7 ms·
Let's Not Flip Sides on IP Maximalism Because of AI
- Barrin92 3y agoDon't understand this discussion at all. There's no need to flip your position due to AI. Any produced work may or may not infringe copyright. If you produce a work that lifts say, characters or expressions straight out of a story you're likely violating copyright. If you used AI tools to produce that same work it still does. It's irrelevant how you technically produced the work, by pen, typewriter or chatbot api. Asking if training a model violates copyright is unintelligible because 100 GB of weights don't resemble any work unless you produce and publish inferences from it.
- infotainment 3y ago> Asking if training a model violates copyright is unintelligible because 100 GB of weights don't resemble any work unless you produce and publish inferences from it. I agree, but there are many who don’t, and assert that any training use should be banned. Those people are the ones who the article is talking about: people who suddenly became copyright maximalists due to their desire to halt AI training.
- pixel8account 3y agoI don't want to halt AI training, I want corporations to fuck off from using my (A)GPL code to train their proprietary models which they then sell to people writing more proprietary code. I would be ok if the derived code is properly GPL licenced too. I suspect many people feel in a similar way too (for example, artists whose art is used to train image generators without compensation).
- jwestbury 3y agoWhat about people reading your code and learning from it before implementing their own code? What's the similarity level where that becomes a problem for you, if their code is closed-source or uses a license you disagree with?
- Y-bar 3y agoPutting aside the fact that what we call AI today is not learning in the same way as humans. They operate on a VASTLY different scale compared to humans. On a good week I can read a book. A single book. A massively parallelised data centre can do that billions or trillions of times faster. Scale of effect (lacking a better phrase) must be considered. a rack of equipment does not need to sleep, eat, take care of themselves, earn a living and so on while churning through millions of words a minute. An actual thinking and learning person has to choose what to spend their limited time and money and attention on, while reading at a pace of dozens of words a minute. Those are not the same things at all.
- TheOtherHobbes 3y agoMore than that, AI-generated work is clearly derivative for the simple obvious reason that none of it would exist without the original sources.
- infotainment 3y agoI mean, by that logic every fantasy story ever is a derivative work. Should everyone be paying JRR Tolkein's estate royalties the moment they include elves in a story?
- dragonwriter 3y agoThat's... not the legal definition of a derivative work.
- safety1st 3y agoI agree with this, but is this something that should be dealt with in the law or in the license? My gut feeling is that the just remedy is A) the GenAI models out there should get to do what they want as long as they are not violating licenses, B) the libre software world needs to hustle and release new versions of the appropriate licenses that specifically forbid use of the source code to train AI unless the AI itself is licensed permissively. Note that in regards to A) I'm pretty sure the AI firms ARE violating copyright today, they have done this knowingly, and they should get a hard slap for that. But they are not violating any particular copyleft licensing provisions to my knowledge
- CaptainFever 3y ago> I'm pretty sure the AI firms ARE violating copyright today, they have done this knowingly, and they should get a hard slap for that. Depends on the jurisdiction. Do note that many countries already passed laws indicating that training is NOT copyright infringement. The EU[1], for example. In which case, no license would matter. https://www.reedsmith.com/en/perspectives/ai-in-entertainment-and-media/2023/06/text-and-data-mining-around-the-globe https://www.reedsmith.com/en/perspectives/ai-in-entertainmen... [1] Yes, in the EU, you can opt-out (but only for commercial purposes). In other countries such as Singapore however, there are no legal mechanisms for opting out.
- CaptainFever 3y ago> I suspect many people feel in a similar way too (for example, artists whose art is used to train image generators without compensation). Just to be a counter-voice, I don't. My code is AGPL too, but since the number of copy"righted" things outnumber the number of AGPL things, I'd rather anybody have the ability to train their own AI on all material. Conversely, if it was considered a derivative, only large corporations like Adobe or Microsoft would be able to train on it (e.g. they can just give themselves a license to do so via the ToS). In other words, it's probably a bad idea to strengthen copyright law for the purpose of enforcing copyleft, due to possibilities of it backfiring on us.
- rjmunro 3y agoI'm not sure it's always true to say "100 GB of weights don't resemble any work". If I train a model on a famous poem or something, and it turns out if you ask the model to quote the poem verbatim, it can, then the model contains the poem. Have I not "copied" the poem into the model?
