3 ms·
If I'm remembering correctly, dang (the main moderator here) specifically stated that ChatGPT comments are not allowed unless it's obviously stated as such, and
by 93po 3y ago
If I'm remembering correctly, dang (the main moderator here) specifically stated that ChatGPT comments are not allowed unless it's obviously stated as such, and even then, only if ChatGPT's response is notable for the discussion.
The component of honesty for me is the social contract that we're interacting in good faith, which for me also implies that you're accurately representing yourself. The implication (and rules) for commenting here is that you're a human writing to another human. To break this basic foundation, even if assumed, is dishonest in my opinion.
I am not sure there's any social media platform that someone could ethically post ChatGPT responses to unless the entire account is clearly labeled as AI.
Your comment brings up the interesting aspect of people who have disabilities and use ChatGPT to assist in their messaging. But that's another conversation.
- peheje 3y agoOkay. I would be interested in a link for the the rule-set. I understand I'm a guest here at HN, and will respect the rules. AI can definitely help with disabilities in communication, but I think it goes much further than this. Non-native language, human bias/error, difference in culture and norms - leading to unproductive discourse, for example.. In any case, I think Q would be a perfect name for an AI producing these snarky (humanly) ego-driven comment we're both guilty of.. I see I'm loosing some internet-points in this discussion (downvotes - I don't even have that capability so can't retaliate, feel like punching bag), so unsure I feel comfortable continuing. Would like to know why people downvote. I think there's some pretty interesting topics brought up between us: honesty in online communications, AI transparency, what constitutes human interaction? However it seems HN is not the place for this, and maybe there's merit in this point, especially with the post being about Amazon Q AI. So let's end it here.
- 93po 3y agoGuidelines link is at bottom of page. I don’t have time to find dang’s comment on my phone right now. I recommend ignoring downvotes unless it’s like negative 5, innocent comments get one constantly and it’s probably people misclicking or deliberate fuzzing. I upvoted your comment just now
- mystcb 3y agoIs it this[1] that you were looking for at all? [1] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=33945628 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=33945628