5 ms·
I wonder when a tesla will show up in a courtroom with a situation like this. I'm not talking about autopilot. I'm talking about the continuous (past ridiculo
by m463 3y ago
I wonder when a tesla will show up in a courtroom with a situation like this.
I'm not talking about autopilot.
I'm talking about the continuous (past ridiculous) removal of physical controls from their vehicles.
For example, the original model S/X had dedicated controls for lots of functions - turn signals, gear shift, wipers, autopilot, steering wheel tilt, etc. On the steering wheel, there were two buttons and a scrollwheel on each side of the steering wheel. Press the center of the steering wheel for the horn. The door had mirror adjustment and windows + lock
Unfortunately a few critical controls were on the touchscreen - defrost front and back were big ones, but all the climate controls, and other nonsense too - all pretty much hidden with multiple taps, or small targets or both.
not all of this is bad - putting lots of detailed but non-critical settings like miles vs km are the perfect thing to have on a touchscreen.
but it needed more dedicated controls.
When the Model 3 came out, it started removing controls. There are two stalks, the turn signal also sort of controls headlights and wipers, the shifter is overloaded with autopilot.
It has two scrollwheels without buttons, you have to push them left and right.
all other controls are on the touchscreen.
It really needs dedicated controls for important things.
And then the updated model S/X came out. wow.
there are NO stalks. turn signals are touch areas on the steering wheel. so are high beams, horn, wipers. the scroll wheels do different things at different times.
shifter? nope - it guesses what direction you want to go. many more things involve
the touchscreen, like going into park. (there is also a touch drive selector in the center console, but you have to look down and touch it to wake, then to select)
Just a mess. It makes you a worse driver.
- ksjskskskkk 3y agoI'm more worried when spacex "pivots" to iron dome like products. you will get a barrage of missiles raining down from space on top of some kindergartens because the autofire ai correlated a bunch of Toyota suvs moving to the same point with terrorists
- networkchad 3y ago[dead]
- IanHalbwachs 3y agoThanks, you've just cured me of my Tesla envy entirely
- seb1204 3y agoI test drove a Hyundai ionic 6. All the levers and dials that had no use because they were set to 'Auto' made me appreciate my model 3 even more.
- noncoml 3y agoWith the big difference of AUTO mode working for Hyundai while failing miserably for Tesla, because instead of using tested an proven technology the rely solely on their cameras. For example look at the complains about the windscreen wipers not firing when they should and firing when they shouldn't: https://teslamotorsclub.com/tmc/threads/wipers-dont-work-properly-in-auto.222547/ https://teslamotorsclub.com/tmc/threads/wipers-dont-work-pro... https://teslamotorsclub.com/tmc/threads/v11-4-7-2023-7-30-auto-wipers-seem-drastically-worse.310288/ https://teslamotorsclub.com/tmc/threads/v11-4-7-2023-7-30-au... and so on.. And that's just for the wipers.
- ImaCake 3y agoIts not just Tesla. Recent Jeep models have a digital speedometer with no analog backup. From an engineering perspective these changes just introduce needless risk of complex failure for no real gain. Surely the speedometer is not the make or break cost item on a car?
- macintux 3y agoFortunately I bought my Jeep with a manual; as long as I know what gear I'm in, I know roughly how fast I'm driving by sound. But I'd be surprised if Jeep is the only example of this (outside Tesla). Surely this is the way all cars have been going for a while.
- mannykannot 3y agoThings started going downhill when the physical controls became indistinguishable by touch.
- JumpCrisscross 3y ago> these changes just introduce needless risk of complex failure for no real gain Analog speedometers are more complex and can’t be patched OTA. Eliminating them from the fleet means one less part to procure and inventory for manufacturing and service. Given the downside is losing precise speed awareness (you should still be able to judge rough speed visually—that’s the back-up), this seems like a fair trade-off. Contrast that with e.g. brake lines, where digital systems can add redundancy. (That doesn’t mean they always do.) Or physical mirrors, which add critical redundancy to cameras.
