6 ms·
Edmunds EV Charging Test: How fast does each EV charge?
- djoldman 3y agoThis is interesting although ostensibly charge speed matters only when driving past the full charge range as presumably most consumers charge overnight.
- ghaff 3y agoPresumably most consumers charge overnight on a day to day basis (because otherwise buying an EV probably doesn't make a lot of sense). But charging matters a lot on longer trips.
- neals 3y agoMany people simply cannot charge over night. Many reasons for this. For example :living in an apartment building with no private parking and no charging.
- Ographer 3y agoTrue, max charging speed is mostly theoretical and probably not experienced by most owners regularly. Until all of the car companies switched to the same plug, you need to look at the distribution and availability of fast chargers compatible with each car. Even though some of these cars have charge speeds much higher than Tesla, it seems to be pretty difficult to actually find a compatible fast charger that is also working. In all the reviews I've watched of new non-tesla road trips, everyone has awful charging experiences where they are stuck waiting at slow chargers.
- pornel 3y agoI think that's an underappreciated statistic. Everyone's worried about the range, but the reality is that the range doesn't matter at all in city driving, and OTOH no BEV will have range long enough for a serious road trip, and it will have to recharge multiple times. And then the difference is whether the charging stops will be quick coffee breaks, or add frustrating hours to the trip time. Here's another data source of 1000km trips in various BEVs with charging time: https://docs.google.com/spreadsheets/d/1V6ucyFGKWuSQzvI8lMzvvWJHrBS82echMVJH37kwgjE/edit#gid=15442336 https://docs.google.com/spreadsheets/d/1V6ucyFGKWuSQzvI8lMzv... - With a fast-charging EV, a 1000km trip can be only half an hour slower than a cannonball run in an ICE car, or can be 5 hours slower in a Nissan Leaf, or 3 hours slower in a Toyota bz4x.
- tlofreso 3y agoBjorn is the GOAT for EV testing
- code_runner 3y agoIn a few 7 or so hour drives in our ev, charging stops added probably an hour total. For how we drive it actually wasn’t bad at all and the chargers were (almost) all in nice spots where we could grab a coffee and use the restroom. I wish I could squeeze a bit more range out at interstate cruising speed though.
- ewams 3y agoHas anyone done the math for how much "coffee" EV drivers consume vs ICE drivers? Wonder what the extra costs are for EV drivers while waiting for a charge.
- code_runner 3y agohaha I'd be surprised if I'm drinking more coffee than usual during those drives.... but any road trip I am definitely consuming more snacks and candy due to very poor self control.
- Retric 3y agoLong range EV’s are already at 5+ hours of driving at highway speeds, adding a single 60% charge (20% to 80%) and your talking well over 8 hours or ~1,000km which is longer than what most people do in a single day. As such battery capacity is a huge deal on road trips assuming you can charge to full overnight and don’t excessively speed.
- harshaw 3y agoNot sure I have a long range EV with the Ioniq 5. But in the winter with precoditioning I basically only get 2 1/2 hours. You can't run the battery to 0, precoditioning sucks up a ton of energy, and you need to get to a fast charger.
- samch 3y agoI probably need to look at their methodology, but my Model 3 hit 1017mi/hr at a 250kW station this month. With Tesla, on a long trip, the battery will pre-condition itself (heating I believe) to allow for faster charging rates. To be fair the number I quoted above, was with a single-digital SOC and a pre-conditioned system. Nevertheless, my real world experience is nearly 2x what Edmunds is reporting.
- cs702 3y agoI routinely take road trips on two long-range Teslas, and that's my experience as well: 1000+ miles/hour when the battery is preconditioned and has less than 20-25% left. The beautiful thing is that, when I'm driving, anytime I tap the supercharger button on the screen and click on a nearby supercharger, the car will precondition the battery on its own for maximum charging efficiency. I don't have to do anything! for road trips, I just type or say a destination and the car figures out if, when, and where it should charge to minimize travel time, and it automagically preconditions the battery on its own. My usual experience is that I arrive, go to the bathroom, grab a drink and a snack, come back to the car, and voilà, it's added 120-180 miles of range.
- LeafItAlone 3y agoIsn’t that true only if 1. You plug the Supercharger into the navigation system, so it knows it’s going to one? If you just hit up a convenient stop, it won’t. 2. Your trip to the Supercharger is long enough for it to matter. If it’s nearby, the preconditioning doesn’t seem to get it warm enough by the time you get there. At least that was my experience in a rental.