- visarga 3y agoYou can simply copy the poem in much less space if that's what you want, but incidental replication is not the same with copying. When you train a model, you use 1T...20T tokens, with deduplication to reduce direct memorization. Then the model is a superposition of gradients from trillions of tokens, no longer just a copy of a poem, it could also write a commentary about it or compose new ones. GPT4 summarizes this in a haiku: "Superposition bright, Gradients blend in the night, New poems take flight."
- philipwhiuk 3y ago> GPT4 summarizes this in a haiku: This has never added any value to a comment. Stop doing it.
- ajnin 3y ago> 100 GB of weights don't resemble any work I don't think that argument has a lot of weight. By the same logic a zip file of a book doesn't resemble the original work if you look at the raw bytes but you can extract it and get it back. It would be hard to argue that the copyright violation happens only when you extract the zip, and not, say, if you distribute the archive.
- panta 3y agoLLM could even be seen as a form of lossy compression after all
- datadrivenangel 3y agoA sufficiently overfit model is indistinguishable from bad compression.
- Barrin92 3y agoThe same logic doesn't apply because you can't get the data back out of the model by unpacking it. It's theoretically not possible because the model is magnitudes smaller than the totality of the data. To use, and invert the example from the other commenter, you can even get an existing poem out of a generative model that genuinely was not in the training data at all. This is because it's not an archive, which does correspond directly to one particular work, but a generative technology.
- danaris 3y agoIf I create an original file in Photoshop that's 8K, then produce a JPG of it, the JPG is both orders of magnitude smaller, and clearly a rendition of the same work. There's no way to get back to the original 587MB 8K PSD from the 87KB 1024x768 JPG, but that's irrelevant to whether the latter is a version of the former. Just because the models are not perceptually the same as their training data does not mean that they are not effectively a lossy compression of that data.
- Marazan 3y ago
- some_random 3y agoThe binary structure of an mp4 file of a copyrighted movie also doesn't resemble any work, until you interpret it in a specific way.
- Y-bar 3y agoSomeone tried that with MP3's a while ago, as expected they lost: https://arstechnica.com/tech-policy/2009/11/about-those-beatles-songs-its-weirder-than-you-thought/ https://arstechnica.com/tech-policy/2009/11/about-those-beat... > So defiant, in fact, that MRT had actually registered for copyright protection on the songs it was selling. "To make matters worse," says EMI's complaint, "Defendants recently sought to register their infringing sound recordings with the Copyright Office, apparently claiming that because they copied the sound recordings using their own computer system, they now own these digital copies and have the right to distribute them to the public."
- fzzzy 3y agoCopyright exists only on complete works and not characters; however any ai produced materials which use trademarked characters would violate trademark. It's just that ai cannot violate copyright unless it produces an identical copy of an existing work.
- wharvle 3y agoCharacters can definitely enjoy copyright protection, distinct from trademark protection. At least in the US.
- hn_acker 3y agoRegarding copyright on characters in the United States [1]: > US Copyright Statute of 1976 does not explicitly mention fictional characters as subject matter of copyright, and their copyrightability is a product of common law. Historically, the Courts granted copyright protection to characters as parts of larger protected work and not as independent creations. They were regarded as ‘components in a copyrighted works’ and eligible for protection as thus.[5] But in practice, if you write a fanfiction story which uses Mickey Mouse as a character and get sued by Disney for copyright infringement, you will not win in court regardless of how different your fanfiction story is from any Disney story unless you can afford as many lawyers of comparable quality as Disney can. And even then, who knows? [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Copyright_protection_for_fictional_characters#United_States https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Copyright_protection_for_ficti...
- TheOtherHobbes 3y agoExamples of crude MJ plagiarism. https://twitter.com/kortizart/status/1588915427018559490/photo/1 https://twitter.com/kortizart/status/1588915427018559490/pho...
- kristopolous 3y agoI really don't see this as fundamentally different from digital sampling equipment for music that became popular in the 1980s. Some new technology comes along that repurposes things created by others that allows people to use it as the implements of a new form of art. The digital sampler was used as a musical instrument in its own right - with high variations, skill, and taste applied to the arrangements of other people's copyrighted sounds. There's a wide variety of opinion on digital sampling and it's really the same thing here. I'd be surprised if a particular person's views on the two are in conflict.