- thereddaikon 3y agoWhy do cars need to be patched OTA? Why isn't the code for something as mission critical as a car not written right before it was shipped? I never needed an ECU update on a car before? And my infotainment rarely needed one to the point where the handful of times it did get a firmware update it was handled during servicing just fine.
- hoseja 3y agoWhat sort of "physical control" would be appropriate for a radar-guided beyond-visual-range anti-air missile?
- ceejayoz 3y agohttps://www.amazon.com/STAPLES-Staples-Easy-Button/dp/B001FVI280 https://www.amazon.com/STAPLES-Staples-Easy-Button/dp/B001FV...
- kps 3y ago“A left mouse push fires it. We actually asked for a great big red button, but they wouldn't give us one.” (British submarine, not the top-level story UI) https://www.theguardian.com/media/2003/jul/17/tvnews.iraqandthemedia https://www.theguardian.com/media/2003/jul/17/tvnews.iraqand...
- dun44 3y agoTypically two different jettison mechanisms, one with a dedicated "emergency jettison" pushbutton. Also a bunch of physical HOTAS controls, from four-way switches to the small joystick under pilot's left thumb.
- mrguyorama 3y agoThe commander of the Vincennes actually had to turn at least one key to enable fire of the missile
- dav_Oz 3y agoIn the near future we will ask ourselves how people back then were doing this virtuoso thing called "driving" and be deeply grateful for the autopilot technology which Tesla was pioneering.
- immibis 3y agoMore like we'll be deeply thankful for driverless trains.
- MobileVet 3y agoThis is on point. I purposely didn’t buy a Tesla because I wanted to drive a car, not a toy. Are touch interfaces all bad? No, but in situations where heavy focus is required and the inputs are dynamically changing, they are a disaster.
- mavhc 3y agoThe left scroll wheel can: play/pause/next/previous/vol up/down in Normal mode If you press the wiper button on the steering wheel it can change wiper speed Long press is a custom function When there's a call it answers/declines, mute/unmute, and ends a call The right one actives autosteer/tacc/fsd, adjusts follow distance and max speed There's 3 buttons for left/right/high beam on the left, and on the right, buttons for wiper mode, voice, rear camera, and in the middle, horn. Not sure I need a button for steering wheel tilt, should only be when stopped. Also do I change gear so often I need a dedicated stalk? It's not a manual car. Direction/park is only done when stopped too. Does voice control not work for defrost? I'd rather have a cheaper car with less parts
- dmix 3y agoYeah I’ve always been suspect of these critiques of Teslas UI. Besides the climate control you don’t really need to tap on the tablet for anything critical to driving WHILE driving. At least that was my experience in my brief experience with a 3. I’d still add maybe another physical dial for stuff like climate, maybe even make them programmable. But that’s for convenience. I find the rare times you need to use xdrive on BMWs which is a physical dial + a few buttons just as distracting as using a tablet while driving.
- m463 3y agodefrost is the big one with me. not only is it on the touchscreen, it doesn't have a dedicated location, is hard to locate visually, then hard to hard to actually press (small target), all in a moving car and without affecting other controls. also, turn on cabin lights? flash headlights off and on? sigh.
- withinboredom 3y ago> When there's a call it answers/declines, mute/unmute, and ends a call Literally do not care about a phone call when it is raining. Hopefully, it at least has coyote time on it so when you adjust the wiper speed it will ignore a phone call. > Not sure I need a button for steering wheel tilt, should only be when stopped. I've had to adjust while driving. I don't remember for what reason, but I know I've had to do it a few times in my hundreds of thousands of miles of driving. > do I change gear so often I need a dedicated stalk? It's not a manual car. Direction/park is only done when stopped too. When you need it, you need it. I was once driving towards a non-gated, non-indicated railroad crossing in my hometown. There was only a train about once a day that went through there, but that day, there was a train that should not have been there. I slammed on the brakes, pulled the emergency brake, and threw the car into park. I stopped with less than an inch between me and the train. I also destroyed my transmission by putting it in park at high speed. Worth it.
