have to be the entire company. This is my current workplace's hybrid policy. It doesn't even make sense to call any other policy "hybrid", in my opinion. You're not actually working in-person with your colleagues in that case, so yeah it's functionally the same as remote work.
- dathmar 3y agoRTO was a way for companies to encourage employees to quit without the need to pay severance. Once those people left then additional downsizing happened. For the most part this has already taken place. Companies that were going to play that game are done and companies that didn't need to downsize never played. I doubt any of this posturing was about effectiveness of remote, hybrid, or in office work.
- mapster 3y agoLikely, though for companies w very skilled (expensive to replace) labor there is much sensitivity re hybrid or WFH. A lot of Bay Area companies are simple downsizing and moving closer to those employees who will be in office. Win win
- newsclues 3y agoMany people refusing to return to the office will complain when their salaries adjust to the new normal.
- devnullbrain 3y agoThe ship has sailed. If the job is outsourceable, they'll adjust regardless. There's not much inherent value in being from the same region as the headquarters & most of what there is comes from timezones.
- gilbetron 3y agoMuch like the threat that food workers will be replaced with robots if minimum wage increases, this is a threat without much bite. If companies thought they could get equal workers by outsourcing and reducing salaries, they already would have. Either being in office is a competitive advantage, or it isn't. We'll find out in the coming years, but I'm pretty sure the answer will be "it depends". And most people will readily accept a pay cut for lower salary if they can live in a lower cost of living area.
- onetimeuse92304 3y ago> Meanwhile, worker productivity hasn’t suffered Correction. Some people, work their assess off all times of the day because now they can be reached around the clock. Some people work the same but make up with availability which can be valuable in itself (I am one of these people). And some people goof off even more than before. Maybe the total productivity didn't change, but definitely it has shifted. The question is what happens now. I think what happens is companies will get better at understanding who is and who isn't spending time working (I am careful not to use word "productive"). And some companies will monitor this and some will make conscious decision to focus on trying to get better at understanding actual productivity. The ones that monitor working time I call sweatshops and I would try to stay away from at all cost. You want to compete on quality of your work or even on productivity. But you definitely do not want to compete with your coworkers over who can spend more time by the computer because there simply are no winners in this game. -- One way it can bite people is that it may help the companies identify who is productive (if the company is smart about it). I once talked with my boss about why he is allowing employees to access company funds (within certain limit). The finances people are furious and want to cut it off and instead give some ridiculously low limit for spending. So one argument is that it allows people to be more efficient. When they need something, they don't have to wait for approvals or for "process". But then the boss also says: "It is much cheaper for me to have an employee steal couple thousand dollars from me because I can easily identify it and fire the employee. It is much more expensive to keep that employee." I think the same applies to working from home. When you allow people to do pretty much what they want, thinking they are unsupervised, you have now much better chance to identify employees who are completely immature, irresponsible or fraudulent about it.
- wkat4242 3y agoMouse jiggler for the win lol. That's what I use when I "goof off".
- hgomersall 3y agoDo you have any evidence to support your assertions?
- 3y ago
- fnordpiglet 3y agoThe only point in the article that matters is the only point that will decide the debate as passions cool: "What makes companies money tends to stick," he said. RTO is dead because it’s economically inefficient. Over time the emotional “but I like my employees to sit where I can see them” will be less and less compelling to boards and shareholders. After time has passed, say 5 years, the next recession will kill the corporate sponsored office and will usher in the “Bring Your Own Office” age. BYOD saved millions. BYOO will save hundreds of millions.
- AnimalMuppet 3y agoQuestion for the HN crowd: How much of a pay cut would you accept to WFH? You should at least accept less by the amount of your commuting costs, because you're not paying that any more. But you're also getting the commuting time back, which might be worth some money too. You're essentially working fewer hours. (Yeah, they're not working hours. Still, it's hours that you can use for what you want instead of for something related to work.) Anyone care to put a number on it? Or do people only like it at the same salary?
- JambalayaJim 3y agoI would require a pay increase to WFH. This is because I'd need to rent my own office in a co-working space.
- dave78 3y ago> But you're also getting the commuting time back, which might be worth some money too. Not necessarily - a lot of people (myself included) essentially give that time to their employer. I drop my kids off at school and start work when I get home at 8am and work until 5pm when I pick them up. When I go in, my commute necessarily occurs between those two events. In my company at least, I don't think this is rare. On the rare days I go into the office, it's easy to notice that people don't show up until well after 9 and everyone is gone by 3:30-4. I think many people have shifted to taking their commute time from what used to be considered the employer's time rather than personal time.