- irishloop 3y agoYes but aren't artists now compensated for their art being used in sampling? At least when it makes a profit? I haven't heard of anyone being compensated for their works making profit for OpenAI
- Kiro 3y agoI was curious and checked how much the drummer behind Amen Break has made, undoubtedly one of the most sampled things in the world. The answer was nothing.
- kristopolous 3y agoIt depends. A lot of times it's just a new, say UMG song that samples another UMG song so it's just Hollywood accounting with cross charging. When say Madonna sampled the Beegees, I'm sure it was a large ordeal. But for low profit or no profit work (independent stuff), the answer is nobody cares. Bob James, one of the most sampled artists in history, take it in stride. He's happy that so many people are listening to his stuff. The Winston's (the famous amen break) were also happy the track got such wide acceptance. Killing Joke, on the other hand, felt "Come as you are" was a rip off of "Eighties" and only dropped it upon the death of Kurt Cobain. Or take Toni Basil's Mickey, which is actually a cover song of Racey's Kitty. Toni Basil has gone to court to secure pretty exclusive rights to the song. Racey does not get any of Toni's cash. So it varies and it's messy.
- 3y ago
- Riverheart 3y agoTLDR Compares “using a computer” to “using an AI” as if they’re the same. Makes AI companies out to be the victim of AI doomers without offering any kind of solution to the people using copyright as a tool to protect their livelihoods. People are not IP maximalists on principle I’d have to guess but if it’s the best available means to safeguard their work from being leveraged against them they will use the means they have. Until that issue is addressed articles like this fall on deaf ears.
- hn_acker 3y ago> Compares “using a computer” to “using an AI” as if they’re the same. No, the article expresses the relationship "using an AI to do X" is a subset of the main set "using a computer to do X", but demonstrates that affecting the subset without affecting other elements of the main set is hard in the context of statutory law. > Makes AI companies out to be the victim of AI doomers The article does not refer to the AI companies as victims, and doesn't focus on the impact to AI companies in particular. The article's argument is a slippery slope: how do you write a law which restricts "using an AI to do X" without restricting other forms of computer tasks? What I have in mind are scraping, downloading (like youtube-dl), parsing, recoloring (can be accessibility-related), and otherwise interpreting (broad umbrella, but I'm thinking along the lines of OCR). > Makes AI companies out to be the victim of AI doomers without offering any kind of solution to the people using copyright as a tool to protect their livelihoods. People are not IP maximalists on principle I’d have to guess but if it’s the best available means to safeguard their work from being leveraged against them they will use the means they have. Until that issue is addressed articles like this fall on deaf ears. While it would be nice if the author of the article had a different proposed solution in mind, pointing out flaws in the solution "treat AI models as copyright infringement" is an important task. Moreover, keep in mind that the status quo is an option, and sometimes better than a change (especially when the First Amendment is involved). Will the AI regulation you have in mind would be worth it, and (separate question) will your proposed solution be better in comparison to the trend of the status quo?
- boredumb 3y agoAndy Warhol is turning in his grave. Jokes aside the recent supreme court case involving his estate, as a non lawyer, feels like it's some sort of precedent towards what is and isn't transformation of IP.
- bayindirh 3y agoThis is just a hit piece which tries to frame scraping whole internet as-is as fair-use, because it's profitable for the AI companies, that's all. There are things on the internet which can be shared freely, but not allowed to be altered. Similarly there are things which are for your eyes only (source-available licensed software, for example), and not to be built-upon. AI companies bundle all of them, say that their models are learning like a human, and this is fair use and training data is non-reproducible. Then someone shows that their code, work, poem, whatever can be emitted as-is, damaging them; same companies act surprised, and a couple of censor filters, and go on. This is not fair use.
- davexunit 3y agoYeah, it's just copyright laundering. If this is deemed legal, then it's fair to return the favor by doing things like training models on proprietary source code to build free software. Effectively killing copyright would be the best possible outcome.
- Spivak 3y agoBut it isn't. If the AI produces a work found to be a copyright violation it isn't magically not just because it was made by AI. This nonsense has laid bare for the world just how little people actually understand copyright. The only interesting question is whether the models themselves violate copyright and it's a tough sell without being able to actually show the copy. Because even if it's able to make something similar to your work it doesn't show the model actually contains a copy of it. If you coax a model to make an image that violates copyright it's gonna be hard to say that it's anything other than you using an advanced drawing tool to copy an image.