- alexey-salmin 3y ago> I wonder when a tesla will show up in a courtroom with a situation like this. Well in this situation no one went to prison, so I guess no reason to worry for Tesla either
- ryanjshaw 3y ago> shifter? nope - it guesses what direction you want to go. I honestly thought you were making this up, or at the very least exaggerating. I can't believe it's true. It just makes no sense.
- InsomniacL 3y agoTesla have a habit of doing things that make no sense and making a success out of it regardless.
- immibis 3y agoCapitalism has a habit of doing things that make no sense and making a success out of it regardless.
- m463 3y agoThis is how many things unfortunately "work". The success comes from other things in spite of the business-selfish decisions. Who would want their TV to spy on them? Who would want an app with nag after nag after nag? businesses want it.
- thereddaikon 3y agoIIRC they got in trouble in Germany for this already because certain controls were mandated by law to be a certain way and they flaunted it. I just bought a new car and a make or break decision for me was the control layout. Too many automakers jumped on the touchscreen bandwagon. Its fine for some things like android auto. But all touchscreen all the time was stupid in star trek and stupid in real life. Having physical controls for things like the lights, wipers and hvac is critical.
- outworlder 3y agoEven in Star Trek it wasn't this horrible. The touch buttons were mostly unchanged and in the same place. See the 'pilot' consoles in the first episode all the way to the last, they are exactly the same. No weird 'modes' or different screens. It is not too farfetched to assume they had some form of haptic feedback (or something even better). They might as well feel like actual buttons to them. The real life implementation is far stupider.
- InsomniacL 3y agoI have a disaster storey to share about this. Sometimes the car does not want to go in to drive/reverse for some unknown reason. Not long after I first got my tesla, I was making a 3 point turn to go on to my driveway. I moved forward, then stopped, turned the wheel, pressed the stalk to go in to reverse, pressed the accelerator and WENT FORWARD, right in to my old car denting the door. There was no indication the car declined to go in to reverse apart from the icon on the screen. Now, Tesla released an update so the car makes an audible noise when changing to drive/reverse and a separate noise when the car refuses your instruction. It's much better but annoyingly the car still refuses quite often to go in to Drive/Reverse when you tell it to, especially when you just get in to it. I now out of habit press the gear stalk 4 or 5 times when first getting in to drive it.
- outworlder 3y agoI wonder if this issue is behind all the reports of people randomly crashing into weird obstacles. Often it's claimed that they are confusing the break and accelerator pedals and one pedal driving is cited. But there's a bunch of other EVs that also have one pedal driving and they seem fine. Mind you, my (much cheaper) EV will beep at me if I try to engage a mode and it refuses. Be it forward, reverse or park. But in the 'ready to drive' state it has never refused reverse or drive; I don't know why it ever would.
- mrguyorama 3y ago>annoyingly the car still refuses quite often to go in to Drive/Reverse when you tell it to How the everloving F** does this even happen? I cannot imagine an ICE car "refusing" switching gears. I know electric vehicles don't manage driving direction through physical gears and linkages like ICE vehicles but this feels like an absurd regression.
- InsomniacL 3y agoJust to be clear, I prefer my Tesla to my ICE car and I enjoy driving it as much as my Kawasaki ZX10R.. The Tesla will refuse to go in to gear for genuine reasons, such as: - refuses forward/reverse if the car is moving too fast in opposite direction - refuses forward/reverse if the car just turned on and foot isn't on brake I haven't worked out what the other reasons are though. The vast majority are when I'm in a rush, I get in sometimes have to press the stalk about 4 times (in 2 seconds) for drive. It could be because my seatbelt isn't on yet, or the car needs a small amount or time to boot up. To be fair I'm moving off faster (even pressing the stalk down a few times) than my ICE car, and Tesla adding the Chimes really helped.
