6 ms·
I think you are too optimistic. While we can do everything you state, I don't think there is enough demand. Most people don't want to be a pilot these days,
by bluGill 3y ago
I think you are too optimistic. While we can do everything you state, I don't think there is enough demand. Most people don't want to be a pilot these days, the exceptions are not enough to support all the R&D needed to get there. Likewise, the other niches where people use airplanes for short flights are not large enough to support the R&D needed to get there. So small flights will be stuck with 1960s airplanes they keep rebuilding, with a few small manufactures doing small refinements on designs that are decades old, as a major redesign is just too expensive. Once in a while some rich person will finance a new airplane, but it will always be a money losing investment and so only flying enthusiasts will spend that money.
- civilitty 3y agoAgreed, GP is way too optimistic. Airplane manufacturing peaked in the late 1970s with over 18,000 planes manufactured a year. These days the numbers are under 3,000 planes a year! Switching to a new power source isn't going to change the fundamental economics of airplane manufacturing. There just isn't enough demand to reach any kind of scale and it's not the gas prices - manufacturing collapsed to its lowest point in the early 1990s before gas prices went out of control.
- tivert 3y ago> I think you are too optimistic. While we can do everything you state, I don't think there is enough demand. Most people don't want to be a pilot these days, the exceptions are not enough to support all the R&D needed to get there. IIRC, there isn't even enough demand there to switch away from leaded fuel.
- S201 3y agoIt's not that there's not a demand for unleaded avgas, I'd say most GA pilots are ambivalent to leaded vs. unleaded fuel; they just want whatever makes the prop spin. The issues with the unleaded avgas rollout are purely bureaucratic. The FAA has been dragging its feet for literally decades to get it done. Even when we have fuels like G100UL approved which is a drop-in replacement for ~80% of the GA fleet, it still takes forever to get across the finish line.
- histriosum 3y agoIndeed. G100UL is drop in for the entire piston GA fleet, though, not 80percent.
- sokoloff 3y ago> the entire piston GA fleet All the spark-ignited piston fleet, but not the diesel piston fleet (which cannot use G100UL [nor is it needed for them as diesel is already unleaded]).
- cjrp 3y agoAren’t they using Jet-A anyway?
- sokoloff 3y agoIn practice: yes; kerosene (Jet-A) and auto diesel are very close compositions, with the former flowing better at low temperatures (as might be found high in the atmosphere). Jet-A comes out of convenient pumps already located on airports. They’re part of the piston GA fleet for which that fuel is not approved (and neither safe nor needed).
- tinus_hn 3y agoWhy would there be a demand for solving someone else’s problem, when you can just say ‘it’s aviation, change is too hard’ and people will eat it up anyway.
- treis 3y agoAutonomous flight would be the game changer. The problem with small planes is that you're splitting the pilot & FO salaries across fewer people. If you're not doing that then 20 person flights become a lot more economical.
- jfim 3y agoPlanes could be flown autonomously, as they have all of the systems to fly and land automatically. The problem is mostly about what to do if for some reason the autoland system can't work, if there are sensors that are malfunctioning, conditions aren't nominal and some non standard corrections need to be done, etc.
- JumpCrisscross 3y ago> people don't want to be a pilot these days, the exceptions are not enough to support all the R&D needed to get there There is a massive market for short-hop flights. They're just difficult to do at a good price, at scale, with human pilots. Autonomous short-hop air travel, especially when demand is periodic or occasional, ably complements or even beats rail and autonomous cars in many real-world scenarios.