- cs702 3y agoYes. I was editing my comment to say the same as you were writing your response! In practice, I just type or say destinations and let the car figure out if, when, and where to supercharge.
- DeRock 3y agoIs that the “peak” rate? Or your average rate? The article is about the latter. Additionally, it uses the actual measured average efficiency of driving for calculating miles, not what the car itself reports (teslas tend to be far too optimistic here)
- tlofreso 3y agoI love the effort Ford is putting into their EV offerings, and Farley seems to get it better than the other legacy auto CEOs. Ford leveraged their two most powerful brands (F-150 / Mustang) to enter the EV market. I contrast this to GM's resurgence to the space with hummer... A brand they discontinued after a tumultuous 2008. That said, Ford aligning on 150kW chargers across their EV portfolio is a miss. I really hope 250kW is road mapped for next gen Ford EVs when they adopt NACS.
- seltzered_ 3y agoTheir vehicle architecture & derating setup only seems to max out at 150 kW so far? I've been researching the ford mustang mach-e and the NCM li-ion batteries max out around 115kW charging and the newer LFP ones max out at 150 kW. Expect the next gen to be different though. At least in the earlier models there's supposedly less temperature sensing to figure out a higher speed compared to say Tesla.
- brightball 3y agoThis test is probably the most critical for everyday users IMO. The next wave of Graphene batteries are supposed to be able to charge significantly faster while handling the heat that goes along with it. There’s a company in Australia working with Bosch that I’ve been watching for a couple of years for this reason. I believe they are projecting 2025.
- donkeyd 3y agoWhere does the huge difference in charging losses come from? Tesla, for example, is 10x lower than most of the cars at the top.
- galangalalgol 3y agoI think they tested without preconditioning the battery. Teslas integrated nav and charging network are both designed to make that not happen on a road trip. Also, those at the top of the list are 800v instead of 400v. Which means you need to find a 800v charger, which is a whole other aspect of the issue. Lastly we don't know to what degree any of these cars are protecting battery longevity.
- donkeyd 3y ago> I think they tested without preconditioning the battery This sounds feasible, I didn't think of that one!
- xeromal 3y agoAerodynamics mostly if you're talking about the Kw/h per 100 miles column
- asylteltine 3y agoProbably because Tesla lies about their stats like actual range
- harshaw 3y agoFast charging is important. However, getting the most out of a level 2 charger is also important. My Ioniq 5 can't pull more than 6.5kw because of faulty hardware in the vehicle (I think the inverter over heats and the circuitry shuts off, or with more recent firmware will rate limit the power). You should be able to pull 9.6kw (I think) with a 40A circuit - so Hyundai's hardware problem leaves a lot of juice on the table. And that matters if you want to charge with a level 2 while when you are traveling.
- cogman10 3y agoThis is a bad chart that really tells you nothing. Could you imagine, for example, measuring how fast you can fill up a car in miles/hour? It's a nonsense measure. A better measure is the 0 to 80% time with a 350kW charger. That'll actually tell you how long you can expect to wait at a charger. But that's also not as flashy a number as "1000 miles per hour charging!"
- fuzzy2 3y ago> measuring how fast you can fill up a car in miles/hour But that’s exactly what my EV’s app shows. (-:
- robertlagrant 3y ago> A better measure is the 0 to 80% time with a 350kW charger. That'll actually tell you how long you can expect to wait at a charger. But that's also not as flashy a number as "1000 miles per hour charging!" No it's not, because different cars have different capacities. This measure standardises that.
- Ographer 3y agoYeah, these are theoretical lab tests. Good luck actually finding a series of working, available fast chargers on a real road trip anywhere. I really want an Ioniq5 but I'll wait until they switch to the Tesla style plugs because the support is currently not there.
- bluGill 3y agoIt also isn't a number I can use to compare cars. Each car will have a different battery. A car with a large battery may fill much faster if you give it a 800kw charger, but since the charger is the limit it takes a while - but in the amount of time it takes to charge a car with a small battery the large battery car would take more charge and get farther. Or something else. Once I've selected a car I'm interested in the 20-80% charge time (that seems to be the recommended fill levels), but until then I'm comparing cars with different batteries and I need something use to compare and 0-80% at 350kW time is not that.
