3 ms·
there are, that's why insulin pump firmware is developed using obsolete and error-prone methods by substandard engineers and why you can't get the source for yo
by kragen 3y ago
there are, that's why insulin pump firmware is developed using obsolete and error-prone methods by substandard engineers and why you can't get the source for your insulin pump firmware and reflash it with a bug-fixed version
- chpatrick 3y agoI see where you're coming from, but I don't think letting anyone mess with the equipment keeping them alive is a good idea either. I really love open source IoT stuff for example and I think it's a great that people are trying to take real ownership of their devices. However it's different if the penalty for failure is your lights not working or immediate death. I think a better solution would be if the source was required to be public so people can identify bugs, but without giving users the ability to flash.
- noir_lord 3y ago> I think a better solution would be if the source was required to be public so people can identify bugs, but without giving users the ability to flash. That would be a solution, still has the problem of "how do you confirm the bug if you can't run the code". Finding those kinds of subtle bugs pretty much requires you be able to execute it.
- kragen 3y agoi do, because not 'letting anyone mess with the equipment keeping them alive' is, obviously, condemning some of them to deaths that they would avoid if they were allowed to i think you would need an overwhelmingly large number of prevented suicides and avoided foolish accidents to justify such a monstrous evil the balance of deaths is very likely to work out the other way around, in fact, because people reflashing their own insulin pumps have much stronger incentives to maximize their survival chances than any possible regulatory regime would, much less the one that actually exists the policy of 'let us make laws and set up regulatory agencies to prevent people from harming themselves' has such an astoundingly bad track record that it always surprises me to hear someone advocating it in apparent seriousness
- numpad0 3y agoRewriting firmware in Rust is not a solution when your beautiful piece of Rust is to be micromanaged using an Android app as the controller.
- kragen 3y agoi'm not sure if rust would help much for most bugs like this, though i guess it would have prevented the therac-25 deaths
- selimthegrim 3y agoI will say that my company did have an engineer that could write proper lock-free algorithms. Unfortunately, they were completely unable to retain him and he didn’t help matters.