- gosub100 3y ago> there are NO stalks. turn signals are touch areas on the steering wheel. so are high beams, horn, wipers I didn't realize how important wipers were till last winter. I was on a 2-lane road at highway speed going into a turn. There had been light snow the previous day which was thawed on the roads, so it was wet and muddy conditions. A truck in the oncoming lane either hit a puddle or otherwise deposited a large splash of muddy water on my windshield instantly, and due to the turn coming up I had to see where I was going. I had about 1 second to find the wipers (it was someone else's vehicle) or I would have gone off the road or into oncoming traffic. That's not the time to hastily search for the wiper button on a touch screen!
- rootusrootus 3y agoI'm not a fan of the removal of the stalks, but this deserves clarification. On the 2017-2023 Model 3, there's a button at the end of the left stalk that immediately activates the wiper. It's basically a mist button, which is also common on most every other car I've driven. So you can always get the wipers to activate instantly without getting anywhere near the touchscreen. On the 2024 Model 3, with no stalks, there is a steering wheel button on the right that serves the same function. Push for mist, hold for wash. Same as the button on the pre-2024 model. Stalkless is probably still going to be a deal killer for me, but still.
- gosub100 3y agoThank you for clarifying. I just felt like sharing because I had no idea that windshield wipers could suddenly be as safety-critical as the steering or brakes, despite 24 years of accident-free driving. (Of course if it's raining, you need them, but every time I've driven in the rain there's still enough wiggle-room with partial visibility to pull over safely)
- m463 3y agowhat I hate is that stalks, even overloaded with too many functions, were in a specific place you could reach for and activate. the steering wheel buttons move depending on which way you are steering. maybe not a big deal when the radio volume is wrong when backing up. Critical when you need to use the horn when backing out of a parking space.
- steeve 3y agoThank you.
- Stratoscope 3y agoThis makes me appreciate my Kia EV6. One side of the steering wheel has buttons for driving functions: cruise control, following distance, lane assist, etc. The other side has audio controls for radio channel selection and volume, voice input, start/end phone call, and a customizable button that I set to record a voice memo. Behind the wheel are a pair of regenerative braking paddles that work much like the paddle shifters on some gas cars: left paddle increases regen, right paddle decreases it. That left button comes in handy on the rare occasion when I may want to slow down in a hurry without lighting up the brake lights. (I will leave it to the reader to speculate on why I may want to do that) The drive mode button (eco/standard/sport/winter) is below the horn button. Two stalks for headlight/turn signal/etc. and wiper/washer control. Dual screens: one in front of the driver with driving info: speed and speed limit, how much battery you're using or regening, etc. A touchscreen in the center for infotainment stuff. Below the center screen is a dual mode touch panel for climate controls or radio/map/nav controls. I just leave this in climate mode. Physical knobs at each end of this panel that change roles for the two modes. The left side of this panel has front/rear defrost, recirculation, and auto climate which remain there in both modes. The center console has physical buttons to turn the EV on or off, a physical R/N/D knob, and physical buttons for parking camera/auto parking and a couple of related features. At the front of the center console are dedicated buttons for driver/passenger seat heating/ventilation and steering wheel heat. Oddly, these are touch buttons in my GT-Line but physical buttons (better!) in the lower-end Wind trim. In Australia the GT-Line keeps the physical buttons here. Behind the steering wheel next to the door are physical buttons for panel illumination level, charge door and rear hatch opening, and a couple of other things. The driver door has traditional buttons for mirror adjustment, lock/unlock, windows, and child lock. After driving gas cars all my life, the first time I got in an EV6 it felt very comfortable, like a real car and not a science experiment.
- FearlessNebula 3y agoAnton Yelchin was killed due to traumatic asphyxiation when he thought he parked his Jeep and got out of the car and it then rolled into him and crushed him against a gate. Arguably the blame falls on GM for building one of those stateless shifters that always pops back to the center.