3 ms·
Seems extremely unlikely. The phone isn’t going to make drastic alterations to reality. It’s just combining multiple exposures. It can’t make someone point a gu
by Aurornis 3y ago
Seems extremely unlikely. The phone isn’t going to make drastic alterations to reality. It’s just combining multiple exposures. It can’t make someone point a gun if they’re not pointing a gun. You could try to imagine a scenario where someone was moving extremely fast through the frame while someone was whipping a gun around at high speed in the same direction and the phone just happened to stitch two moments a fraction of a second apart such that they look slightly closer together, but to get to that point you’d still need someone pointing a gun in the same direction that someone is going.
It’s really hard to imagine a scenario where two exposures a fraction of a second apart could be stitched together to tell a completely false story, but maybe it exists. In that case, I suspect the lawyers would be all over this explanation to try to dismiss the evidence.
- tmalsburg2 3y agoIt’s unlikely, true. But precisely that makes it so dangerous. If such a picture is presented as evidence in a murder case, the possibility that it is telling the wrong story will be discounted and someone may go to prison for the rest of their lives.
- adastra22 3y agoWhat the comment you're replying to is saying could absolutely have happened. Imagine a "Han shot first" sort of situation: two people with guns, one shoots the other. The shooter claims it was self-defense, as the other guy went to fire first but was just slower. An iPhone picture captures the moment, but has the shooter firing, and the other guy's gun still at his side. This is perfectly analogous to TFA--notice that the woman has enough time to move her arms into very different positions in the same composited moment.
- 0cVlTeIATBs 3y agoWell, the Rittenhouse case had a very important moment when the victim admitted that, while looking at a freeze-frame view of a video taken when he was shot, he had raised his pistol which was pointed at Rittenhouse only a fraction of a second before. [0] That photo was critical for the defense getting him to say that. There were also concerns over wether or not zooming in on an iPad should be allowed in that case--like if a red pixel next to a blue could create a purple one, etc. [0] https://www.denverpost.com/2021/11/08/shooting-victim-says-he-was-pointing-his-gun-at-rittenhouse/ https://www.denverpost.com/2021/11/08/shooting-victim-says-h...