3 ms·
> Windows-as-an-App Is Coming To do what ? Running on bare hardware is a challenge for Windows.
by hulitu 3y ago
> Windows-as-an-App Is Coming
To do what ? Running on bare hardware is a challenge for Windows.
- doubled112 3y agoWindows on bare metal to run Edge to run Windows-as-an-app Sounds simple to me /s Think of all of the telemetry data possible this way!
- smoldesu 3y ago> To do what ? Is it not obvious? It's the same purpose as XCode Cloud and Ubuntu Pro and Office 365; force users to pay recurring fees for basic functionality. This is what service-ification of completely normal software looks like, our penance for not caring enough as consumers.
- dingnuts 3y agoThe "basic functionality" that an OS provides requires constant maintenance from the vendor. You're welcome to use Windows XP if you want, and then you can enjoy not having new device drivers for modern hardware or patches to protect against new attack vectors. Or is Microsoft supposed to patch security vulnerabilities forever, after your one time purchase? I don't like subscriptions for everything but don't act as though an OS, which must receive continuous updates -- continuous labor from the vendor -- in order to remain secure and thus be usable as an Internet appliance, which is its primary purpose today, is not already a subscription service even if it is not priced as one.
- smoldesu 3y agoConstant maintenance does not entail running an OS on their servers and RDPing into it. I have a capable machine, I can service it myself. If Microsoft wants to EOL OSes after a one-time purchase, that is their prerogative. There is a distinct difference in expectation between subscription OSes and LTS releases, though. That's why Microsoft can value a Windows license at hundreds of dollars. OS vendors have a continued interest in supporting my hardware so they can exploit me as a customer. If Microsoft makes too hasty of a move, they know they'll just push their users onto competing platforms that don't charge for 5+ years of support. Stuff like MacOS, ChromeOS or even Linux.
- tester756 3y ago>Running on bare hardware is a challenge for Windows. What do you mean?
- trealira 3y agoI don't know exactly what the OP was trying to say, but in my experience, Windows runs noticeably slowly and is sluggish compared to Linux on the same hardware. I have a Skylake CPU and 16GB of RAM, too; it's not just a crappy netbook. I dual boot my laptop with Windows 11 and Linux with GNOME. In Windows, just opening the Settings app takes a few seconds: 1 for the window to actually open, and the rest of the time loading the actual UI (since at first it's just a blank window). Opening applications takes longer. I can open fewer tabs in the web browser before the machine starts to lag. Reading and writing files is slower. (I recall reading that NT made different tradeoffs compared to Linux regarding file I/O and starting processes that made them slower, but the benefits to the tradeoffs they made aren't apparent to me in my usage.) Running Linux with GNOME (typically said to be bloated compared to other DEs or standalone WMs) is much snappier in all these cases.
- nashashmi 3y agoI was just thinking about this the other day. If I had to build a new OS built on top of a web interface that controlled an operating system, installed programs, opened files with set programs, shared between programs, and made it all cloud based, what would it look like? How could I do that? The front would have a set number of UI concepts, theme, interface commands and controls. The back would have data that would appear in the form of drop downs, item list, buttons, images, colors, etc (i think that covers everything). And then a special renderer would be paired with the interface. This renderer would depict (a VNC?) things like the layout of a webpage (... by firefox?), the structure of a cad drawing, the photoshopping of a 1 GB image, the 10,000 messages in your inbox, all based on the data obtained from the web. I am not too familiar with GPU stuff so I don't know how much the renderer can partially leverage a local GPU versus a cloud GPU.