- bayindirh 3y agoLet's imagine an hypothetical LLM, which has been trained on books, published by publishers (companies). Thousands, thousands of book which are not out of their copyright terms, without telling to their authors. All of the things emitted by this LLM will be a remix of these books. Will the outputs of this LLM be a violation of copyright? I bet it will be. Let's train the same AI, on self-published, but again copyrighted material. Will the outputs of this LLM be a violation of copyright? I bet it should be. but, in reality, in discourse, we see that if it's company IP, then ordinary people are doing it wrong because it's copyright violation, and if it's people's IP, then ordinary people are doing it wrong, because it's fair use. Copyrighting things are not a privilege given to corporations. If it's fair use, I can train a voice model with Freddie Mercury's voice, and make him a vocal of my garage band, but RIAA will end my life, but if a company samples my sound and reproduces for a video without my consent, it'll be fair use because I don't have 1000 lawyers. This is what bothers me.
- dun44 3y agoOr perhaps it’s time to reconsider whether the whole idea of “IP ownership” still makes sense. It was introduced because it was, on the whole, beneficial to society. Now that AI can make producing content much cheaper, do we still need that incentive?
- dasil003 3y agoDo we want AI to be the only economical way for “content” to be created in the future? And for the corporate owners of AI to be the middle men on all creativity? I’m no great fan of the current IP regime, but the economics of building, maintaining and operating LLMs have the potential to completely gut human creativity and replace it with a mechanical ouroboros eating its own tale.
- thaumasiotes 3y ago> It was introduced because it was, on the whole, beneficial to society. How do you know? It was introduced; people have mostly not made the argument that it was beneficial to society. You could argue that the fact that it was introduced shows that it was beneficial to society, but that theory has problems with laws that are repealed. Prohibition was introduced for the same reason, that it was beneficial to society. And it was repealed because that was beneficial to society too. Is that... true?
- man4 3y ago[flagged]
- chilmers 3y agoYeah it's surprising to me how many people who were previously skeptical of IP laws in general, are all on board to use them to attack AI companies, advocating that a copyright holder should have the right to control exactly how their work can be used by any downstream system. The nightmare scenario I see is, if this principle is established for AIs, it will not just be restricted to AIs. Human artists too will eventually be required to only create new commercial works under license, based on the artistic works they have been exposed to. The result will that it be impossible to be create art commercially except by working for a large content company with a large existing IP library and cross-licensing agreements with other rights holders. And if you think this is an impossible scenario, ask yourself when lawyers, lobbyists and politicians have ever shrank from expanding legal rights for corporations at the expense of individuals, even when the vast majority of people would not agree to the expansion. Today's absurdity is tomorrow's legal reality, and the chance to fully control creative expression will be far too tempting to turn down.
- danaris 3y ago[flagged]
- MightyBuzzard 3y agoAI is not reproducing it any more than someone inspired by it creating something new in the same style would be. They're just greedy ass hats.
- danaris 3y ago"Regular people writing and creating artwork are greedy asshats for wanting it to remain possible to be compensated for their creations" is really not a strong argument, especially against "massive, wealthy companies want to be able to create works that mimic the style of these artists and writers for profit with zero marginal cost in perpetuity".
- MightyBuzzard 3y ago
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- Am4TIfIsER0ppos 3y agoI'm going to take the side of the IP argument based on whatever hurts big business most. If they want to "steal" from the little guy by locking everything up behind copyright (or patents or trademarks) then I will oppose it. If they want to "steal" from the little guy by ingesting his works into the AI machine then I will oppose it. Notice how governments and companies became "worried" about AI when people were starting to emulate certain styles in the images generated. Suddenly they needed to be regulated and censored (even harder).
- coldblues 3y agoGood take. Big companies should suffer so that the regular person can strive and compete. It is clear that big AI companies virtue signal so that they can exploit regulations and become monopolies. In the end the only thing enforcing these laws is government that can only enforce through punishment and ultimately violence, and you can fend that with enough money. AI training will continue to be done illegally and in the gray by both regular parties and those that can pay for the privilege. Most of the artists I follow draw styles and subjects that can't easily be replicated using AI. Anyone with a refined enough taste should not feel threatened or relieved. The continued technological progress serves those who adapt. What you should fear is surveillance tech.
- weeblewobble 3y agoGenerative AI is almost always a service problem. If a model can offer customized art instantly 24/7 for free but the artist says you have to wait 3 months and it’ll cost 500 dollars and I only accept PayPal, then the model’s service is more valuable.