- 3y ago
- throw555chip 3y ago[flagged]
- mvdtnz 3y ago> If a few powerful people can engineer a disease like COVID an unleash it the world, What
- asdajksah2123 3y agoSo much wrong in this comment including the obtuse conspiracy mongering. But I wanted to answer the simple question that's posed. The stock market is going up because company profits are going up. Additionally the return of war thanks to the spread of populist nationalism and the growth of AI both promise future growth in profits as well. It adds up very comfortably.
- wkat4242 3y ago> These days, most remote work is done as part of a “hybrid” arrangement, with some days at home and the rest in the office. For me the office days are terrible now though. I used to have my own desk, obviously that doesn't fly with hybrid. But the whole running around with laptops is just so horrible. I really hate the office (and the colleagues that love the office and keep asking us to come in because they feel lonely or something). I don't think this works for me.
- btbuildem 3y agoIt's good to see the broad but anecdotal sentiment backed up by data. The RTO/WFH struggle is clearly about money (what else could it be about in a corporate world?), and it's fascinating to watch some companies chew their own limbs off (metaphorically speaking) to appease investors-at-large. Here I speculate, but the pattern seems to be that board members are involved with multiple organizations, and are stakeholders in even more - and those with ties to commercial real estate (and all the funds heavily invested into it) will do whatever it takes to push for higher office occupancy. At the same time, they're doing this (arguably) to a disadvantage to the companies they're supposed to steward - forcing best talent out, paying a premium for half-empty office space, and generally eroding morale by this display of duplicity. At the same time, I love seeing the quiet resistance by the rank-and-file and even some middle management. The new reality is here, and there's no going back. The % of days WFH has flatlined, and I imagine over time it will begin to slowly but steadily trend back up.
- matchbok 3y agoI love how it has to be some massive conspiracy, not the well-known fact that junior employees and productivity both take a hit with full-time remote work. A lot of these orgs are coasting and the impact won't be known for a while.
- EA-3167 3y agoIf that's a "well-known fact" then could I trouble you for some sources to that end?
- Workaccount2 3y agoReminder to HN: Only a tiny sliver of the workforce are tech workers who are tasked to write lines of code on a laptop all day. RTO articles are about RTO in general, not RTO for developers.
- danaris 3y agoSure, but that doesn't mean only a tiny sliver of the workforce does 99.5% of their work on a computer every day. There are other whole professions that can cheerfully go full remote so long as they have adequate tech support for it.
- Spivak 3y agoCustomer support, sales, marketing, design, finance, account management, customer retention, management, hr, legal, purchasing, leadership, analysts of ever form, copywriters,... If your work is at all "office job" you probably don't need to be anywhere particular.
- yafbum 3y agoThe title is misleading without context. TFA doesn't argue that RTO is a bad policy or is being abandoned. It only presents facts showing that the post-COVID RTO trend is flatlining, i.e. employees aren't currently RTO'ing any more or any less than they were last month (as a share of paid work days).
- _8j50 3y agoIt's always frustrating when you live in a capitalist economy but rich people don't care about saving money. I disagree with the sentiment that RTO is about saving money. For most companies saving on real estate cost would make a big difference on their bottomline. But what really frustrates me is they could save at least 10-15% on salary (biggest cost for most companies) for those who want to WFH. Part of it is manager ego but a bigger part in my opinion is like most things in the corporate world, consultants are driving RTO because they always have a conflict if interest (the real estate companies they also consult with) and by nature they're extroverts. I've worked with people in the past where even though it is their job, they will not lift a finger to help you unless they socialize with you in person and know they can play political quid-pro-quo. These people cannot function remotely and many of them are typically managers. But see, I would have expected consultants to use the opportunity to train management on how to manage a remote workforce efficiently. A lot of money to be saved/made all around with WFH but greed has gotten so bad they want the whole cake and be able to show it off. More cake isn't good enough.
- JambalayaJim 3y ago>I've worked with people in the past where even though it is their job, they will not lift a finger to help you unless they socialize with you in person and know they can play political quid-pro-quo. This is basic human psychology you're talking about, not "political quid-pro-quo" motivation.
