3 ms·
Can we please stop this propaganda? "Stroads" are roads for all users, not just bike bros. And roads are absolutely beautiful, they allow people to move. As a
by cyberax 3y ago
Can we please stop this propaganda?
"Stroads" are roads for all users, not just bike bros. And roads are absolutely beautiful, they allow people to move. As a result, well-designed car-oriented American cities are _far_ more efficient than nicely-looking but horrible-to-live European cities.
If you want to use pejorative names, then I propose: "slumhive" ("slum beehive") for any high-rise building and "broads" ("bike bro roads") for bicycle lanes.
- alkonaut 3y agoStroads are bad for cars too (not just pedestrians and bicyclists). That's the argument against stroads. Roads are good and streets are good but stroads is the worse of both with the benefits of none.
- cyberax 3y agoNo. Roads with turn lanes are _flexible_, they allow fast arterial flow, with easy turns. This allows far more variation in design than just high-speed roads and slow local roads. Moreover, removing "stroads" does NOT reduce fatalities! Boston's accident rate went up from 16 vehicular deaths in 2016 (before they drank the KoolAid) to 26 this year. The attacks on surface roads by groups with an agenda (push people into dense cities) is predictable. They want traffic to become untenable, so they just lie and insinuate.
- Boltgolt 3y agoInteresting, so you don't think that separating different kinds of traffic (through traffic and local traffic) would inheritly also be better for car drivers?
- cyberax 3y agoThe whole thing with "stroads" is that they allow to seamlessly transition between these modes. You can't have the left turns on a regular road, so you either need multi-level interchanges (that take too much space), or you need to force drivers to make right turns and circle around. The latter _can_ be a solution for some roads, but it necessarily lengthens the trip and significantly increases its time because you have to make 3 right turns instead of one left turn.
- alkonaut 3y agoRoundabouts don’t take as much space as multi level intersections. It’s the best solutions in many cases.
- Skeime 3y agoYeah, and there are absolutely no people with an agenda to make cars a necessity. I mean, who would that be? It would need to be a huge industry that makes its profit from selling cars to people. I can’t think of any such industry. /s Sure, hyper-dense cities are not ideal, but neither are spread-out asphalt wastelands where cars are the only means of getting around. This is terrible for anyone who can’t drive (children, people with impaired vision, people who can’t afford cars). I have also lived in Houston (without a car) and I found getting around absolutely miserable. Even when I had friends pick me up with their cars, the distances were huge and a lot of the time, this would be because of parking lots creating gigantic empty space everywhere. (At least, this was my impression.)
- cyberax 3y ago> Sure, hyper-dense cities are not ideal, but neither are spread-out asphalt wastelands where cars are the only means of getting around. This is terrible for anyone who can’t drive This is the only rational argument against cars. I especially want children to have more autonomy. Yet it'll be far better solved by self-driving vehicles. They already exist, and they work.
- Skeime 3y agoThe only rational argument? Cars are also dangerous for their surroundings and their passengers. In addition, individual cars are an environmental disaster, in terms of noise, air pollution, climate, and use of natural resources. Finally, I believe (admittedly without having a source at hand) that not using a car is beneficial to one’s health because modern humans move their body way too little — biking or walking, even just to the next bus stop, are much better (but of course, this last part is ultimately a private decision).
- emodendroket 3y agoNone of the claims in the last paragraph are true. Self-driving vehicles still have serious limitations, especially in the city context we’re talking about, and children aren’t going to have their own cars.
- timwaagh 3y agoI don't know whether the design of American cities is efficient. They might be. and I do believe in roads for all users. That's why a bike lane is called a bike lane and not a bike road. Bike paths and 'bike superhighways' exist in my country but they're unimportant. But having been in the us only once it was very obvious the us has a problem with safety for drivers. There were cars at the side of the highway (Orlando to Tampa) everywhere, presumably from accidents. Of course traffic wasn't moving. I wasn't driving on holiday and I was glad about it. It's possibly to do with the fact that Americans all need to drive, ensuring lax standards for driver tests. Maybe if you guys would embrace bike lanes you could also embrace real driver certification. Just dump people who can't drive on second tier transportation like bikes, ebikes, escooters and trains and ensure everyone else gets proper training.
- palotasb 3y agoAs someone living in Amsterdam, Netherlands, I don't understand the resistance. I agree with the article and I think it is advocating for the right thing, so it's the right kind of propaganda. Maybe there is more common ground between you and Strong Towns than you'd think? They don't just advocate for "bike bros." Here everyone bikes from kids in elementary school to their grandparents. The key is having separate car infrastructure (roads, highways) and biking/pedestrian infrastructure (streets, bike lanes, pedestrian-only areas). The net effect is that many people here choose non-car transport (public transport, biking, walking), which reduces traffic. This also makes getting around by car more efficient, for destinations where you need to use a car, because there is less traffic. If you want to live in a single-family home in the suburbs and own a car, you can do that here too. It's fine because there are roads to get around the country. Not stroads though, so no need to worry about pedestrians or cyclists when you're on a road, so they allow moving faster. If you want to live in an apartment in the city without owning a car, you can do that here too. It's fine because there is public transport, proper bike lanes and streets to get around the city. Not straods though, so no need to worry about cars. I'd say it's both nicely looking and quite efficient. Not sure by what metric would an American city be more efficient, but generally I wouldn't want to trade places.
- cyberax 3y agoAs I said, I lived in Amsterdam. > Maybe there is more common ground between you and Strong Towns than you'd think? They don't just advocate for "bike bros." Yes, they do. They literally do. All their "solutions" just accidentally ALWAYS make traffic worse and push people into dense cities.
- JohnFen 3y ago> "Stroads" are roads for all users "Stroads" are roads for cars. They are terrible for everyone else.
- beej71 3y agoFrankly they're not even great for that. When was the last time you enjoyed traveling on a stroad by any means?
- cyberax 3y agoJust 15 minutes ago? I enjoyed not having to wait 15 minutes for a bus, and then do a transfer with another 10 minute wait. One way.
- 16bytes 3y agoThe question wasn't if you enjoyed driving vs. other modalities, it was "do you enjoy driving on a stroad?". Personally, I hate them. They're chaotic, prone to accidents, ugly and well, everything TFA talks about. Well built infrastructure makes it better for everybody.