8 ms·
Backlash over fake female speakers shuts down developer conference
- varjag 3y agoThe russian guy comes up with russian names for his sockpuppet chick accounts. Is that to explain away the grammar?
- throwaway74354 3y agoIt's not exactly correct to call every ex-Eastern Block actor russian by default. The guy's name spelling is Latvian and one of the speakers' surname is Ukrainian.
- varjag 3y agoHis name is russian in Latvian transcription, and it would also be incorrect to refer to the unintegrated, very pro-russian diaspora there as generically "ex-Eastern Block".
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- quit-the-woke 3y ago[flagged]
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- wruza 3y agoSo they got what they wanted. A store is inclusive because everyone can enter it. A conference is inclusive only if you drag every type of person in by force, faking it if it didn’t work out. “Otherwise it’s not inclusive and I’m not participating”. Isn’t that pure nonsense.
- woodruffw 3y agoI'm having trouble parsing this comment. Who got what they wanted?
- pelagicAustral 3y ago[flagged]
- nielsbot 3y agoHow do you know their motivation?
- soco 3y agoSo we are all missing the point that the organizer LIED around and he's being rightfully punished for that?
- pelagicAustral 3y agoNo, I don't think people are, at large, missing the point. I think there is some more reflecting to do about the article in that pretty much points out the lengths people are going to go so they can conform to the CURRENT_THING. Almost like virtue signaling is actually a thing.
- mcphage 3y agoWeird that he was willing go to the lengths of “inventing fake women speakers”, but not willing to go the much shorter lengths of “inviting real women to speak”.
- soco 3y agoSo basically NOT conforming to the CURRENT_THING at all. Yet still we don't blame them for such blatant lies... maybe because we actually think it's the right way to do things in life - lie and cheat the rules we don't agree with? I know one can even get elected president like this, but it's definitely not what I'd call "role model" behaviour, to put it mildly.
- phpisthebest 3y ago>> IP logs from a forum for programmers obtained by 404 Media I am more interested in what forums is turning over their IP logs to the media, what the privacy policy was for that forum, and if other members of that forum know this is happening
- paulgb 3y agoIf you create sockpuppets on a forum for the purpose of fraudulently establishing a fake identity to sell conference tickets, I don’t think you have an expectation of privacy with respect to server logs that establish that. Same as if you rob a bodega, you don’t expect privacy rights over the CCTV footage.
- thih9 3y ago> Same as if you rob a bodega, you don’t expect privacy rights over the CCTV footage. This comparison is inaccurate. The bodega wasn’t robbed. This is a media reporter asking a bodega for CCTV footage because they are investigating one of the customers.
- jdiff 3y agoOne of the customers who has been thrown out of the bodega and banned on multiple instances. At least one of which he came back after wearing a fake mustache.
- j16sdiz 3y agoI guess CCTV footage won't go to media either, or do they?
- veeti 3y agoThis is absolutely not the case in many European locales. For instance, a gas station owner can be fined for infringing the privacy of a shoplifter by publishing CCTV footage [1]. [1] https://www-mtvuutiset-fi.translate.goog/artikkeli/huoltoasema-julkaisi-polttoainevarkaaksi-epaillyn-kuvan-ja-nimen-facebookissa-laitonta-totesi-hovioikeus-loukkasi-epaillyn-yksityisyytta/7648586?_x_tr_sl=auto&_x_tr_tl=en&_x_tr_hl=en-US&_x_tr_pto=wapp https://www-mtvuutiset-fi.translate.goog/artikkeli/huoltoase...
- dom96 3y agoThe craziest thing about this is that apparently refusing to participate in a conference that faked female speakers is now "woke".
- pelagicAustral 3y agoThat was not my take at all... I took that the conference faked being woke (by being inclusive) in order to grab the attention of better male speakers. Which is a pretty good joke because it works at some many levels.
- ghusto 3y ago> "To spell it out why this conference generated fake women speakers," Orosz alleges, it was "because the organizer wants big names and it probably seemed like an easy way to address their diversity concerns. Incredibly lazy." In an ideal world, Orosz thought about that sentence immediately after uttering it, and had a realisation. Of course she didn't, though :(
- rob74 3y agoGergély is the Hungarian version of Gregor and therefore usually male - so "he" or "they", but definitely not "she"...
- self_awareness 3y ago> "To spell it out why this conference generated fake women speakers," Orosz alleges, it was "because the organizer wants big names and it probably seemed like an easy way to address their diversity concerns. Incredibly lazy." Well this is what you get if you impose such artificial requirements like forced diversity. Edit: People are offended like if there aren't any other groups of people who base their business models on diversity. This guy has done it poorly, so it's visible, hundreds of others do it better, and you don't even notice this happens.
- Zetobal 3y agoNope it's absolutely a YOU problem if you decide to defraud your clients and your speakers. No matter the reason if you are the one defrauding people it's your fucking fault.
- striking 3y agoIs it "forced diversity" if speakers would just rather not speak at a conference that doesn't make an effort to align with their ideals i.e. doesn't attempt to be diverse?