- _8j50 3y agoCan you explain to me what you mean? To me, you do your job because that's why you get paid. And for non-managerial roles you work with others not because you want to but because you need to in order to reach assigned objectives. If you request someone to QA your code as a dev for example, the question of the QA guy knowing you in person, liking you and then knowing he can extort favors later on should never be even a consideration. What I was saying was for some people it is a significant consideration and they can't do any of that remotely. They are people persons and extroverts, their mindset does not allow them to do work without considering the social cost benefit analysis to be done in person. These are the people that demand you turn on cameras during a zoom call. I mean, it is what it is, not even a problem so long as managers can manage those people as well as everybody else. But it is exactly those people that end up being managers. It's like trying to explain antarctica to someone in the sahara. You do your job and do it well with no upside other than your paycheck - a lot of people do that and they can be very productive remotely because their objective of getting paid is being met. But when their performance review suffers from their nose not being brown enough they will fall in line and focus on that and inefficiently try to brown nose remotely and then hybrid and still fail and then execs think the reason for lower productivity is WFH not their managerial incompetence for both types of people when they WFH. There are plenty of succesful remote-first companies. If you suffer from productivity loss it is because your managers and hr are failing at their jobs. Not your employees.
- harryf 3y agoTo me the interesting thing is how this plays out vs. commercial real estate market. Rentals in commercial real estate are generally long term (e.g. 3 years or longer). In general companies probably only started serious decision making in 2022 after it become clear "work from home" was not going away after seeing that offices are still partly empty most of the time. That suggests we're probably going to start seeing a commercial real estate collapse, beginning some time in 2024 as significant numbers of rental agreements expire. If that's true, I wonder what impact this will have on cities in general? There are so many potential knock-on consequences it's hard to predict outcomes.
- bee_rider 3y agoIf commercial real-estate could be repurposed to residential units (it isn’t trivial of course, you need way more bathrooms and whatnot!) it would be a great victory for people who would like to live inside.
- jillesvangurp 3y agoMany places still have record low unemployment; meaning that employers have to compete for the best people. And working from home is a perk that is easy to give away. Saves on office cost and keeps people happy. Win win. Having to lease large offices is expensive (though probably about to get a lot cheaper given they are all empty) and having to twist people's arms to make them spend time in it is not a great basis for keeping people happy. They'll get to reflect on the futility of their commute to and from cubicle hell twice a day and might conclude the grass is greener next doors and simply might change job to some place with a better work/life balance. Usually, it's the best people that leave first. People with options tend to go for the nicest ones. That might change if unemployment goes up. Job security for remote workers might not be as strong as for people in the office. When companies have to decide about who to let go, the people they'd miss the least will be at the top of the list. I.e. remote people are at a disadvantage. Either way, I don't think the clock will be reverted to pre 2020 anytime soon. Companies should move on, adapt, and focus on how to make this new reality work for them. Save cost on offices and travel. Provide access to co-working spaces. Tap into the global labor market instead of hiring locally. Ironically, for some places in the world this is a problem in the sense that this drives down rates. I'm seeing that the freelance market has gotten a lot tougher in the last years. I'm competing with people all over Europe. The fact that I'm in Berlin is of relatively low value to my clients.
- nostrademons 3y agoManager of a hybrid team here, 2 remote, 4 in 2 different remote offices, and 4 in the office with me. My experience is that remote workers often have higher velocity but lower agility. When there's a well-defined task and little ambiguity, remote workers can usually complete it faster than in-office workers. But when the task is highly ambiguous, requires many course corrections, involves rapid communication, or relies on a large degree of trust, the in-office teams end up more productive. It all stems from known research on the benefits & detriments of office work, i.e. offices build trust and allow higher-bandwidth communication, but they also have more distractions and a less comfortable work environment. I think the trigger that would bring people back to the office is a new economic boom based on new and unknown technology. That creates a highly ambiguous environment where you're forging ahead in unknown directions and need a lot of trust in leadership to make progress at all. Established companies with known markets probably would be better off adopting remote work - the employees work faster, and there are already well-known processes and strategic direction. Of course, if you're already well-established in your market, it probably doesn't matter what you do.
- theknocker 3y ago[dead]
- m3kw9 3y agoThe tech isn’t there for quick discussion, it’s a very UI/UX issue especially for current generation of video conferencing software, there is a huge layer between digital and physical. Hopefully AR can bridge some of that gap. Future job may look for prospects that are adept in AR office work and will be asked how well they use it
- foobarian 3y agoThis is such a huge gap. Why there is no widespread more impromptu collaboration product I have no idea. I try to get people to use the excalidraw shared whiteboard any chance I get, at least that doesn't require the uncomfortable on-camera appearance. There's got to be some other process we could try to recreate (to the extent possible) that "together" feeling of the office. Maybe set aside an hour when team calls into a meeting but just keep on working as normal? And can banter/ask random questions etc. Otherwise things are just too formal.