- tetromino_ 3y ago
- cosgrove 3y agoKnowing starting battery temperature would go a long way to interpreting the results here. You could assume they all started the same, but it would be nice to know for sure. Nowhere do they describe initial starting conditions for the batteries / vehicles besides saying 10% SOC at start.
- fuzzy2 3y agoToo bad they only have these high-spec cars. Many small and/or cheaper EVs barely support more than 100 KW charging.
- cs702 3y agoIt appears they purposefully did not precondition any of the batteries. In fact, they don't even mention preconditioning. Why not? On top of that, it appears that they conducted the tests using only CCS adapters, which in the US are now being dumped by every manufacturer in favor of NACS adapters, i.e., what Tesla uses. NACS isn't even mentioned. Why not? I routinely take road trips on two long-range Teslas, and typically 1000+ miles/hour when the battery is preconditioned and has no more than 20-25% left. In practice, I just type or say a destination and the car figures out if, when, and where it should charge to minimize travel time, automatically preconditioning the battery on its own. My usual experience is that I arrive, go to the bathroom, grab a drink and/or a snack, come back to the car, and voilà, the car has added 120-180 miles of range. EDITS: Added comment about NACS.
- jefftk 3y ago> They purposefully did not precondition any of the batteries. Where are you seeing that? It looks like they use P3 for the testing, and while I'd like it if P3 was clearer about their testing approach it sounds to me like they do precondition? https://www.p3-group.com/en/p3-charging-index-comparison-of-the-fast-charging-capability-of-various-electric-vehicles-from-a-users-perspective_07-22/ https://www.p3-group.com/en/p3-charging-index-comparison-of-...
- pbjtime 3y ago1000+ mph? Must be a Tesla plaid.
- _ea1k 3y agoThe Model 3 can do that, and the Model Y as well on some occasions... but the catch is that it is 1000 rated miles. Real world mileage is much lower.
- bryanlarsen 3y agoThey can do their rated mileage -- if you don't mind driving 55.
- aeyes 3y agoUnfortunately they didn't publish the testing conditions. This might not match your own experience with any of these cars, charging speed depends on battery temperature.
- bluGill 3y agoEdmunds is mostly in California and so while they do real world testing, it is real world for where their editors live. (they need everyone to do long term testing and report how it really did as they drive in the real world). The above is all as I can figure out from reading articles. Their about page doesn't actually state any of that. As such I might be wrong.
- natch 3y agoThis kind of obsessing is kind of incongruous with reality given the fact that there is already one known clear leader in terms of massive, growing, and healthy charger network and overall real world charging speed. If there is a winner already not only in terms of charger network and speed, but also in terms of the best features, many enabled by for example network connectivity, cameras, an onboard beast of a computer, and a great software ecosystem with feature filled updates.. why even dive into one admittedly important aspect of the also-ran cars? The only reason this information would be helpful is if someone for some reason was walled off from buying the one brand of car that is far and away beyond the others in most aspects.
- floatrock 3y agoThis is neat and all, but in my experience in the northeast, the bottleneck isn't the car, it's the fast charger itself. I've done EA, EvGo, and sometimes ChargePoint with one of the cars in the upper half of this list. I never see the 250 or 350kW fast chargers go above 120-160. The bottleneck isn't the car, it's the charger network. I'd like to see them test the various networks at different times of day with different occupancy rates and tell people what they would really expect.
- pornel 3y agoFor eGMP cars the temperature makes a lot of difference. I regularly hit the advertised 18 minutes/230kW charging when it’s >20C outside, but in colder weather it’s stuck at 80kW until it the battery heats up.
- Roark66 3y agoThis is a nice chart, but what we need with EVs is modularity of the batteries. Imagine you're buying a 100kWh battery equipped EV when it's 15 year's old and the battery has 20% of its capacity, but it still weights the same as it was new. The rest of the car except few cosmetic issues is in great shape. If the battery consisted of 10 modules 10kWh each, you could sell for scrap all 10, add some money and buy let's say two new packs for a total of 20kWh (because you can't afford more now and you need a car for a 20 mile commute only). Your car becomes a lot lighter, you have an option to add capacity gradually, but even more importantly all the raw materials from the old battery that had only 20% of its capacity can now be recycled into 10 new 10kWh batteries. If we are serious about moving to electric cars for environmental reasons we have to look beyond co2 and this could be one of very good first steps.