2 ms·
> Lerdahl's criticism of serialism is also convincing, i.e. the abstract structure of music does not translate to the heard structure of music. There are ways
by zozbot234 3y ago
> Lerdahl's criticism of serialism is also convincing, i.e. the abstract structure of music does not translate to the heard structure of music.
There are ways to address this however. One can add small-scale atonal elements to an otherwise tonal work, in a way that can be understood by the ear. I think this may account for why Webern is perhaps the most popular among the atonal and serial composers: his works are small-scale enough that one can at least think about what grokking them musically may be like. Same for the 'freely atonal' works of early Schoenberg. So it was nowhere near the total failure some people might think it was, just not the be-all and end-all.