- vidarh 3y agoNo, this is what you get if someones response to speakers making a choice about the kind of events they want to speak at is fraud instead of addressing the concerns in an honest way. He has no inherent right to expect speakers to speak at his event. It doesn't matter if they expect a diverse lineup or a bowl of M&M's with all the brown ones picked out - he has the choice of complying with their requirements or finding someone else. Or, I guess, resorting to lies and deceit and getting called out for it.
- uwagar 3y agoso top male speakers are attracted by fake female speakers. what does that say about them top male speakers?
- striking 3y ago... That they prefer to speak in spaces that make an effort to be diverse, in solidarity with those from underrepresented groups? Why take the least charitable view?
- raxxorraxor 3y agoThat the absence of people with particular attributes in a group is evidence of discrimination is a least charitable view that forms the axiom of policies that discriminate on lines like race or gender.
- raziel2p 3y ago"Attracted by" seems disingenuous. More likely, top speakers (including male) want to know that the conference(s) they talk at put efforts into diversity. The same might also go for attendees.
- footy 3y agothat they care about increasing diversity of the spaces where they're invited to talk. I suppose it also says that they trusted the conference organizers and didn't do enough legwork to verify the fake speakers weren't fake, but it seems uncharitable to blame someone for that. Most people would have taken the claims at face value.
- tyingq 3y ago"He also confirmed that speakers like him have rules for participating in conferences, including only joining inclusive speaker lineups."
- gear54rus 3y agothat they're straight?
- olalonde 3y agoFaking speakers is pretty shitty but at the same time, it is disheartening to acknowledge that in 2023, there are still people who care about the gender or race of speakers.
- dash2 3y agoI ran a workshop a few years back, and some female speakers wrote to me (collectively) to ask that I include more women, along with suggested names. Given that in academia there is already probably pro-female bias in hiring, I think this was bad, and in retrospect I should not have accepted it.
- raziel2p 3y agoI have to read a lot between the lines here so correct me if I misunderstand what happened. You ran a workshop, in the academic field, which tends to hire more women than men these days (your words). Your workshop still managed to be male dominated, despite being in a female-dominated field, and women complained about that?
- olalonde 3y ago> which tends to hire more women than men these days (your words) They said there was a "pro-female bias in hiring", which does not necessarily mean it's a female-dominated field. In fact, it's often the male-dominated fields that have pro-female bias because there is often a desire to increase the female ratio.
- peteradio 3y agoAcademia is still male dominated in many fields by a wide margin but the latest hiring may be heavily biased towards female and yet it has not made a significant dent (my interpretation).
- dash2 3y agoYou are indeed mistaken. The field isn't female-dominated. The claim was not that academic hiring hires more women, but that it is biased in favour of hiring women, which isn't the same. And even if it hired more women, that wouldn't make it female-dominated - a stock is not the same as a flow.
- Krasnol 3y agoIt wouldn't surprise me to see Sizovs presented by certain triggered groups as a poor hero who, faced with the necessities of the evil woke culture had to lie.
- sandworm101 3y agoFew know how hard it is to organize these things. Getting speakers lined up isn't easy, especially those with any reputation. They hum an haw, provarikating until the last minute. At the same time you have to put money down on venues. It is always desperate until the last minute. So it is no surprise that, faced with pullouts, organizers did something stupid.
- striking 3y agoFrom the article, just in case you're really taking the organizer's story at face value: > Orosz alleged that DevTernity's addition of Boyko to the lineup was "not a one-off." He posted what he said is evidence from past years of more fake speakers that were advertised at both DevTernity and other events organized by Sizovs, and 404 Media also claims that a hugely popular female tech influencer Instagram account called Coding Unicorn may have been secretly managed by Sizovs. Do you really think his story holds up if he's been running a catfishing account for five years?
- rsynnott 3y agoPer the article, they appear to have done this frequently, for years.
- jwestbury 3y agoIf you read the rest of the article, it seems fairly clear that one of the fake women advertised as speaking at the conference is a fictional persona created by the conference's organiser, and has been run as a social media presence for several years. It's hard to see this as an innocent mistake, in context.
- that_guy_iain 3y agoI understand why people want to talk at conference that have a diverse array of speakers. However, the fact there is an extreme shortage of a specific gender shouldn't really fall on conference organisers. One conference that was blasted for only having one or two women speakers was organised by a women who pointed out that every women who applied got to speak. It's got to the point from what I've noticed from conference organisers talking on Twitter/X in the past the only way they can get women speakers in a decent amount is for them to approach women who don't give talks and invite them to talk. That is a bit worrying since anyone who has given a talk will know, your first time is completely terrible. So conference organisers are sometimes putting on a lower quality conference to tick boxes.
- raziel2p 3y agoGood. We don't need every conference to be of top quality speaker or content wise, the same way companies don't always need to hire all the top tech talent - especially if it comes at cost of inclusiveness and diversity.
- mcphage 3y agoThis was a conference where people don’t apply to speak, you only got to speak by invitation. So that excuse doesn’t work here.