- clutchdude 3y agoIt was dead the moment my company got used to expecting us to have video meetings from 8AM to 10AM. It's one thing to get me into the office - it's another to expect me to get everything done in my morning routine, get to the office and immediately be ready in front of a desk, contributing to discussion, communicating status, etc. By the time these meetings wrap up, I get the post meeting notes written down/persisted and do all of the other things you need to do after being in meetings for 2 hours, it is almost lunch time.
- fullshark 3y agoThe Economics just don't make sense for RTO. Now the question does it make sense to pay your labor those big salaries if you don't have an office, and instead are just paying for remote workers who could be anywhere on the planet?
- travisb 3y agoGlobal outsourcing has been a thing for decades now, and yet there are still software developers in California. At the end of the day "anywhere on the planet" just isn't true. Language, work culture, time zones, shared educational base, low network latency, and more are all still important in remote work and place strong constraints on how geographically distributed a team can be. Even splitting a team up between West Coast and East Coast presents difficulties due to time zones -- and that's a case where everything else is more or less identical.
- m3kw9 3y agoJust like paper(physical), companies are digitizing office which is a very natural progression as a result of tech innovations
- carbine 3y agoI think for demanding jobs the distinction between remote and in-office is non-trivial. If you expect people to push themselves to (and past) the limit, coming into the office and handling all the interruptions that entails is an enormous source of daily friction. We hear so much hand wringing about the loss of 'hallway conversations,' but few people seem to discuss the loss of productivity from high performers in particular. I was at an intense startup when the pandemic hit, and switching from in-office to remote was such an unlock. I had an additional ~90 mins a day, could wear whatever, and just focus on executing.
- JumpinJack_Cash 3y agoLike many in here I making the leap to founding a startup. Unlike many in here I have no delusions of 20bn exits, much less 20mm exits, hell not even a 200k personal ROI. But one point I am not willing to negotiate on is physical presence in the same working area. The startup will crash and burn and cost me time and money but while it's still standing I shall be the leader of a wolf pack and in the trenches with my soldiers. If I can't find a group of equally stoked individuals ready to match and amplify my energy I think I'd give up the startup idea entirely and move to South America to buy a Series D Football Club instead. At least footballers are quite the stoked bunch and it's impossible for them to claim that they can WFH.
- firefoxd 3y agoOur company had ~100 people before covid. During covid, we grew to ~700 people. All of which were hired to work remotely. The office was designed for no more than 160 employees, so we can't go back even if we wanted to. And we have people working all over the world. The company gets acquired by a fortune 100 that does not do remote work. Now let's see how this one goes...
- leoh 3y agoNot at Google it ain't over...
- oglop 3y agoLadies and gentlemen, I present to you Shopify. I'm sorry but if it's software related, I don't get going into the office at all. My entire experience before was one of mostly depression at work because I'd get maybe a couple hours a day to code. What the other hours had in store or what the point was, who knows. But, it was mostly for people to talk and network and "feel like they were working" form my cynical perspective. I just don't believe people that say you _have_ to be in office to solve complex problems or some such nonsense. There are too many examples that show this is laughably false. If someone wants to go in, I don't mind. But don't conflate your discomfort of being alone with your mind with "better productivity" because a work environment provides you with distractions.
- HDThoreaun 3y ago> I just don't believe people that say you _have_ to be in office to solve complex problems I don't think anyone is saying that. They're saying that collaboration on those problems is more effective/easier when everyone is in the office together, not that it doesn't happen when remote. It's hard for me to see how this could be wrong. The most obvious example is that when in person I have lunch with colleagues where we talk about work things that we absolutely do not talk about when everyone is remote. There's much less siloization. It's not impossible to fix that in a remote environment, but most companies don't know how to, and instead of replacing leadership with a remote first team it's easier to go back to in person.
- Spivak 3y ago> I don't think anyone is saying that. They're saying that collaboration on those problems is more effective/easier when everyone is in the office together. I genuinely don't ever see this dynamic at least for technical problems. The back-and-forth in Slack of people that can now take time to compose an informed response is second to none. Being able to instantly demo your ideas and pass the screen share around is better than any whiteboarding. I don't get the culture. I'm far less creative if you make me try and make decisions based on whatever knowledge I happen to have in my brain-cache at the moment.
- helen___keller 3y agoI wish someone would tell my employer, who requires me to badge into my office to sit myself and work remotely with my coworkers who operate out of another office
- dr_ 3y agoShouldn’t we be discussing this by industry? Healthcare is 18% of the GDP and seems to be growing. Most, if not all, of healthcare services work is done in person at this time and for the foreseeable future. Remote may work in tech and tech heavy businesses, but it doesn’t work everywhere.
