4 ms·
I don't agree that surface syntax doesn't matter unless it affects language functionality. Syntax is UI for programming languages, and UI for programming langua
by pcwalton 15y ago
I don't agree that surface syntax doesn't matter unless it affects language functionality. Syntax is UI for programming languages, and UI for programming languages matters as surely as UI for other software matters. Fortunes have been won and lost on UI.
To me, the problem is that there is no answer to programming language syntax that pleases everybody. There are general aesthetic principles to follow, but the fundamental questions - semicolons vs. newlines, indentation vs. braces, short vs. long keywords - generate a lot more heat than light. We have to pick one and disappoint somebody.
Note that even in this thread, there is disagreement about whether JavaScript is too terse or too verbose!