3 ms·
Do you also object if they do Google searches? The reviewer certainly shouldn't depend on the results in either case. But it certainly seems reasonable to refe
by ghaff 3y ago
Do you also object if they do Google searches?
The reviewer certainly shouldn't depend on the results in either case. But it certainly seems reasonable to refer to references that aren't solely in their head.
- sudosysgen 3y agoKnowing which Google search to do is valuable expertise that goes beyond copying a submission into ChatGPT.
- jerf 3y agoThat clearly has nothing to do with what I said, and the accusation is not that the reviewer "referred" to an AI. And for the same reasons I laid out, if a reviewer thinks they need to "refer" to an AI, they should just tell the editor they're not qualified. The editor does not need a reviewer to serve as a middleman between them and a GPT. The reviewer is adding no value at that point; the editor can already "refer" to an AI themselves if they want to.