24 ms·
Open specs controlled by one company are only kind of open, especially when they can iterate the spec faster than smaller competitors can keep up. Here's a doo
by tedunangst 15y ago
Open specs controlled by one company are only kind of open, especially when they can iterate the spec faster than smaller competitors can keep up. Here's a doomsday scenario with WebM. Google 1) updates the spec, 2) releases a new version of Chrome, and 3) transcodes all the videos on Youtube to the new format. The question becomes, can Google accomplish those three things faster than Apple/Microsoft/Mozilla can release updated browsers? The spec is open, even the source is open, so all you have to do is recompile and push an update to all your users whenever Google says so if you don't want them to see the "Your browser is obsolete" warning message.
- ok_craig 15y agoIs this seriously something people think would happen? Wouldn't the internet at large be up in arms at Google for this kind of behavior?
- tedunangst 15y agoLike I said, it's a sort of doomsday scenario. Then again, I've seen comments here on HN calling IE obsolete specifically because it didn't implement some HTML5 subspec that had been updated less than 48 hours before. It's hard to predict what will or will not enrage the internet.
- zobzu 15y agoWhile a horde of zombies voted you down I quite agree with that point of view. Even if it's not as black & white Google already attempts a lot of this. They basically want to be the ones to decide. There's no "consortium" it's just "lets push feat ZZ on our websites, web clients, and say its the new feat everyone has to support. Plus its open source anyway we're the good guys!" If others disagree well, so far it's been pretty much a grey area. Google keeps pushing the technologies others refused. But when Google controls even more of the market, let's say with 50%+ Chrome (they have the market already, website wise, except for FB.), there won't be a need to push anymore. It'll be Google's way or, well, nothing. Even if it's features that are released within 48H.
- drivebyacct2 15y agoThis is absurd scenario on top of infeasbily-expensively-absurd scenario. Google has no desire to do this, it would completely fly in the way of WebM's original goals. Further, the idea that YouTube could retranscode content in any sort of timeline like that...