- vidarh 3y agoIs there an extreme shortage? Or is there an extreme shortage of women who applies to speak because they're not used to seeing many women speak and assume they wouldn't get a slot? I genuinely don't know, but I have met enough women in tech with speaking experience as a total introvert that I do find it astounding that someone making a living of arranging events don't have a sufficient network to be able to line up some women as speakers. Makes it very hard to think this doesn't reflect their attitudes. > It's got to the point from what I've noticed from conference organisers talking on Twitter/X in the past the only way they can get women speakers in a decent amount is for them to approach women who don't give talks and invite them to talk. Then they should do that. As a man, of the times I've been speaking in public-ish contexts in my life, I've volunteered or applied less than half. I'm not at all surprised it takes work to line up speakers, and more work to line up speakers of any group that has a history of being underrepresented in this field. If you expect every speaker you sign up to be drawn from applicants, it's also not just diversity you throw over-board, but you lose out on a whole lot of perspectives from people who for other reasons aren't really that interested in speaking, or are too busy with other things, but who might be willing to if asked. > That is a bit worrying since anyone who has given a talk will know, your first time is completely terrible. The way to fix that is to ensure more women get a first chance to hold a talk. If they don't want that to be at their conference, then try to work with user groups and the like to find women who have held talks there, or arrange events to provide a feed. Once is understandable - people may well not realize what is needed to fix the problem. But if they then don't act, or if they lie and deceive people about it, it's another matter. This reminds me of when my ex worked for a major investment bank where she as a black woman was promptly put on a "diversity board" to figure out how they could fix their diversity without actually changing the one thing that made fixing their diversity impossible: They heavily weighed in their hiring candidates from certain schools which skewed significantly white and male, to the point that even if they hired every black person and every female from those schools entire graduating classes, they'd still have a diversity problem. They did not want to hear that. They wanted nice quotes for their website and some token photos (and eventually got a significant bill for settling employment law cases instead) The point is that if you genuinely want to address diversity, and your applicant pool isn't diverse, then you need to look beyond your applicant pool. If you choose not to, then you don't really care about addressing diversity; in that case, you're just trying to do enough to be able to throw your hands up, and it's in that case entirely fair for people to judge the organizers accordingly.
- guessmyname 3y agoMy suggestion to enhance diversity among conference presenters: each top presenter could bring a “plus one” from an underrepresented group to co-present. Alternatively, they could opt to forfeit their spot and locate someone in their professional network who can represent both a minority group and, if possible, deliver the original presentation.
- pelagicAustral 3y agoLet's make even better. Let's use a roulette type of device with three wheels, one inside the other. The center wheel is gender, the middle wheel is race, and the third wheel is underrepresented jobs in tech. That way I can have a plus-one that is a gender fluid, Berber, truck driver.
- ksjskskskkk 3y ago[flagged]
- vidarh 3y agoIt's not the conference presenters' duty to fix a problem that will only be there if the organizers can't be bothered to try.
- colpabar 3y ago"Ok everyone, here's John Doe, and his token black guy!"
- rvz 3y agoGrifters gonna grift. We must accelerate diversity with AI.
- fzeroracer 3y agoI feel like I'm going insane with some of the takes here. The creator of the conference created catfishing accounts devoted to advertising the event, they advertised and sold their conference as being 'diverse' knowing full well that they're lying and the responses is 'oh, the poor organizer had to commit fraud to survive'? What? If they're lying about whos going to the conference and speaking, then what else are they lying about? They've been doing this charade for years now. Regardless of your opinions on diversity I would fucking hope that people would agree committing fraud is bad.
- rsynnott 3y agoIt was also an unusual conference in that they didn't do CFPs; _all_ the speakers were recruited. Very odd setup.
- actualwitch 3y ago[flagged]
- yjftsjthsd-h 3y ago> The quality of discussion on hn has been steadily declining for a while. I reckon we are at reddit level at this point, with no end in sight. https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html > Please don't post comments saying that HN is turning into Reddit.
- fallingknife 3y agoSeems like the lesson here is that nobody wants to go to the party unless they know who else is going to be there. Makes kind of a chicken and egg problem. Not surprised that this type of fakery is going on. Reminds me of VC rounds where nobody wants to be the first in and if you get a big name everybody FOMOs in. Not surprising to me that the same guy who runs the conference also runs influencer accounts because it seems to be the same skill. Of course everybody expects those to be fake. Maybe we should feel the same way about conferences, because they sure seem that way to me.
- vidarh 3y ago> Seems like the lesson here is that nobody wants to go to the party unless they know who else is going to be there. Makes kind of a chicken and egg problem. This may indeed be tricky, but if it was "just" that he'd been sneaky about it to get the ball rolling and he subsequently had fixed the issue by replacing the fake women with real women before starting to sign up attendees it'd have been a lot easier to have sympathy.
- ChrisArchitect 3y agoRelated discussions from a few days ago: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=38435481 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=38435481 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=38439794 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=38439794