- standardUser 3y agoCan you imagine an employer telling all employees to RTO now, a year and a half after nearly all pandemic restrictions ended? I would be livid. That doesn't seem to be happening on any large scale at this point, and instead companies with a lot of remote workers seem to be hiring more in-office workers, creating a hierarchy where longer tenured employees can WFH and newer employees cannot. Personally, I would hate to be on the losing side of that division.
- hnburnsy 3y agoWhy do so few RTO articles mention the savings in CRE. According to Bard average CRE expenses are... --------------- ...some studies offer insights into the average CRE expenses across different industries and company sizes. Here's a breakdown: By Industry: Finance & Insurance: 10-15% Professional Services: 8-12% Technology: 5-8% Manufacturing: 4-6% Retail: 5-10% By Company Size: Small Companies (1-250 employees): 5-10% Mid-sized Companies (251-2,500 employees): 8-12% Large Companies (>2,500 employees): 10-15% These are just general ranges, and the actual percentage for a specific company can be higher or lower depending on the factors mentioned above.
- mountaineer 3y agoFor the "Ask HN: Who is hiring?" monthly trends, the data shows similar trends. [1] * Remote positions have been consistently 60%+ this year * Onsite peaked at about 23%. * Hybrid peaked at 15%. [1] https://www.hntrends.com/2023/november.html?compare=Remote&compare=Onsite&compare=hybrid https://www.hntrends.com/2023/november.html?compare=Remote&c...
- honkycat 3y agoI don't want to waste a significant portion of my day commuting in a car, and I don't want to pay out the nose to live close to work. People would be more amenable to offices if they were driving to downtowns that aren't paved over car-hells with 30% of the land being taken up for car storage. We built our cities wrong. People have had enough.
- ttymck 3y agoWe being "the US", to clarify?
- ineedaj0b 3y agoif anyone in these comments is hiring or knows a remote job opportunity with very little coding experience, I would be very thankful. I'm driven... but I think it will take ~6ish months to get good at coding and having -any- job in the meantime would very helpful. I delivered furniture prior to this, so any leads would be helpful.
- pmarreck 3y ago100% Remote likely hits ADHD people hardest, btw. A not-insignificant percentage of all people.
- flappyeagle 3y agoThe best societal outcome of remote work is better sorting of talent into higher productivity jobs. If a company paying big bucks needs some some they get to select from a global talent pool, or at least several time zones. The best talent gets the best jobs. This is better for both the employees and the employers. The losers are the under-talented who now must compete with a larger labor pool.
- hintymad 3y agoCan someone help me understand the prof's logic? WFH has dropped to 28% from the early 60% this year, and then flattened. Why did the prof conclude that RTO is dead? Shouldn't the conclusion be that most of the people have returned to office?
- flappyeagle 3y agoYoung people are starting to push for in office from what I see. The transition from school to sitting in your apartment is harsh. For a lot of them in person work is a great place to make friends and romantic partners too.
- egberts1 3y agoEconomist Paul Krugman wrote that by 2005, it would become clear that the Internet's effect on the economy is no greater than the fax machine's.
- grogenaut 3y agoAt this point threads about if RTO or WFH are like arguing about vim vs emacs. It's mostly anecdata and personal preference. And like any change it'd be annoying. If we had ceos forcing all of the devs to use vim there'd be a similar gnashing of teeth especially after everyone optimized their life around an emacs config that finally worked 72%.
- Spivak 3y agoIt's not vim/emacs. It's "use whatever editor works best for you" and "use vim" which is why people are mad. No force need be applied to "we have an office but you can work remotely if you'd like."
- OfficeChad 3y agoNot good. Hopefully the government steps in and drags them back to the office, put the ATF to work!
- gumballindie 3y agoNot in the UK it’s not. Some companies, even those posting jobs here on HN, didnt get the fax that remote work particularity in tech is the way.
- vermaden 3y agoWhen I was working on a company that ALL people were in one same office - it sometimes made a difference as I could just stand up from my desk and go to a coworker that I needed to do/fix some stuff. When the same company started to grow - and had multiple offices across entire Poland - we started to communicate each other with IM/email/teleconferences/... This is the part when staying in the office was pointless as I/we needed to use IM/email/teleconferences/... anyway - so it does not matter if You do it from home or from the office. Many manager do not understand that. I work daily from home and I am not going back to office because of waste of my time (and money). If - for some reason - current employer would try to force me to get back - I am out of company in minutes and getting other job in more mature employer. My $0.02 on the topic.